301 U.S. 103 (1937)
In October 1935, the Associated Press discharged Morris Watson, an employee in its New York office.1 The American Newspaper Guild filed a charge with the National Labor Relations Board alleging that Watson’s discharge violated the National Labor Relations Act.2
The Board served a complaint upon the Associated Press charging unfair labor practices.3 The Associated Press answered, admitting Watson’s discharge but denying that it was due to his union activities and raising constitutional objections to the validity of the Act and the Board’s jurisdiction.4
At a hearing before a trial examiner the Associated Press appeared specially and moved to dismiss the complaint on constitutional grounds.5 After the motion was overruled, counsel withdrew from the hearing and the matter proceeded without the petitioner’s participation.6 The examiner recommended an order against the Associated Press, and the Board issued findings of fact, conclusions of law, and an order requiring the Associated Press to cease discouraging union membership, to reinstate Watson, and to make him whole for lost pay.7
The Associated Press refused to comply with the order.8 The Board petitioned the Circuit Court of Appeals for enforcement pursuant to the Act, and that court entered a decree enforcing the order.9 The Associated Press did not challenge the Board’s findings of fact in its answer to the enforcement petition.10
The Associated Press is a New York membership corporation whose members are representatives of newspapers.11 It collects news from members and other sources throughout the United States and foreign countries, edits and rewrites the information, and distributes it to member newspapers using leased telegraph wires and other means of communication.12 Watson worked in the News Department of the New York office, where he received, rewrote, and filed news for transmission.13
Whether the National Labor Relations Act as applied to the Associated Press exceeds the power of Congress to regulate commerce under Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution?14
Congress possesses authority under the Commerce Clause to regulate labor relations in industries engaged in interstate commerce when labor disputes would directly burden or obstruct the free flow of such commerce.15 The National Labor Relations Act protects employees' right of collective bargaining and prohibits employer discrimination against union activities.16
No. The Associated Press collects news throughout the United States and foreign countries then edits rewrites and transmits the product over leased interstate telegraph wires to member newspapers in multiple states.17 Watson performed rewrite and filing duties in the New York office that directly supported this continuous interstate distribution of news.18 A strike or labor disturbance among employees in Watson's class would therefore directly impede the interstate movement of news in the same manner as a disruption among teletype operators or telegraph employees.19
The National Labor Relations Act as applied to the Associated Press does not exceed the power of Congress to regulate commerce.20
Whether the National Labor Relations Act as applied to the Associated Press abridges the freedom of the press guaranteed by the First Amendment?21
The First Amendment freedom of the press does not exempt publishers or news agencies from generally applicable labor regulations that protect employees' rights to organize and bargain collectively.22 Such regulations are valid so long as the employer remains free to discharge editorial staff for any reason other than union activity and the regulation does not dictate news content or editorial policy.23
No. The Board's order rests solely on the finding that Watson was discharged for his guild activities rather than for unsatisfactory work or anticipated bias.24 The Associated Press may still discharge any editorial employee including Watson for failure to meet its standards of impartiality or for any other non-union reason and remains entirely free to enforce its chosen editorial policies.25 The regulation therefore bears no relation to the content or impartiality of the news distributed.26
The National Labor Relations Act as applied to the Associated Press does not abridge the freedom of the press.27
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Van Devanter, Mcreynolds, And Butler
Justice Sutherland dissented on the ground that the Act as applied abridges freedom of the press.28 He argued that this prevents the Associated Press from exercising independent judgment over the retention of editorial employees whose union sympathies might introduce color or distortion into news reports.29 He maintained that the unqualified command of the First Amendment forbids Congress from substituting its judgment for that of press management in editorial employment decisions even when the stated purpose is regulation of commerce.30
Sutherland concluded that the order compelling reinstatement therefore violates the First Amendment.31
Whether the National Labor Relations Act denies trial by jury in violation of the Seventh Amendment?32
The Seventh Amendment right to jury trial does not extend to administrative enforcement proceedings brought under the National Labor Relations Act.33
No. The contentions that the Act and the Board's order deprive the Associated Press of the right to trial by jury are sufficiently answered by the reasoning in Texas and N. O. R. Co. v. Brotherhood of Railway and Steamship Clerks.34 National Labor Relations Board v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. confirms the same result.35
The National Labor Relations Act does not deny trial by jury in violation of the Seventh Amendment.36