159 N.E. 173 (1927)
The plaintiff, Allegheny College, is an institution of liberal learning at Meadville, Pennsylvania.1 In June 1921, a drive was in progress to secure for it an additional endowment of $1,250,000.2 An appeal to contribute to this fund was made to Mary Yates Johnston of Jamestown, New York.3
In response thereto, she signed and delivered on June 15, 1921, the following writing: a document promising to pay $5,000 to the order of the Treasurer of Allegheny College thirty days after her death, with the proceeds to be added to the endowment or used to educate students preparing for the ministry under the name of the Mary Yates Johnston Memorial Fund, subject to the condition that the provisions of her will then extant be first met. On the reverse side appeared the indorsement naming the fund and stating the will condition.4
The sum of $1,000 was paid upon account in December 1923 while the promisor was alive, and the college set the money aside to be held as a scholarship fund for the benefit of students preparing for the ministry.5 Later, in July 1924, the promisor gave notice to the college that she repudiated the promise.6 Upon the expiration of thirty days following her death, this action was brought against the executor of her will to recover the unpaid balance.7
The case was heard at Trial Term, which rendered judgment, followed by review in the Appellate Division, before reaching the Court of Appeals.8
Whether Mary Yates Johnston's written pledge created an enforceable obligation against her estate in favor of Allegheny College?9
A charitable subscription is enforceable as a bilateral contract when the promisee, upon accepting a partial payment, impliedly assumes a duty at the promisor's request to perform acts necessary to perpetuate the donor's name in a memorial fund, thereby supplying the consideration through a return promise.10
Yes. The established facts show that Mary Yates Johnston's pledge expressly conditioned the gift on its being known as the Mary Yates Johnston Memorial Fund for educating students preparing for the ministry.11 When Allegheny College accepted the $1,000 payment in December 1923 and set the sum aside as a scholarship fund, it subjected itself to the implied duty to couple the donor's name with announcements of the scholarship in its circulars and customary communications. This assumption of duty occurred at the promisor's implied request as reflected in the pledge terms naming the memorial fund.12
The resulting return promise by the college created a bilateral agreement with mutual obligations.13 The facts further establish that the college could not accept the partial payment while remaining free to treat the fund as anonymous, as that would thwart the purpose of the subscription and constitute a failure of consideration.14 The longing for posthumous remembrance supplies a sufficient benefit to the promisor to support enforcement of the residue.15
Mary Yates Johnston's written pledge created an enforceable obligation against her estate in favor of Allegheny College.16
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Andrews, J.
Kellogg dissents, concluding that the pledge was a gift rather than an offer to contract.17 He states that the language on the reverse side expressed only an expectation or wish and did not request the college to perform any act through which the sum might bear the stated title.18 The considerations recited in the pledge were inadequate at law, and no sufficient quid pro quo was exacted from the donee.19
Even treating the pledge as an offer for a unilateral contract, Kellogg reasons that the requested acts were never performed because the donation was not to take effect until after the donor's death, at which point the offer was withdrawn.20 He maintains that a promise by the college could be implied but that such a promise was not the acceptance of an offer giving rise to a contract, since the donor stipulated for acts rather than promises.21 Kellogg rejects any expansion of consideration doctrine through promissory estoppel in this context and would hold that no contract was formed.22