602 N.W.2d 749 (S.D. 1999)
In 1995, the defendant farmers each contracted to sell corn and soybeans to Farmers Elevator Company of Eden, South Dakota, with delivery to be completed by December 1, 1995.1 Atwood-Kellogg, Inc., provided financing to the elevator company and retained a security interest in its accounts receivable and contract rights.2 The elevator company subsequently suffered serious financial problems and became insolvent, a fact undisputed by the parties.3
On November 6, 1995, at the elevator company's annual stockholders meeting attended by the farmers and others, a representative of Atwood-Kellogg announced that the company would guarantee payment of the grain contracts in writing.4 This announcement was retracted on November 20, 1995, when the representative informed the board that no written guarantees would be provided.5 On November 29, 1995, the president of Atwood-Kellogg mailed a letter to the president of the elevator company proposing to guarantee payment on the farmers' contracts.6
One farmer who served on the board of directors received a copy of the November 29 letter, though it did not specify particular contracts, while the remaining farmers first learned of the letter's existence from their attorney on August 24, 1998.7 Several farmers made partial deliveries of commodities to the elevator company after it became insolvent.8 The farmers refused to deliver the remaining commodities under the contracts due to the elevator's insolvency.9
Atwood-Kellogg filed suit against the farmers for breach of contract based on their failure to deliver.10 Both parties moved for summary judgment in the trial court.11 The trial court granted summary judgment to the farmers but denied Atwood-Kellogg's motion.12 Atwood-Kellogg appealed to the South Dakota Supreme Court.13 On February 22, 1996, the elevator company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, which was later converted to Chapter 7.14
Whether the Defendant Farmers are relieved from their obligation to deliver corn and soybeans to the insolvent buyer, Farmers Elevator of Eden, when the Plaintiff, the Elevator’s financier, offered to pay for the corn and soybeans?15
In contracts for the sale of goods, the seller must make timely delivery while the buyer must accept and pay.16 Under SDCL 57A-2-702, a seller discovering buyer insolvency may refuse delivery except for cash.17 Under SDCL 57A-2-609(1), when reasonable grounds for insecurity arise, a party may demand adequate assurances of due performance in writing and suspend performance until assurances are received; however, a demand may be written or oral if it creates a clear understanding that performance is suspended until assurances are provided.18
No. The established facts show that the farmers refused to deliver remaining commodities after the elevator became insolvent.19 Atwood-Kellogg provided a November 29 letter proposing to guarantee payment, yet most farmers did not receive that letter until 1998.20 Several farmers made partial deliveries after insolvency.21 The rule requires the seller to condition refusal on a demand for cash under SDCL 57A-2-702 or to provide a clear understanding of intent to suspend performance pending assurances under SDCL 57A-2-609.22
The facts show disputes over whether any demand for cash or assurances occurred, whether the guarantee letter constituted cash or adequate assurance, and whether the farmers communicated a clear intent to suspend performance.23 Because these fact questions remain unresolved on the scanty record, the farmers are not relieved of their delivery obligation as a matter of law and summary judgment was improper.24
The trial court erred in granting summary judgment to the farmers; the judgment is reversed and the case remanded for trial on the disputed factual issues concerning compliance with SDCL 57A-2-609 and SDCL 57A-2-702.25
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Gilbertson dissents on the ground that the material facts are undisputed: the elevator was insolvent, Atwood orally promised then revoked a written guarantee, and only one farmer received the November 29 letter.26 He concludes that Atwood's letter is not cash under SDCL 57A-2-702 because it is an unsecured promise to pay rather than legal tender or its equivalent, citing Dale v. Felton.27 Gilbertson further argues judicial estoppel bars Atwood from seeking a trial after demanding summary judgment in its own favor for a specific damages amount.28
He also argues that the parties had a clear understanding the farmers had suspended performance, satisfying SDCL 57A-2-609 under AMF, Inc. v. McDonald's Corp.29 He would affirm the summary judgment for the farmers.30