360 U.S. 109 (1959)
Lloyd Barenblatt had been a graduate student and teaching fellow at the University of Michigan from 1947 to 1950 and an instructor in psychology at Vassar College from 1950 until shortly before his appearance before the Subcommittee.1 Pursuant to a subpoena, Barenblatt appeared on June 28, 1954, accompanied by counsel, before a Subcommittee of the House Committee on Un-American Activities.2 After answering preliminary questions about his background, he refused to answer five specific questions concerning his membership in the Communist Party and related affiliations at the University of Michigan and elsewhere, relying on grounds set forth in a prepared memorandum.3
The Subcommittee was conducting an inquiry into alleged Communist infiltration into the field of education.4 The House certified the matter to the United States Attorney for the District of Columbia after receiving the Subcommittee's report.5 An indictment in five counts followed under 2 U.S.C. § 192.6 With the consent of both sides, the case was tried to the court without a jury, resulting in conviction on all counts and imposition of a general sentence of six months' imprisonment and a $250 fine.7
Barenblatt's conviction was initially affirmed by a unanimous panel of the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in 1957.8 This Court granted certiorari, vacated the judgment, and remanded for further consideration in light of Watkins v. United States.9 The Court of Appeals sitting en banc then reaffirmed the conviction by a divided court.10 This Court again granted certiorari to consider the statutory and constitutional challenges.11
The investigation formed part of the Un-American Activities Committee's long-standing program that included hearings on Communist influences in education in 1947, 1952, and 1953.12 Just prior to Barenblatt's appearance, the scope of the day's hearings had been announced as addressing communism in education and the experiences of Francis X. T. Crowley, with activities in Michigan, Boston, and New York.13 Crowley had testified earlier that day identifying Barenblatt as a former member of an alleged Communist student organization at the University of Michigan.14
Whether Rule XI of the House of Representatives provided sufficient legislative authorization for the Subcommittee to compel testimony regarding Communist activities in education?15
The congressional power of inquiry is as penetrating and far-reaching as the potential power to enact and appropriate under the Constitution. It is subject to limitations including the requirement that Congress may only investigate areas in which it may potentially legislate.16 Rule XI's authorization to the Un-American Activities Committee must be read with the persuasive gloss of its long legislative history rather than in isolation.17
Yes. Rule XI authorized the Subcommittee's inquiry into Communist infiltration of education because the House steadily continued the Committee's life at the start of each Congress.18 The House supported its activities with substantial appropriations.19 The House raised it to standing committee status in 1945.20
The House affirmatively approved its work on Communist influences in education through the 1947 program, 1952 and 1953 hearings, and the 1953 appropriations debate.21 Barenblatt appeared pursuant to subpoena before the Subcommittee during its announced investigation of communism in education and the background of Francis X. T. Crowley.22
The Committee's history of investigating Communist activities in universities supplied the definite content that cured any facial vagueness in the Rule.23 The legislative gloss demonstrated beyond doubt that the House had clothed the Committee with pervasive authority to investigate Communist activities in the domain of national security, including education.24
Rule XI supplied valid legislative authorization for the Subcommittee to compel Barenblatt's testimony.25
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Warren, C.j., And Douglas, J.
Justice Black dissented on the ground that Rule XI is too broad and vague to support any conviction.26 Rule XI authorizes compulsory examination about all un-American propaganda without an unequivocal congressional statement of the need for the information.27 A witness cannot know with sufficient certainty what the compelling need is when the authorizing resolution supplies no clear standard.28
Congress must state expressly and unequivocally when it wishes to investigate ideas in education.29
Whether the petitioner was adequately apprised of the pertinency of the Subcommittee's questions to the subject matter of the inquiry?30
Yes. Pertinency appeared with undisputable clarity because the subject matter of the inquiry had been identified at the commencement as Communist infiltration into education.33 The scope of the day's hearings had been announced as communism in education and the experiences of Francis X. T.
Crowley in Michigan, Boston, and New York.34 Crowley had testified immediately before Barenblatt and identified him as a former member of an alleged Communist student organization at Michigan.35 Barenblatt had stood mute when the Chairman stated that the files showed he possessed valuable information about Communist activities while at Michigan.36 Barenblatt raised no specific pertinency objection at the time the questions were put.37
His prepared memorandum contained only a contemplated objection buried in a general challenge to the Subcommittee's power.38
Barenblatt was adequately apprised of the pertinency of the questions.39
Whether the Subcommittee's questions infringed rights protected by the First Amendment?40
The First Amendment protects an individual from being compelled to disclose associational relationships in some circumstances.41 The protections do not afford a witness the right to resist inquiry in all circumstances.42 Resolution of the issue involves a balancing by the courts of the competing private and public interests at stake in the particular circumstances shown.43 The subordinating interest of the State must be compelling to overcome the individual constitutional rights.44
No. The balance between the individual and governmental interests must be struck in favor of the government because Congress has wide power to legislate in the field of Communist activity and to conduct appropriate investigations in aid thereof.45 This power rests on the right of self-preservation.46 The Court has consistently refused to view the Communist Party as an ordinary political party given the long-accepted view that its tenets include the ultimate overthrow of the Government by force and violence.47 The investigation into Communist infiltration of universities was related to a valid legislative purpose.48
The questions identifying Barenblatt as a member of the Communist Party were within the permissible scope of the inquiry.49 The record showed no attempt to pillory witnesses or use indiscriminate dragnet procedures.50 Barenblatt's refusal to answer questions whose pertinency was clear beyond doubt therefore did not offend the First Amendment.51
The Subcommittee's questions did not infringe Barenblatt's First Amendment rights.52
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Warren, C.j., And Douglas, J.
Justice Black dissented on the ground that the First Amendment forbids Congress from passing any law abridging freedom of speech, press, assembly or petition.53 The Committee's activities through exposure, obloquy and public scorn do precisely that.54 He rejected any balancing process that would allow abridgment whenever the governmental interest is deemed greater.55
The real interest at stake is society's interest in being able to join organizations and advocate causes without later governmental penalties.56 The Court's approach reduces balancing to a play on words while the Government's interest in self-preservation is vastly overstated.57
Whether the investigation served a valid legislative purpose rather than mere exposure?58
So long as Congress acts in pursuance of its constitutional power, the Judiciary lacks authority to intervene on the basis of the motives which spurred the exercise of that power.59 An investigation is not rendered invalid merely because exposure may result, provided the primary purposes are in aid of legislative processes.60
Yes. The investigation served a valid legislative purpose because the Un-American Activities Committee had long investigated Communist activities including espionage, infiltration into labor and professional groups, and influences in education.61 The record disclosed considerable testimony concerning the foreign domination and revolutionary purposes of the Communist Party.62 The Subcommittee Chairman's opening statement evinced no intention to control classroom discussion.63
The dominant theme remained Communist infiltration furthering the alleged ultimate purpose of overthrow.64 The Court of Appeals correctly concluded that the primary purposes of the inquiry were in aid of legislative processes.65 The Judiciary may not restrain a lawful exercise of power on the ground that a wrong motive or purpose impelled its exertion.66
The investigation served a valid legislative purpose.67
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Warren, C.j., And Douglas, J.
Justice Black dissented on the ground that the chief aim, purpose and practice of the Committee is to try witnesses and punish them by humiliation and public shame because they are or have been Communists or refuse to admit Communist affiliations.68 The Committee's own reports demonstrate it seeks to expose and eliminate suspected Communists from employment through pitiless publicity.69 Such punishment by exposure is a legislative function forbidden by the Constitution.70
The proceedings against Barenblatt were part of a program to stigmatize and punish without the safeguards of judicial trial.71