758 S.W.2d 446 (Mo. 1988)
The plaintiff tenant rented an apartment on the third floor of a building owned by the defendant landlord at 5560 Cates in St. Louis in March 1984.1 At the time she took possession, the inside latch on the rear southside window was broken, permitting entry from the adjoining fire escape.2 A burglar had previously gained access to the apartment through the front balcony doors, which were also reachable from the fire escape, and the landlord was aware of this incident.3
The plaintiff reported the broken window latch to the landlord on multiple occasions and informed him of her concerns for her safety.4 She noted that she had been assigned to collect rents from other tenants and that the area was known for violent crimes.5
In September 1984, an intruder entered her apartment through the unsecured window and committed a sexual assault against her.6 The plaintiff brought suit against the landlord, claiming negligence in three specific respects: failing to install a lock on the rear window after repeated requests, failing to secure the gate in the fence surrounding the backyard, and failing to take precautions to prevent easy access to the fire escape.7 The trial court sustained the defendant's motion to dismiss the petition for failure to state a claim.8
The plaintiff appealed to the Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District.9 That court transferred the case to the Missouri Supreme Court because two similar cases were pending before it.10 After deciding Madden v. C & K Barbecue Carryout, Inc. and Decker v. Gramex Corp. in 1988, the Supreme Court addressed this appeal.11
Whether the trial court erred in sustaining the defendant's motion to dismiss the petition?12
A petition in a negligence case must state facts demonstrating a duty owing from the defendant to the plaintiff, a breach of duty, and damages as a result.13 Trial courts should hesitate to dismiss cases at the pleading stage unless it is clear that no claim for liability is presented.14 The owner of an apartment building has a recognized duty to use due care to make common premises safe, as against foreseeable risks.15
Yes. In March 1984, the plaintiff tenant took possession of an apartment on the third floor of a building owned by the defendant landlord at 5560 Cates in St. Louis. Upon arrival, she discovered that the inside latch on the rear southside window was broken, which would allow an intruder to enter from the adjoining fire escape. A prior burglary had occurred through the front balcony doors, also accessible from the fire escape, and the landlord knew about that incident.
The plaintiff repeatedly reported the broken latch to the landlord and expressed her fears for her safety, noting her assignment to collect rents from other tenants and the neighborhood's history of violent crimes. Subsequently, in September 1984, an intruder entered through the unsecured window and sexually assaulted her. The plaintiff then filed suit alleging negligence in three respects, including the failure to install a lock on the rear window after requests, the failure to secure the backyard fence gate, and the failure to prevent easy access to the fire escape. The trial court granted the defendant's motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim.
On appeal, the Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District, transferred the case to the Missouri Supreme Court due to pending similar cases. After resolving Madden v. C & K Barbecue Carryout, Inc. and Decker v. Gramex Corp. in 1988, the Supreme Court took up this matter. The petition alleges the essential elements because the landlord had a duty to make the common fire escape safe against foreseeable criminal entry, he breached it by not taking precautions, and the plaintiff suffered damages from the assault.16
The trial court erred in dismissing the petition at the pleading stage.17
Related opinions on this issue
Judge Donnelly would have allowed the case to proceed only if the jury could allocate fault among the landlord, the tenant, and the criminal actor under a pure comparative fault system, holding each responsible only in proportion to his fault.18 The principal opinion holds that a landlord may be held liable to a tenant for criminal acts of a third person.19 His bottom line is that he dissents because the court did not adopt comparative fault in this context.20
Judge Robertson argues that the traditional duty to maintain common areas does not support liability here because the fire escape is not dangerous in itself and the crime did not occur in the common area.21 He contends that no special relationship exists between landlord and tenant like that of innkeeper and guest, and the tenant had superior knowledge and ability to secure her own window.22 He diverges from the majority by concluding that the landlord does not owe a duty to protect against criminal acts via the fire escape on these pleadings, and would affirm the dismissal of the petition.23
Whether the plaintiff's petition alleges facts sufficient to proceed beyond the pleading stage on claims arising from the assault?24
Yes. The petition details the landlord's knowledge of the broken window latch and prior burglary through the fire escape, the repeated reports by the plaintiff, and the failure to secure access to the common fire escape, which proximately caused the assault and resulting injuries.27 The landlord knew or should have known of the dangerous condition of the fire escape by reason of which a criminal intruder could obtain easy access to the plaintiff's apartment.28 The fire escape is part of the common premises under the landlord's control, and the petition alleges that the defendant failed to take available precautions to deny an intruder easy access to the fire escape.2930
The petition alleges facts sufficient to proceed beyond the pleading stage.31
Whether a landlord owes a duty to tenants to use due care to make common premises safe against foreseeable risks of criminal intrusion?32
The owner of an apartment building has a recognized duty to use due care to make common premises safe, as against foreseeable risks. If a private apartment can be entered through a window, injury to the occupants is foreseeable.33 There is no logical reason why a dangerous condition of common premises, proximately causing injury on private premises, could not be the occasion for liability.34
Yes. The fire escape is part of the common premises under the landlord's control.35 The landlord knew or should have known of the dangerous condition by reason of which a criminal intruder could obtain easy access to the plaintiff's apartment.36 The petition alleges that the defendant failed to take available precautions to deny an intruder easy access to the fire escape.
If a private apartment can be entered through a window, injury to the occupants is foreseeable. There is no logical reason why a dangerous condition of common premises, proximately causing injury on private premises, could not be the occasion for liability.
A landlord owes a duty to tenants to use due care to make common premises safe against foreseeable risks of criminal intrusion.37