269 U.S. 20 (1925)
Thomas Agnello, Frank Agnello, Stephen Alba, Antonio Centorino and Thomas Pace were indicted in the District Court, Eastern District of New York, under § 37, Criminal Code, c. 321, 35 Stat. 1088, 1096, for a conspiracy to violate the Harrison Act, c. 1, 38 Stat. 785, as amended by §§1006, 1007, 1008 of the Revenue Act of 1918, c. 18, 40 Stat. 1057, 1130.1 The indictment charges that defendants conspired together to sell cocaine without having registered with the Collector of Internal Revenue and without having paid the prescribed tax.2 The overt acts charged are that defendants had cocaine in their possession, solicited the sale of it, met in the home of defendant Alba at 138 Union Street, Brooklyn, and made arrangements for the purpose of selling it, brought a large quantity of it to that place, and sold it in violation of the Act.3 The jury found defendants guilty. Each was sentenced to serve two years in the penitentiary and to pay a fine of $5,000. The Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment.4
The evidence introduced by the Government was sufficient to warrant a finding of the following facts: Pasquale Napolitano and Nunzio Dispenza, employed by government revenue agents for that purpose, went to the home of Alba, Saturday, January 14, 1922, and there offered to buy narcotics from Alba and Centorino.5 Alba gave them some samples. They arranged to come again on Monday following. They returned at the time agreed. Six revenue agents and a city policeman followed them and remained on watch outside.6 Alba left the house and returned with Centorino. They did not then produce any drug. After discussion and the refusal of Napolitano and Dispenza to go to Centorino’s house to get the drug, Centorino went to fetch it. He was followed by some of the agents. He first went to his own house, 172 Columbia Street; thence to 167 Columbia Street, — one part of which was a grocery store belonging to Pace and Thomas Agnello, and another part of which, connected with the grocery store, was the home of Frank Agnello and Pace.7 In a short time, Centorino, Pace and the Agnellos came out of the last mentioned place, and all went to Alba’s house. Looking through the windows, those on watch saw Frank Agnello produce a number of small packages for delivery to Napolitano and saw the latter hand over money to Alba. Upon the apparent consummation of the sale, the agents rushed in and arrested all the defendants.8 They found some of the packages on the table where the transaction took place and found others in the pockets of Frank Agnello. All contained cocaine. On searching Alba, they found the money given him by Napolitano.9
And as a part of its case in chief, the Government offered testimony tending to show that, while some of the revenue agents were taking the defendants to the police station, the others and the city policeman went to the home of Centorino and searched it but did not find any narcotics; that they then went to 167 Columbia Street and searched it, and in Frank Agnello’s bedroom found a can of cocaine which was produced and offered in evidence.10 The evidence was excluded on the ground that the search and seizure were made without a search warrant.11 In defense, Centorino and others gave testimony to the effect that the packages of cocaine which were brought to and seized in Alba’s house at the time of the arrests had been furnished to Centorino by Dispenza to induce an apparent sale of cocaine to Napolitano, that is, to incite crime or acts having the appearance of crime, for the purpose of entrapping and punishing defendants.12 Centorino testified that, after leaving Napolitano and Dispenza with Alba at the latter’s home, he went to his own house and got the packages of cocaine which had been given him by Dispenza and took them to 167 Columbia Street, and there gave them to Frank Agnello to be taken to Alba’s house.13 Frank Agnello testified on direct examination that he received the packages from Centorino but that he did not know their contents, and that he would not have carried them if he had known that they contained cocaine or narcotics.14
On cross examination, he said that he had never seen narcotics. Then, notwithstanding objection by defendants, the prosecuting attorney produced the can of cocaine which the Government claimed was seized in Agnello’s bedroom and asked him whether he had ever seen it.15 He said he had not, and specifically stated he had never seen it in his house. In rebuttal, over objections of defendants, the Government was permitted to put in the evidence of the search and seizure of the can of cocaine in Frank Agnello’s room, which theretofore had been offered and excluded.16
Whether search of the house of Frank Agnello and seizure of the cocaine there found, without a search warrant, violated the Fourth Amendment?17
The Fourth Amendment secures the people against unreasonable searches and seizures of their houses and effects. A search without a warrant is unreasonable unless it qualifies as a narrow exception, such as a search incident to a lawful arrest. That exception permits officers to search the person arrested and the immediate place of arrest to locate weapons, means of escape, or evidence connected to the crime. The authority does not extend to other premises several blocks away once the suspects are in custody elsewhere and the offense is complete.18
Yes. The revenue agents arrested all defendants at Alba's house at 138 Union Street after observing the apparent sale of cocaine packages. After taking the defendants into custody and while transporting them to the police station, other agents proceeded several blocks to 167 Columbia Street, entered Frank Agnello's bedroom without a warrant, and seized a can of cocaine.19 The established facts contain no indication that any warrant had been obtained or even sought.20
The government offered no other justification, such as exigent circumstances or consent.21 The trial court initially excluded the evidence precisely because the search lacked a warrant.22 These concrete circumstances establish that the search and seizure of the can of cocaine from Frank Agnello's home violated the Fourth Amendment.23
The search of Frank Agnello's house and the seizure of the cocaine found there therefore violated the Fourth Amendment.24
Whether the admission of evidence of such search and seizure violated the Fifth Amendment?25
When a search or seizure violates the Fourth Amendment, the Fifth Amendment forbids the government from using the evidence thereby obtained to incriminate the person whose rights were violated. A defendant need not first move for the return of the property. This rule applies when the facts showing the constitutional violation are undisputed and the defendant had no prior notice that the government possessed the item or intended to offer it.26
Yes. Frank Agnello testified on direct examination only that he received packages from Centorino without knowing their contents. On cross-examination the prosecutor produced the can seized from his bedroom and asked whether Agnello had ever seen it; Agnello denied any knowledge of it.27 Over objection the government then introduced the previously excluded evidence of the warrantless search in rebuttal.28
The established facts show that Agnello had never been informed before trial that agents had searched his home or found cocaine there.29 Because the violation was clear from the government's own witnesses and Agnello maintained he never possessed the can, he was not required to make a preliminary motion for its return.30 The Fifth Amendment therefore barred use of the evidence against him.31
Admission of the evidence obtained through the unlawful search and seizure therefore violated Frank Agnello's rights under the Fifth Amendment.32
Whether the admission of evidence obtained through the unlawful search and seizure requires reversal of the judgments against all defendants?33
A constitutional error requires reversal only when it affects the substantial rights of the complaining party. Evidence admitted in violation of one defendant's Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights does not automatically prejudice codefendants when the trial court limits its use to the defendant whose rights were violated and the evidence is not attributable to the others.34
No. The trial court expressly instructed the jury that the can of cocaine and the circumstances of its seizure could be considered only against Frank Agnello.35 The other defendants never requested a broader limiting instruction and do not claim any erroneous instruction was given.36 The established facts demonstrate that the packages seized at Alba's house were carried there by Frank Agnello at Centorino's direction.37 Whether Agnello knew their contents is irrelevant to the liability of his codefendants.38
His act of delivery is chargeable to them regardless.39 Consequently the improperly admitted evidence did not prejudice the substantial rights of Thomas Agnello, Stephen Alba, Antonio Centorino, or Thomas Pace.40
The erroneous admission of the evidence therefore requires reversal only of the judgment against Frank Agnello; the judgments against the remaining defendants may stand.41