506 U.S. 263 (1993)
In 1989 clinics that perform abortions and organizations supporting legalized abortion, including the National Organization for Women and its members who may wish to use the clinics, filed suit in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia against Operation Rescue, an unincorporated association whose members oppose abortion, and six individual organizers and coordinators of its activities.1
Operation Rescue regularly staged demonstrations in the Washington, D.C., metropolitan area in which participants trespassed on clinic property and physically blocked entrances and exits, preventing patients, physicians, and staff from entering or leaving the facilities.2 The district court conducted an expedited trial.3 It made findings that substantial numbers of women seeking services at the targeted clinics traveled interstate to reach them.4 The demonstrations had closed at least one clinic for more than six hours, during which 240 demonstrators were arrested while outnumbering the local police.5
The district court ruled that the petitioners had violated 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) by conspiring to deprive women seeking abortions of their right to interstate travel.6 It also ruled for the respondents on their pendent state-law claims of trespass and public nuisance.7 As relief the court entered an injunction barring petitioners from trespassing on or obstructing access to abortion clinics in specified Virginia counties and cities in the Washington metropolitan area.8 Pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1988, the court ordered petitioners to pay respondents $27,687.55 in attorney’s fees and costs.9
The Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the judgment in 1990.10 The Supreme Court granted certiorari in 1991.11 It heard argument in the October 1991 Term and directed reargument after the case was restored to the calendar in 1992.12 The case was reargued on October 6, 1992.13
The record established that petitioners defined their rescues as physical intervention between abortion providers and the women seeking their services.14 All participants shared a commitment to stopping the practice of abortion and reversing its legalization.15 The district court further found that the demonstrations occurred without advance notice.16 The scale of the events repeatedly overwhelmed local law-enforcement resources.17
Whether the first clause of 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) provides a federal cause of action against persons organizing demonstrations that obstruct access to abortion clinics?18
To prove a private conspiracy in violation of the first clause of § 1985(3), a plaintiff must show (1) that some racial, or perhaps otherwise class-based, invidiously discriminatory animus lay behind the conspirators' action, and (2) that the conspiracy aimed at interfering with rights protected against private, as well as official, encroachment.19
No. The established facts show that Operation Rescue and the individual petitioners organized demonstrations in which participants trespassed on clinic property and physically blocked entrances and exits to abortion clinics in the Washington metropolitan area.20 The district court found that petitioners defined their rescues as physical intervention between abortion providers and the women seeking services.21 All participants shared a commitment to stopping the practice of abortion.22 These facts establish opposition to abortion rather than the required class-based animus.23
The right to abortion is not among the few rights protected against private encroachment.24 The right to interstate travel was only incidentally affected because petitioners opposed abortion regardless of whether it followed interstate travel.25
The first clause of 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) does not provide a federal cause of action on these facts.26
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Kennedy joined the majority but added that essential considerations of federalism are at stake.27 A false step in interpreting § 1985(3) risks making ordinary state crimes concurrent violations of a century-old statute.28 He noted that another federal statute, 42 U.S.C. § 10501, offers the possibility of powerful federal assistance when state officials request it for law-enforcement emergencies.29
Whether opposition to abortion constitutes the class-based invidiously discriminatory animus required under 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3)?30
No. The established facts show that the district court found petitioners define their rescues not with reference to women but as physical intervention between abortionists and the innocent victims.34 All petitioners share a deep commitment to stopping the practice of abortion.35 The record does not indicate that the demonstrations are motivated by a purpose directed specifically at women as a class.36 Opposition to abortion is not an irrational surrogate for opposition to women.37
Men and women are on both sides of the issue.38 The Court has held in Maher v. Roe and Harris v. McRae that disfavoring abortion is not ipso facto sex discrimination.39
Opposition to abortion does not constitute the class-based invidiously discriminatory animus required under 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3).40
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Blackmun
Joined by Justice Blackmun
Whether a conspiracy to obstruct access to abortion clinics aims at interfering with rights protected against private encroachment, such as the right to interstate travel?47
No. The established facts show that substantial numbers of women seeking services at the clinics traveled interstate.51 Petitioners' proposed demonstrations would not implicate the right to interstate travel because the only actual barriers would have been in the immediate vicinity of the clinics.52 This restricted movement within Virginia.53 Petitioners oppose abortion regardless of whether it is performed after interstate travel.54
Therefore the right to interstate travel was not aimed at.55 The right to abortion is not protected against private encroachment.56
A conspiracy to obstruct access to abortion clinics does not aim at interfering with rights protected against private encroachment.57
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Souter would have remanded for further findings on whether the conspiracy had the purpose of preventing or hindering law enforcement from securing equal protection.58 He noted that the district court found the rescuers outnumbered the police.59 The police were unable to prevent the closing of the clinic for more than six hours.60
Whether the hindrance clause of 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) applies when demonstrators prevent local police from securing access to abortion clinics?61
The hindrance clause covers conspiracies for the purpose of preventing or hindering the constituted authorities of any State from giving or securing to all persons within such State the equal protection of the laws.62 The claim was not presented in the complaint.63 It was not ruled on below.64 It was not included in the questions presented on certiorari.65
No. The established facts show that respondents' complaint alleged only a conspiracy for the purpose of denying women their right to privacy.66 It did not set forth a claim under the hindrance clause.67 Neither the district court nor the court of appeals considered the application of that clause.68 The issue is not fairly included within the questions on which certiorari was granted.69 The Court declined to accept a supplemental brief addressing it.70
The hindrance clause of 42 U.S.C. § 1985(3) does not apply on this record because the claim was not properly presented.71
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Blackmun
Joined by Justice Blackmun
Whether respondents were entitled to attorney's fees under 42 U.S.C. § 1988 after their § 1985(3) claims failed?79
Because respondents were not entitled to relief under § 1985(3), they were not entitled to attorney's fees and costs under 42 U.S.C. § 1988.80
Respondents were not entitled to attorney's fees under 42 U.S.C. § 1988.83