355 S.W.2d 742 (Tex. Civ. App. 1962)
John L. Dellinger sued George Thompson Brown and Dan Christian Woldert, Jr., minors between seven and eight years of age who were represented by guardians ad litem, to recover damages to his house and furnishings from a fire that occurred on January 23, 1959.1 On that date Dellinger and his wife were out of town in Austin.2 Their garage was attached to their residence and had a canvas curtain or tarpaulin closing the entrance that was weighted down with boards and fastened with fasteners.3 The two boys gained entrance to the garage and discovered a small portable charcoal grill which they moved within a short distance of the inside of the curtain.4
The boys secured leaves from a pile outside the garage and filled the grill with them. Woldert went to his nearby home to obtain matches and returned, after which the boys ignited the leaves in the grill.5 They experienced difficulty and Woldert made two additional trips home for more matches before they succeeded in lighting the fire.6 The boys then stood with their backs toward the fire to warm themselves on the cold morning before discovering that the canvas curtain had caught fire.7
The fire spread rapidly from the grill to the curtain and then to the garage, house, and contents, causing damage in excess of $28,000.8 The boys were unable to extinguish the fire but escaped the garage safely.9 Prior to the incident the boys had played in the Dellingers' yard, been in the house when the owners were present, and assisted Dellinger in burning leaves on an adjacent lot during which he cautioned them to keep back from the fire.10 There was also evidence that the boys had played in the garage before the fire.11
Dellinger had never permitted the boys to play with fire or build a fire in the garage.12 Neither he nor his wife had given the boys express or implied authority to build a fire in the grill or play with matches on the premises.13 The parties made stipulations and submitted depositions to the record. Dellinger filed an amended motion for partial summary judgment on the issue of liability which the trial court sustained while denying the defendants' motions.14 The parties stipulated the amount of damages and the trial court entered final judgment for the plaintiff from which the defendants appealed.15
Whether the minor defendants became trespassers as a matter of law when they ignited the fire in the charcoal grill in the plaintiff's garage?16
Yes. The boys had entered the Dellinger yard and house only when owners were present and had assisted with leaf burning under direct supervision and caution, yet on January 23, 1959, with the owners absent in Austin, they entered the attached garage, moved the portable charcoal grill near the fastened canvas curtain, gathered leaves, made multiple trips for matches, and ignited the fire inside without any express or implied authority.19
The minor defendants became trespassers as a matter of law.20
Whether minors between seven and eight years of age can be held civilly liable for their voluntary and purposeful acts that damaged the plaintiff's property?21
Minors are civilly liable for their own torts, including trespasses to property, when they possess sufficient capacity to perform the physical acts in question even if they lack intent to cause the resulting harm.22
Yes. The seven- and eight-year-old boys, described as normal with average or above-average intelligence, voluntarily secured leaves, obtained matches from home on three occasions, filled and ignited the grill inside the garage, and stood warming themselves, acts they completed successfully and thus had capacity to perform.23
The minors can be held civilly liable for the damage caused.24
Whether the trial court correctly granted partial summary judgment on liability where the record contained no unresolved material fact issues?25
Summary judgment on liability is proper when stipulations, depositions, and the record establish that defendants committed a trespass as a matter of law and no genuine issue of material fact remains for trial.26
Yes. The parties' stipulations confirmed the boys' unauthorized entry into the garage and their ignition of the fire in the charcoal grill without any consent. Depositions established that Dellinger had never permitted the boys to play with fire or build fires on the premises and that neither express nor implied authority existed for such acts. The resulting damage exceeded $28,000, and the record presented no genuine disputes on the elements of trespass or the boys' capacity to perform the physical acts at issue.27
The trial court correctly granted the partial summary judgment.28
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Davis dissented from the affirmance of the summary judgment. He observed that the transcript contained no evidence of service of citation upon the minor defendants themselves, which is a necessity under Texas law.29 An attorney can represent minors but cannot waive or admit away any substantial rights of the minors, and all facts must be proved rather than stipulated against minors under nine years of age.30
Additionally, a question of fact existed as to consent because the plaintiff testified by deposition that the two minors had played in his garage before and were welcome to do so. The attorneys for the minors lacked authority to stipulate otherwise.31 Therefore, Justice Davis would reverse the summary judgment.32