504 U.S. 428 (1992)
In 1986, petitioner Burdick, a registered voter in the city and county of Honolulu, learned that only one candidate had filed nominating papers to run for the Hawaii House of Representatives seat in his district.1 He wrote to state officials inquiring about Hawaii’s write-in voting policy.2 He received a copy of an opinion letter issued by the Hawaii Attorney General’s Office stating that the State’s election law made no provision for write-in voting.3
Burdick filed this lawsuit.4 He claimed that he wished to vote in the primary and general elections for a person who had not filed nominating papers.5 He also claimed that he wished to vote in future elections for other persons whose names might not appear on the ballot.6 The United States District Court for the District of Hawaii concluded that the ban on write-in voting violated petitioner’s First Amendment right of expression and association.7 It entered a preliminary injunction ordering respondents to provide for the casting and tallying of write-in votes in the November 1986 general election.8
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit entered a stay and vacated the district court judgment.9 It reasoned that consideration of the federal constitutional question was premature because neither the plain language of Hawaii statutes nor any definitive judicial interpretation established that the legislature had enacted a ban on write-in voting.10 The Ninth Circuit ordered the district court to abstain under Pullman until state courts had determined whether Hawaii’s election laws permitted write-in voting.11
On remand, the district court certified three questions to the Supreme Court of Hawaii asking whether the state constitution or election laws required or permitted election officials to allow, count, and publish write-in votes.12 Hawaii’s high court answered no to all three questions.13 It held that Hawaii’s election laws barred write-in voting and that these measures were consistent with the State’s Constitution.14
The district court granted petitioner’s renewed motion for summary judgment and injunctive relief but entered a stay pending appeal.15 The Ninth Circuit reversed, holding that Hawaii was not required to provide for write-in votes.16 The Supreme Court granted certiorari to resolve the disagreement on this question.17
Whether Hawaii’s prohibition on write-in voting unreasonably infringes upon its citizens’ rights under the First and Fourteenth Amendments?18
A court considering a challenge to a state election law must weigh the character and magnitude of the asserted injury to the rights protected by the First and Fourteenth Amendments that the plaintiff seeks to vindicate against the precise interests put forward by the State as justifications for the burden imposed by its rule.19 The court must take into consideration the extent to which those interests make it necessary to burden the plaintiff’s rights.20 When those rights are subjected to severe restrictions, the regulation must be narrowly drawn to advance a state interest of compelling importance.21 But when a state election law provision imposes only reasonable, nondiscriminatory restrictions upon the First and Fourteenth Amendment rights of voters, the State’s important regulatory interests are generally sufficient to justify the restrictions.22
No. In 1986, petitioner Burdick, a registered voter in the city and county of Honolulu, learned that only one candidate had filed nominating papers to run for the Hawaii House of Representatives seat in his district. He received confirmation from the Hawaii Attorney General’s Office that the State’s election law made no provision for write-in voting.23 Burdick filed this lawsuit claiming he wished to vote for persons who had not filed nominating papers.24 The United States District Court for the District of Hawaii entered a preliminary injunction ordering respondents to provide for the casting and tallying of write-in votes in the November 1986 general election.25 The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit vacated the judgment and ordered abstention under Pullman until state courts determined whether Hawaii’s election laws permitted write-in voting.26
On remand the district court certified three questions to the Supreme Court of Hawaii, which answered no to all three and held that Hawaii’s election laws barred write-in voting.27 The district court then granted summary judgment and injunctive relief.28 The Ninth Circuit reversed.29 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.30 Applying the Anderson standard to these facts shows that Hawaii’s election laws afford adequate ballot access through party petitions, established parties, and nonpartisan ballots until two months before the primary, rendering any burden on voters’ rights limited rather than severe.31 The State’s interests in avoiding factionalism, preventing sore-loser candidacies, and guarding against party raiding are sufficient to justify that limited burden under the flexible standard that applies to reasonable, nondiscriminatory restrictions.32
Hawaii’s prohibition on write-in voting does not unreasonably infringe upon its citizens’ rights under the First and Fourteenth Amendments.33
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Kennedy dissents on the ground that Hawaii’s write-in ban, considered together with its ballot access rules, imposes a significant and recurring burden on voters’ right to cast a meaningful vote for the candidate of their choice.34 He notes that Democratic candidates frequently run unopposed in state legislative races.35 Large percentages of voters cast blank ballots in those races.36
The early deadlines and single-ballot requirement for nonpartisan and third-party candidates create substantial disincentives that compound the injury.37 In his view the State’s asserted interests in preventing sore-loser candidacies and party raiding are not advanced to any significant degree by a total ban.38 The ban applies even in primaries and is overinclusive.39
Therefore the ban cannot survive scrutiny at any level.40