56 Ill. 2d 95, 306 N.E.2d 39 (1973)
The circuit court of Cook County dismissed the plaintiff's complaint for failure to state a cause of action.1 The appellate court reversed the dismissal and remanded the cause to the circuit court.2 The Supreme Court of Illinois granted leave to appeal from that decision.3 This wrongful death action seeks damages for the death of the plaintiff's decedent during an attempted armed robbery at the Racine Currency Exchange.4
On April 27, 1970, John Boyd entered the Racine Currency Exchange for the purpose of transacting business.5 While Boyd was there, an armed robber entered the premises.6 The robber placed a pistol to Boyd's head and told Blanche Murphy, the teller, to give him the money or open the door or he would kill Boyd.7 Murphy was located behind a bulletproof glass window and partition at the time of the demand.8
Murphy did not comply with the robber's demand but instead fell to the floor.9 The robber then shot Boyd in the head, killing him.10 The plaintiff filed suit against Racine Currency Exchange and Blanche Murphy. The complaint set forth several acts of negligence by the defendants in connection with the incident.11
Count I of the complaint alleged that the defendants breached their duty by refusing to accede to the robber's demands.12 It further alleged that the defendants followed a policy of protecting their money at all costs, including the safety and lives of customers, and deliberately withheld knowledge of this policy from customers.13 Count II alleged that the Currency Exchange was negligent in failing to instruct its employees on the proper course of conduct during an armed robbery.14 It also alleged negligence in employing an incompetent person and in failing to furnish guidelines for handling such situations or to disclose the policy to customers.15
Whether the defendants owed a duty to the business invitee to comply with the armed robber's demands to protect his safety?16
It is fundamental that there can be no recovery in tort for negligence unless the defendant has breached a duty owed to the plaintiff.17 A person has no duty to anticipate the criminal acts of third parties.18 An exception to this rule exists when criminal acts should reasonably have been foreseen.19 In determining whether a duty exists, the likelihood of injury, the magnitude of the burden of guarding against it and the consequences of placing the burden upon the defendant must also be taken into account.20
No. The facts alleged show that the robber placed a pistol to Boyd's head and demanded money or to open the door or he would kill Boyd while Murphy stood behind bulletproof glass.
It may encourage the use of hostages, thereby generally increasing the risk to invitees upon business premises.21 The consequence of placing the burden upon the defendant would grant criminals additional leverage to enforce their demands.22
The defendants did not owe to the invitee Boyd a duty to comply with the demand of the criminal.23
Related opinions on this issue
The majority opinion fails to take into account the principles of law clearly enunciated in Restatement (Second) of Torts, secs. 302B and 449, and on the basis of pure conjecture concludes that nothing that defendant’s employee could have done would have saved the deceased from death or injury.24 The majority’s polemic on the subject of the hazards which would be created by an application of established legal principles to this case finds little support in logic and none whatsoever in the legal authorities.25
Whether what defendants did or did not do proximately caused the injury that befell plaintiff’s decedent, whether Blanche Murphy had the time so she could, under the circumstances alleged, exercise the kind of judgment expected of a person of ordinary prudence, were questions of fact which, from all the evidence, must be decided by a trier of the facts, judge or jury.26 I would affirm the judgment of the appellate court.27