141 S. Ct. 2373 (2021)
California law requires charitable organizations seeking to solicit contributions in the state to register with the Attorney General's Office and renew those registrations annually.1
Over 100,000 charities are registered in California, and roughly 60,000 renew their registrations each year.2 Renewing charities must file copies of their Internal Revenue Service Form 990, including Schedule B, which requires disclosure of the names and addresses of donors who contributed more than $5,000 in a taxable year or more than 2 percent of an organization's total contributions.3
The petitioners, Americans for Prosperity Foundation, a public charity devoted to education and training about principles of a free and open society, and Thomas More Law Center, a public interest law firm, have renewed their registrations since 2001 but out of concern for their donors' anonymity declined to file unredacted Schedule Bs.4 Beginning in 2010 the Attorney General increased enforcement efforts and sent deficiency letters to charities that had not complied with the Schedule B requirement.5 When the petitioners continued to resist disclosing contributors' identities, the Attorney General threatened suspension of their registrations and fines for noncompliance.6
Each petitioner filed suit in the Central District of California alleging that the compelled disclosure violated their and their donors' First Amendment rights and challenging the requirement both on its face and as applied.7 The District Court granted preliminary injunctive relief, but the Ninth Circuit vacated and remanded.8 After bench trials on remand the District Court entered judgment for the petitioners and permanently enjoined the Attorney General from collecting their Schedule Bs.9 The Ninth Circuit again vacated the injunctions, reversed the judgments, and remanded for entry of judgment in favor of the Attorney General. The Ninth Circuit denied rehearing en banc, and we granted certiorari.
Whether California's requirement that charitable organizations disclose the identities of their major donors by filing unredacted Schedule B forms with the Attorney General violates the First Amendment?10
The First Amendment protects freedom of association, and compelled disclosure of affiliations with advocacy groups is subject to exacting scrutiny.11 Exacting scrutiny requires a substantial relation between the disclosure requirement and a sufficiently important governmental interest, and the regime must be narrowly tailored to that interest even if it need not be the least restrictive means.12
Yes. California's blanket requirement that all renewing charities file unredacted Schedule Bs fails exacting scrutiny.13 It is not narrowly tailored to the state's interest in preventing charitable fraud and self-dealing.14 The regime applies indiscriminately to over 100,000 registered charities and 60,000 annual renewals.15 It harvests sensitive donor names and addresses from every filer.16 The District Court found after trial that Schedule Bs were not integral to investigations.17 The Attorney General does not rely on them to initiate cases.18 The petitioners Americans for Prosperity Foundation and Thomas More Law Center demonstrated risks of threats and harassment to donors.19 The up-front collection imposes a broad burden without considering less intrusive alternatives such as subpoenas or audit letters that the record showed could serve the same ends.20
Because the disclosure regime sweeps far more broadly than necessary and creates unnecessary risks of chilling association, it violates the First Amendment on its face.21
California's requirement that charitable organizations disclose the identities of their major donors by filing unredacted Schedule B forms with the Attorney General violates the First Amendment.22
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Thomas concurs in the judgment that the disclosure requirement violates the First Amendment and that the District Court properly enjoined collection of the forms.23 He would apply strict scrutiny rather than exacting scrutiny to laws compelling disclosure of protected associations.24 This is because such burdens on privacy of association warrant the most rigorous review.25
Thomas also expresses continuing doubts about the overbreadth doctrine.26 He questions whether courts may invalidate lawful applications of a law merely because some applications might be unlawful.27 Yet he joins the holdings that the California regime fails scrutiny as applied to the petitioners.28
Joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch
Justice Alito, with whom Justice Neil Gorsuch joins, concurs in Parts I, II-A, II-B, and III, and concurs in the judgment.29 He joins most of Chief Justice Roberts's opinion and agrees that the exacting scrutiny standard has real teeth: it requires narrow tailoring and consideration of alternative means of obtaining information.30 For the reasons the Court explains, California's broad approach fails exacting scrutiny and is facially unconstitutional.31
The Court's decision is clear and the result is correct.32 He declines to decide categorically whether exacting or strict scrutiny must apply in every compelled-disclosure case; the choice of standard does not affect the outcome here.33
Joined by Justice Stephen G. Breyer And Justice Elena Kagan
Justice Sotomayor dissents and would affirm the Ninth Circuit.34 She argues that the Court abandons the requirement that plaintiffs demonstrate an actual First Amendment burden before demanding narrow tailoring or facial invalidation.35 Sotomayor contends that petitioners failed to show with objective evidence a reasonable probability that confidential Schedule B submission would expose donors to threats or reprisals.36 She argues that the Court improperly presumes burdens without the evidentiary showing required by precedents such as Reed and Buckley.37
She maintains that the facial challenge fails because many charities and donors do not prefer anonymity and that the proper remedy would be as-applied relief rather than invalidating the requirement across the board.38