138 Wash. 423, 244 P. 700 (1926)
The respondent Allen resided as a tenant in the Argonne Apartments located in Seattle for about one year leading up to April 29, 1924.1 Hannaford owned and operated those apartments.2 On that date Allen prepared to relocate to a different apartment house, and transfer men arrived to handle her furniture.3
Hannaford then appeared carrying a pistol and warned the transfer men that she would shoot them full of holes should they move any of Allen's belongings.4 Moments later Hannaford stood a few feet from Allen, aimed the pistol directly at her face, and threatened to shoot.5 Although Hannaford conceded holding the pistol, she maintained that she neither aimed it at Allen nor uttered any threats.6
Allen filed suit to recover damages based on the assault.7 A trial before the court and jury produced a verdict of $750 for Allen.8 The trial court denied post-verdict motions for judgment notwithstanding the verdict and for a new trial before entering judgment on the verdict.9 Hannaford took an appeal from the resulting judgment.10
Whether pointing a pistol at another person and threatening to shoot constitutes an assault when there is no evidence that the pistol was loaded?11
An assault occurs when the defendant points a pistol at the plaintiff in a threatening manner, creating a reasonable fear of personal injury in the mind of the plaintiff, even if there is no showing that the pistol was loaded. The presence or absence of an assault depends more upon the apprehension created in the mind of the person assaulted than upon the undisclosed intentions of the person committing the assault.12
Yes. Although Hannaford denied pointing the pistol or making threats, the jury was entitled to believe Allen's version of the events based on the evidence presented at trial.13 The apprehension created in Allen's mind was reasonable because, for all she knew, the pistol could have been loaded and could have caused her immediate death.14 This security against unlawful assaults is one of the most important objects of civilized society, and Allen had a right to live without being put in fear of personal harm.15
Pointing the pistol at Allen and threatening to shoot her constituted an assault even without evidence that the pistol was loaded.16
Whether a verdict of $750 is excessive in an action for assault arising from the pointing of a pistol and threats to shoot?17
A verdict is not excessive if it compensates for the mental distress and nervous condition resulting from the assault, as mental distress is a material portion of the injury, and comparison to other cases like a $2,000 verdict for a similar but more aggravated assault supports the amount.18
No. The verdict of $750 is not excessive because there was evidence as to the immediate effect upon Allen of the pointing of the pistol at her, with the threat to shoot, and her nervous condition thereafter as a result thereof.19 In comparison, a $2,000 verdict was upheld in a case where the defendant at the point of a pistol drove the plaintiff out of her home, which may have been more aggravated but with a much larger verdict.20 The injury is not necessarily all physical.21 The mental distress may be a very material portion of the injury flowing from such a wrong.22 To measure damages by such a standard allows compensation for injury actually received rather than punitive damages.23
The trial court properly denied the motion for a new trial on this ground.24
The verdict of $750 is not excessive.25