198 P.2d 847 (Or. 1948)
During the summer of 1945, Portland Meadows commenced arrangements for the purchase of land and the construction of a one-mile race track north of Portland, Oregon.1 On August 25, 1945, an option for the purchase of 21 acres was secured from H.M. Seivert, one of the promoters of the theater project.2 On October 15, 1945, the defendant applied for and received a license to operate a race meet in May 1946, accompanied by extensive newspaper publicity about night racing lighting.3 Grading began in November 1945 and the project was completed on September 14, 1946.4
During the fall of 1945, the land for the plaintiff's theater was being prepared for night auto racing by Northwest Sports, Inc.5 On November 29, 1945, a lease was executed between Northwest Sports and the promoters of Amphitheaters, Inc., allowing construction and operation of a drive-in theater on the adjoining property, provided it did not interfere with auto racing operations.6
Plans for the theater construction were turned over in March 1946, with construction commencing in May or June of that year.7 The outdoor theater was completed and began operating on August 31, 1946, fifteen days before the first races at the track.8 Amphitheaters invested $135,000 in the theater, while the defendant expended sums greatly in excess, including $100,000 on lighting facilities alone.9
The properties adjoin between Denver Avenue and Union Avenue just north of Portland's city limits.10 The theater screen, about 40 feet high and 50 feet wide, faces slightly south of west toward the defendant's oval track.11 To illuminate the track for night racing, approximately 350 1500-watt lights were mounted in clusters on 80-foot poles at 250-foot intervals, with the nearest cluster 832 feet from the screen.
Light from the track, equivalent to full moonlight, spilled onto the screen, impairing picture quality and causing financial losses including refunds to patrons.12 Amphitheaters built wing fences and a shadow box to block light from highways, moon, and stars.13 After complaints in September 1946 and the filing of suit, the defendant installed 100 hoods and later 30 louvers, reducing but not eliminating the spill.14 The trial court directed a verdict for the defendant, from which Amphitheaters appealed.
Whether the casting of light from the defendant's race track onto the plaintiff's property constitutes a trespass?15
Under our decisions every unauthorized entry upon land of another, although without damage, constitutes actionable trespass.16
No. The facts establish that the light from the defendant's race track spills onto the plaintiff's property.17 This does not constitute a trespass because it is a non-trespassory invasion governed by the law of nuisance rather than trespass.18
The distinction is clear from the Restatement classifying such cases as non-trespassory.19 Airplane cases relied upon by plaintiff are distinguishable due to the ad coelum doctrine.20
The casting of light does not constitute a trespass.21
Whether the trial court erred in directing a verdict for the defendant on the plaintiff's claim that the race track lights constitute a nuisance?22
It is established law that an intentional interference with the use and enjoyment of land is not actionable unless that interference be both substantial and unreasonable.23
No. The facts show that Amphitheaters' drive-in theater is an abnormally sensitive use.24 It requires special protections such as wing fences and a shadow box to exclude even moonlight and starlight.25 The light from the race track equivalent to full moonlight would not interfere with ordinary uses of property.26
The properties are in a non-residential area outside city limits.27 Both parties developed simultaneously.28 Light is generally beneficial rather than noxious.29 Therefore the interference is damnum absque injuria as a matter of law justifying the directed verdict.30
The trial court did not err in directing a verdict for the defendant.31