425 U.S. 341, 96 S. Ct. 1612, 48 L. Ed. 2d 1 (1976)
In the course of an investigation into possible criminal violations of the federal income tax laws for the years 1966 through 1971, two special agents of the Intelligence Division of the Internal Revenue Service met with petitioner Beckwith at a private home where he occasionally stayed.1
The agents arrived at 8 a.m. to avoid potential embarrassment at Beckwith's place of employment, which opened at 10 a.m.2 The agents were invited into the house.3 When petitioner entered the room where they were waiting, the agents introduced themselves to him.4 The agents informed Beckwith that they were assigned to investigate his federal income tax liability for the years 1966 through 1971.5 The senior agent then read to petitioner from a printed card a statement advising him of his rights under the Fifth Amendment.6
Beckwith acknowledged that he understood his rights.7 The agents then interviewed him until about 11 o'clock.8 The agents described the conversation as friendly and relaxed.9 Beckwith noted that the agents did not press him on any question he could not or chose not to answer.10
Prior to the conclusion of the interview, the senior agent requested that petitioner permit the agents to inspect certain records at his place of employment.11 The agents met petitioner approximately 45 minutes later.12 The senior agent advised the petitioner that he was not required to furnish any books or records.13 Petitioner supplied the books to the agents.14
Prior to trial, petitioner moved to suppress all statements he made to the agents or evidence derived from those statements on the ground that petitioner had not been given the warnings mandated by Miranda v. Arizona.15 The District Court ruled that he was entitled to such warnings when the court finds as a fact that there were custodial circumstances.16 The District Judge found that on this record there is no evidence whatsoever of any such situation.17 The Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment of conviction.18 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.19
Whether a special agent of the Internal Revenue Service, investigating potential criminal income tax violations, must, in an interview with a taxpayer, not in custody, give the warnings called for by Miranda v. Arizona?20
Miranda warnings are required only for custodial interrogation.21 Custodial interrogation is defined as questioning initiated by law enforcement officers after a person has been taken into custody or otherwise deprived of his freedom of action in any significant way.22 The focus of an investigation alone does not trigger the requirement.23
No. The established facts establish that two special agents met Beckwith at a private home where he occasionally stayed after arriving at 8 a.m. to avoid potential embarrassment at his workplace.24 Beckwith was invited inside.25 The agents identified themselves and read a statement advising him of his Fifth Amendment rights including the right to seek assistance of counsel. Beckwith acknowledged understanding those rights.26 The ensuing interview lasted until approximately 11 o'clock, was described by both sides as friendly and relaxed, and involved no pressure on questions Beckwith chose not to answer.27
Before concluding, the agents requested permission to inspect records at Beckwith's workplace, met him there about 45 minutes later, again advised him he was not required to furnish the books, and received the records from him.28 The District Court found no evidence of custodial circumstances, and the Court of Appeals affirmed that Beckwith was neither arrested nor detained against his will.29 These facts demonstrate that Beckwith was not in custody or otherwise deprived of his freedom in any significant way, so the full Miranda warnings were not required even though the investigation had focused on him.30
The special agents were not required to give the full Miranda warnings during the non-custodial interview of Beckwith.31
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Marshall concurred in the judgment.32 He observed that the agents provided Beckwith with a warning stating that they investigated possible criminal violations, that Beckwith could not be compelled to answer questions that might incriminate him, that anything he said could be used against him, and that he could seek the assistance of an attorney.33 Under the circumstances of this case, in which Beckwith was not under arrest and the interview took place in a private home where he occasionally stayed, the warning recited above satisfied the requirements of the Fifth Amendment.34
Marshall added that if this warning had not been given, he would not join the judgment of the Court.35
Justice Brennan dissented.36 He argued that the fact Beckwith had not been taken into formal custody is not determinative.37 Miranda warnings are also mandated when the taxpayer is interrogated by Intelligence Division agents in surroundings where the practical compulsion to respond to questions about his tax returns is comparable to the psychological pressures described in Miranda.38 Brennan agreed with the Seventh Circuit that the warnings are required when the investigative machinery of the government is directed toward the ultimate conviction of a particular individual.39 The dual criminal-civil nature of an IRS interrogation creates misapprehensions for the taxpayer tantamount to the deprivation of the suspect's freedom of action in any significant way.40
He would reverse the judgment of conviction and remand for a new trial.41