668 A.2d 521 (Pa. 1995)
In 1986, appellant Albert Cafazzo underwent surgery for implantation of a mandibular prosthesis.1 The procedure took place at appellee Central Medical Health Services, Inc. and was performed by the appellee physician.2 The implanted device was a Proplast TMJ Implant manufactured by Vitek, Inc.3
Several years after the surgery, the device was discovered to be defective.4 In 1992, Albert Cafazzo and his wife Tammy J. Cafazzo filed a complaint against the physician and the hospital.5 The complaint alleged that all defendants sell, provide or use prosthetic devices and that they had provided, sold or otherwise placed in the stream of commerce the defective Proplast TMJ Implant.6
The complaint asserted that the prosthesis was defectively designed, unsafe for its intended use, and lacked any warning necessary to ensure safety.7 By the time suit was filed, the manufacturer Vitek, Inc. was in bankruptcy.8 Appellees filed preliminary objections in the nature of a demurrer.9
The trial court granted the demurrer, holding that the complaint failed to state a claim cognizable under Pennsylvania law. The Superior Court affirmed.10 The Pennsylvania Supreme Court granted allocatur to determine whether liability will attach under the circumstances of this case.11
Whether a hospital and a physician can be held subject to strict liability under the Restatement of Torts (Second) § 402A for defects in a product incidental to the provision of medical services?12
Section 402A of the Restatement (Second) of Torts imposes strict liability on one who sells any product in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to the user or consumer.13 This applies if the seller is engaged in the business of selling such a product and the product reaches the consumer without substantial change in condition.14 Medical service providers are not sellers under this rule when a product is merely incidental to the primary function of providing medical treatment rather than the focus of a merchandising enterprise.15
No. The established facts establish that in 1986 Albert Cafazzo underwent surgery for implantation of a mandibular prosthesis at the appellee hospital performed by the appellee physician.16 The implanted device was a Proplast TMJ Implant manufactured by Vitek, Inc. The prosthesis was incidental to the surgical procedure, which constituted the provision of medical services rather than the sale of a product.17 Appellees therefore were not engaged in the business of selling the implant within the meaning of Section 402A, and the policy considerations underlying strict liability do not support its application here.18
A hospital and a physician cannot be held subject to strict liability under the Restatement of Torts (Second) § 402A for defects in a product incidental to the provision of medical services.19
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Cappy dissents from the majority opinion.20 He contends that the majority improperly subordinates Pennsylvania precedent such as Francioni v. Gibsonia Truck Corp. to decisions from other jurisdictions.21 Cappy argues that the majority presents conflicting statements about the purpose of the Francioni test.22
He contends that the majority misapplies its prongs by sidestepping whether medical providers are in the marketing chain.23 Cappy further argues that the majority creates a new test that would exclude defendants amenable to other causes of action.24 He concludes that the majority has failed to advance with caution and that its approach risks eradicating strict liability.25