468 U.S. 263 (1984)
In 1939 Hawaii enacted an excise tax on wholesale liquor sales to offset increased governmental costs from liquor consumption.1 The original statute contained no exemptions.2
In 1971 the legislature added an exemption for okolehao, a brandy distilled from the root of the indigenous ti plant. In 1976 it added an exemption for fruit wine manufactured in Hawaii from local products, primarily pineapple wine.3 Both exemptions were enacted to encourage development of Hawaiian liquor industries and remained in effect during the tax years at issue.4
Appellants Bacchus Imports, Ltd. and Eagle Distributors, Inc. are licensed wholesalers that import and sell liquor to retailers in Hawaii.5 Foremost-McKesson, Inc. and Paradise Beverages, Inc. were also parties to the suit.6 They sell the liquor at their wholesale price plus the 20% excise tax imposed by § 244-4.7 The wholesalers also pay a separate one-half percent tax under Haw. Rev. Stat. § 237-13.8
Between 1974 and 1979 the wholesalers paid the excise tax under protest pursuant to Haw. Rev. Stat. § 40-35.9 They filed refund claims in the Tax Appeal Court seeking approximately $45 million.10 Their complaints alleged that the tax with its exemptions violated the Import-Export Clause and the Commerce Clause.11 The Tax Appeal Court rejected both claims.12
On appeal the Hawaii Supreme Court affirmed.13 It upheld the statute against Equal Protection, Import-Export, and Commerce Clause challenges.14 The court found the exemptions rationally related to promoting local industry.15 It concluded that the tax did not discriminate against interstate commerce because its incidence fell on in-state wholesalers and consumers.16 The Supreme Court of the United States noted probable jurisdiction in 1983.17
Whether the wholesalers have standing to challenge the Hawaii liquor tax exemptions?18
Parties liable for a tax have standing to challenge its constitutionality when the tax affects their competitive position even if the economic burden may be passed on to customers.19
Yes. Bacchus Imports, Ltd. and Eagle Distributors, Inc. are liable for the 20 percent excise tax under Haw. Rev. Stat. § 244-4 on all their wholesale sales whether or not customers pay their bills.20 The tax raises the price of their imported products relative to the exempted local beverages.21 This gives them a concrete interest in litigating the claimed discrimination as shown by their payment of the tax under protest and their refund claims totaling approximately $45 million.22
The wholesalers have standing to challenge the Hawaii liquor tax exemptions.23
Whether the Hawaii liquor tax exemptions for okolehao and pineapple wine violate the Equal Protection Clause?24
A tax exemption that discriminates against imported products violates the Equal Protection Clause unless the distinction is rationally related to a legitimate state purpose such as promoting local industry.25
Yes. The exemptions for okolehao distilled from the indigenous ti plant and for pineapple wine manufactured from local fruit were enacted to promote Hawaiian industries.26 Yet the Hawaii Supreme Court found these products are not in competition with imported liquor.27 The distinction therefore lacks a rational relationship to the asserted purpose and amounts to mere economic protectionism.28
The exemptions violate the Equal Protection Clause.29
Whether the Hawaii liquor tax exemptions for okolehao and pineapple wine violate the Commerce Clause?30
A state tax that discriminates against interstate commerce by exempting local products while taxing out-of-state products is virtually per se invalid when it has both the purpose and effect of economic protectionism.31
Yes. The 1971 and 1976 exemptions were enacted at the behest of local manufacturers to encourage and promote the establishment of a fruit wine industry in Hawaii and to aid the economic recovery of the Hawaiian pineapple industry.32 The effect is discriminatory because some competition exists as price differentials may cause drinkers to switch from taxed imports to the exempted local beverages.33 This violates the Commerce Clause as applied to the wholesalers who import and sell only the taxed products.34
The exemptions violate the Commerce Clause.35
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stevens concurs in the judgment and in the opinion of the Court.36 He writes separately only to emphasize that the Court's decision does not call into question the power of the States to regulate or tax the sale of liquor in ways that do not discriminate against interstate commerce.37 His concurrence makes clear that the ruling preserves broad state authority to impose nondiscriminatory taxes and regulations on liquor sales.
Joined by Justice Marshall
Justice Brennan, with whom Justice Marshall joins, dissents from the majority opinion.38 He maintains that the Hawaii tax exemptions do not violate either the Equal Protection Clause or the Commerce Clause.39 According to his view, the exemptions represent a reasonable means of promoting local industry within the State.40
Furthermore, they do not discriminate against interstate commerce in any constitutionally significant way.41 Therefore, he would uphold the judgment of the Hawaii Supreme Court rather than reverse it.42
Joined by Justice O'connor
Justice Rehnquist, with whom Justice O'Connor joins, joins in Justice Brennan's dissent and adds additional comments of his own.43 He contends that the Court's decision represents an unwarranted extension of the negative implications of the Commerce Clause.44 He points out that the Twenty-first Amendment gives the States broad authority to regulate the liquor traffic.45
This Court has repeatedly recognized that authority in prior cases.46 In his opinion, the Hawaii statute constitutes a valid exercise of that authority and should be sustained.47
Whether the Twenty-first Amendment saves the Hawaii liquor tax exemptions from invalidation under the Commerce Clause?48
The Twenty-first Amendment does not authorize state laws that constitute mere economic protectionism unrelated to core Amendment purposes such as temperance or the control of liquor traffic.49
No. The exemptions were enacted solely to promote local industry rather than to advance any Twenty-first Amendment concern.50 Therefore they cannot be saved by the Amendment.51 The central purpose of the provision was not to empower States to favor local liquor industries by erecting barriers to competition.52 This conclusion follows from the facts that the legislature's goal was to encourage development of the Hawaiian liquor industry.53
The Twenty-first Amendment does not save the exemptions from invalidation under the Commerce Clause.54