369 So.2d 523, 2 A.L.R.4th 1042 (Ala. 1979)
J.H. Borland, Sr., and Sarah M. Borland own approximately 159 acres of land located just south of Troy, Alabama, on Henderson Road. On this property, the Borlands raise cattle, grow several different crops, and have a large pecan orchard.1
In 1968, Sanders Lead Company started an operation for the recovery of lead from used automobile batteries on property just east of the Borlands' property across Henderson Road. The company's smelter was placed on the west edge of its property nearest to the Borlands' land. The smelter reduces plates from used automobile batteries, and the process results in emission of lead particulates and sulfur dioxide gases.2
Sanders Lead installed a filter system known as a bag house to intercept lead particulates.3 The smoke passes through two cooling systems before the bag house.4 On two occasions the cooling system failed to function properly, resulting in the bag house catching fire on both occasions.5 There is a dispute as to the efficiency of the bag house throughout its operation.6
The Borlands allege that because of the problems with the bag house their property has been damaged by a dangerous accumulation of lead particulates and sulfur dioxide deposits.7 The case was tried ore tenus to the trial judge without a jury and judgment was rendered for the defendant.8 In its final decree the trial court commented that the plaintiffs' land is significantly increased in value due to its proximity to the lead plant and has a much higher value as commercial property.9
Whether a property owner may maintain an action in trespass to recover damages for pollution of his land by lead particulates and sulfur dioxide emitted from a neighboring industrial facility?10
Yes. The Borlands own approximately 159 acres of land on which they raise cattle, grow crops, and maintain a pecan orchard.13 Sanders Lead Company operates a smelter on adjacent property that emits lead particulates and sulfur dioxide.14 The emissions from the smelter, due to problems with the bag house, have accumulated on the Borlands' property causing damage.15
This satisfies the elements of an indirect trespass because the invasion affects the exclusive possession, the act is intentional, it is reasonably foreseeable, and substantial damages to the res have occurred.16
A property owner may maintain an action in trespass to recover damages for pollution of his land by lead particulates and sulfur dioxide emitted from a neighboring industrial facility.17
Whether the trial court misapplied Alabama law by concluding that compliance with the Alabama Air Pollution Control Act shielded the defendant from liability for resulting damages?18
The Alabama Air Pollution Control Act expressly preserves private remedies for damages resulting from air pollution and does not shield a defendant from liability.19
Yes. The trial court was under the mistaken impression that compliance with the Alabama Air Pollution Control Act shielded the defendant from liability.20 However, section 22-28-23 of the Alabama Code specifically provides that nothing in the Act shall be construed to limit or abrogate any private remedies available for restitution for damage resulting from air pollution.21
The trial court misapplied Alabama law by concluding that compliance with the Alabama Air Pollution Control Act shielded the defendant from liability for resulting damages.22
Whether evidence that the plaintiffs' property increased in commercial value due to its proximity to the defendant's plant precludes recovery for trespass?23
Evidence that the plaintiffs' property increased in commercial value due to its proximity to the defendant's plant does not preclude recovery for trespass because such a rule would permit private condemnation which is impermissible.24
No. The trial court incorrectly applied the law in concluding that because the plaintiffs' farm had increased in value as industrial property due to its proximity to the lead plant, the plaintiffs could not recover.25 The appreciation factor is totally unrelated to the wrongful acts complained of and the proper measure of damages is the difference in value before and after the trespass based on the owner's use of the property.26
Evidence that the plaintiffs' property increased in commercial value due to its proximity to the defendant's plant does not preclude recovery for trespass.27