70 A.2d 5 (Del. Ch. 1949)
The amended complaint in Brophy v. Cities Service Co. alleged four causes of action.1 Only one sought relief against Thomas F. Kennedy.2
With the exception of Kennedy, the individual defendants were directors of Cities Service Company throughout the period involved in the action and constituted the controlling majority of the board.3
Kennedy was employed in an “executive capacity” and as “confidential secretary” to the defendant, W. Alton Jones, a director and officer of Cities Service Company.4 In those capacities he had access to confidential information concerning Cities Service Company and its operations and the operations of its subsidiaries.5
The complaint alleged that by reason of his employment, Kennedy knew in advance from 1932 to the date of filing the amended complaint when Cities Service Company, or its controlled subsidiaries, intended to purchase shares of Cities Service Company’s stock on the open market in quantities sufficient to cause a rise in its market price.6 Knowing in advance when such purchases were to be made, Kennedy acquired for his personal account, or for the account of his nominees, Cities Service Company’s shares prior to the purchase by the company. He thereafter sold them at a profit resulting from the rise in the market price incident to the purchase by Cities Service Company.7
The relief sought against Kennedy was that he be directed to account as a constructive trustee for all profits made by him from the purchase and sale of such stock.8 The complaint alleged that Kennedy and other defendants used confidential and secret information to their own advantage and to the detriment of Cities Service. This was done by acquiring shares in advance for their personal accounts and selling said shares at profits resulting from the rise of the market price incident to the purchase by Cities Service.9
Whether the amended complaint states a cause of action against Thomas F. Kennedy?10
Constructive trusts depend for their existence on the wrongful conduct of a defendant causing unjust enrichment, and not on the intent of the parties.11 A mere employee does not ordinarily occupy a position of trust and confidence toward his employer.12 But if an employee in the course of his employment acquires secret information relating to his employer’s business, he occupies a position of trust and confidence toward it analogous in most respects to that of a fiduciary, and must govern his actions accordingly.13 A fiduciary is subject to a duty to the beneficiary not to use, on his own account, information confidentially given him by the beneficiary or acquired by him during the course of or on account of the fiduciary relation, in competition with or to the injury of the beneficiary.14 When a person in a confidential or fiduciary position, in breach of his duty, uses his knowledge to make a profit for himself, he is accountable for such profit.15 Public policy will not permit an employee occupying a position of trust and confidence toward his employer to abuse that relation to his own profit, regardless of whether his employer suffers a loss.16
Yes. The amended complaint alleges that Kennedy occupied a position of trust and confidence toward Cities Service Company by reason of his employment as executive and confidential secretary to one of its officers and directors.17 It further alleges that he acquired knowledge of the company's plans to purchase its own stock through that confidential employment and used the information to purchase and sell the stock for his personal profit. These facts establish the existence of a confidential relation and a breach of the duty not to use such information for personal gain.
Because the rule does not require an allegation of loss to the corporation when an accounting for profits is sought, the complaint states a cause of action against Kennedy.18
The motion to dismiss the amended complaint is therefore denied.19