188 U.S. 14
The case involved the application of a Massachusetts statute governing recognition of out-of-state divorces obtained by the state's own inhabitants.1 Massachusetts courts refused to enforce a South Dakota divorce decree under that statute.2 The dispute over the validity of the statute's application reached the Supreme Court of the United States.3 The case was argued on February 28, 1902, and the Court issued its decision on January 19, 1903.4
Whether the Massachusetts statute conflicts with the Constitution of the United States?5
The Full Faith and Credit Clause requires each state to give effect to the judicial proceedings of other states.6 This obligation does not preclude inquiry into whether the rendering court possessed jurisdiction over the subject matter.7 Jurisdiction to grant a divorce requires bona fide domicile in the rendering state.8 A state retains authority to enact statutes protecting its public policy.9 Such statutes deny enforcement to out-of-state divorces obtained by its own inhabitants who travel elsewhere without acquiring a bona fide domicile.10 They also address causes arising under the law of the domiciliary state.11
No. The Supreme Court first confirmed its jurisdiction because federal rights had been asserted and denied below.12 The Massachusetts statute establishes a rule of public policy that withholds effect from divorces obtained by Massachusetts inhabitants who leave the state to evade its laws.13 Because domicile is essential to jurisdiction over the subject matter of divorce, a decree rendered without bona fide domicile in the rendering state is not entitled to extraterritorial effect.14 The appearance of a party cannot supply the missing jurisdictional element.15
The statute therefore operated within constitutional bounds when the Massachusetts courts refused enforcement, as the Full Faith and Credit Clause does not compel recognition of a judgment lacking jurisdictional foundation.16 The state's power to regulate the dissolution of marriages among its citizens remains intact.17
The Massachusetts statute does not conflict with the Constitution of the United States.18
Whether the South Dakota divorce decree was entitled to enforcement in the courts of Massachusetts?19
A divorce decree is entitled to full faith and credit only when the rendering court had jurisdiction over both the parties and the subject matter.20 Subject-matter jurisdiction for divorce rests on bona fide domicile of at least one party within the state.21 Appearance by a party cannot confer jurisdiction over the subject matter when domicile is absent.22 A state may refuse enforcement of such a decree without violating the Full Faith and Credit Clause.23
No. The South Dakota statute made domicile rather than mere residence the basis for jurisdiction.24 Because the petitioning spouse retained Massachusetts domicile and never established a genuine domicile in South Dakota, the South Dakota court lacked power to render a decree entitled to extraterritorial effect.25 The Massachusetts courts therefore properly declined to enforce the decree under the state statute.26
The South Dakota divorce decree was not entitled to enforcement in the courts of Massachusetts.27