623 So. 2d 1180 (Fla. 1993)
On March 9, 1990, plaintiff-appellee Kevin Fox was working for Eastern Airlines as a technician performing maintenance and overhaul on the electrical systems of airplanes.1 Fox was servicing an aircraft fan, Allied fan model 73 FA18, when his fingers were caught in the rotating blades of the fan. The fan did not have a safety screen at that particular moment.2
Allied's maintenance and service manual did not indicate that a safety screen or guard needed to be used over the fan while it was being serviced. Moreover, Eastern Airlines and its employee, Kevin Fox, failed to place a guard or screen over the fan.3 Eastern Airlines was nonetheless aware of the OSHA requirement that guarding be placed over rotating machines to protect operators from hazards. Apparently, this accident occurred during a strike against Eastern, and Mr. Fox, as well as other employees, had only been engaged in this type of work for a short period of time.4
As a result of the accident, Mr. Fox received permanent physical injuries: four fingers of his left hand were injured, two of which were amputated. He was able to return to work four months after the accident.5 Eastern Airlines was immune from suit pursuant to the Workers' Compensation Act.6
Mr. Fox alleged that Allied was negligent in failing to instruct that the fan should be serviced with a safety screen, and in failing to warn of the fan's suction.7 The trial court denied Allied's request to allow the jury to consider and assess non-party Eastern's percentage of fault, if any, under Florida's Tort Reform Act.8 The jury found Allied to be seventy percent (70%) negligent and Mr. Fox thirty percent (30%) comparatively negligent. Mr. Fox was awarded a total amount of $350,000.00 in damages.9
Thus, the amended final judgment was $245,000.00.10 The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit certified to the Supreme Court of Florida a question concerning the interpretation of section 768.81(3), Florida Statutes (1989).11
Whether the interpretation of section 768.81(3), Florida Statutes (1989), requires the jury to consider a non-party's comparative fault when determining a party's liability?12
Section 768.81(3), Florida Statutes (1989), requires that liability be apportioned to all participants in an accident to determine a defendant's percentage of fault.13
Yes. The statute mandates apportionment among every participant regardless of party status or immunity, so the trial court should have permitted the jury to evaluate Eastern Airlines' role.14
The established facts demonstrate that Eastern failed to place a guard over the fan even though it knew of the OSHA guarding requirement and maintained internal procedures for screen use.15 Eastern's immunity under the Workers' Compensation Act does not remove it from the apportionment calculation.16
Because the jury received no instruction on Eastern's potential fault, the seventy-percent allocation to Allied cannot stand as a complete determination of comparative responsibility under the statute.17
The statute requires the jury to consider a non-party's comparative fault when determining a party's liability.18
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Kogan, J.
Chief Justice Barkett dissented for the reasons stated in her Fabre v. Marin opinion.19