172 F.2d 80 (3d Cir. 1948)
In June 1947, Campbell Soup Company, a New Jersey corporation, entered into a written contract with George B. Wentz and Harry T. Wentz, Pennsylvania farmers, for delivery of all Chantenay red cored carrots to be grown on fifteen acres of the Wentz farm during the 1947 season.1 Delivery was to occur at Campbell's plant in Camden, New Jersey, at prices ranging from twenty-three to thirty dollars per ton according to the time of delivery.2
The Wentzes harvested approximately one hundred tons of carrots from the fifteen acres.3 Early in January 1948 they informed a Campbell representative that they would not deliver at the contract price, when the market price stood at least at ninety dollars per ton and such carrots were virtually unobtainable.4 The Wentzes sold approximately sixty-two tons to defendant Lojeski, a neighboring farmer, who resold about fifty-eight tons on the open market, half to Campbell and the balance to other purchasers.5
On January 9, 1948, Campbell instituted suits against the Wentz brothers and Lojeski to enjoin further sales of the contract carrots and to compel specific performance.6 The district court denied equitable relief.7 The cases came before the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on appeals from those judgments.8
The contract was prepared on a printed form supplied by Campbell.9 It specified that carrots were to be delivered with stalks cut off in clean sanitary bags or containers approved by Campbell, whose determination of conformance would be conclusive.10 The form allowed Campbell to refuse carrots in excess of twelve tons per acre, contained a covenant by the grower not to sell carrots to anyone else or permit others to grow them on his land, and provided liquidated damages of fifty dollars per acre for grower breaches but none for Campbell.11 One paragraph excused Campbell from accepting carrots under circumstances beyond the control of the parties or labor disturbances while stating that the grower could not sell or dispose of any carrots he was unable to deliver to Campbell.12
Whether the legal remedy is inadequate for breach of the contract for sale of Chantenay red cored carrots?13
A party may have specific performance of a contract for the sale of chattels if the legal remedy is inadequate.14 Inadequacy of the legal remedy is necessarily a matter to be determined by an examination of the facts in each particular instance.15 The test for specific performance is not necessarily objective, as equity has granted it for articles the value of which was personal to the plaintiff.16
Yes. The facts of the case establish that the legal remedy was inadequate.17
It was expressly found that at the time of the trial it was virtually impossible to obtain Chantenay carrots in the open market.18 Campbell uses these carrots in fifteen of its twenty-one soups, and the preservation of uniformity in appearance is a matter of considerable commercial significance.19 Although the carrots are not unique in nutritive value, their blunt shape, color, and texture make them particularly suitable for the plaintiff's processing needs.20 The court concluded that the goods were unavailable on the open market and that the plaintiff had contracted for them long ahead in anticipation of its needs.21 Therefore the legal remedy is inadequate.22
The legal remedy is inadequate for breach of the contract for sale of the Chantenay red cored carrots.23
Whether the terms of the printed contract between Campbell Soup Company and the Wentzes preclude equitable relief?24
Equity does not enforce unconscionable bargains.25 A party who has offered and succeeded in getting an agreement as tough as this one should not come to a chancellor and ask court help in the enforcement of its terms.26 The sum total of the provisions drives too hard a bargain for a court of conscience to assist.27
Yes. The contract terms are too one-sided to permit equitable relief.28 The agreement was made on a printed form furnished by the buyer with the buyer's interests in mind.29 Paragraph nine excuses Campbell from accepting carrots under circumstances beyond the control of the parties or labor disturbances but does not permit the grower to sell them elsewhere unless Campbell agrees.30
There is no provision for damages for breach by Campbell while the grower faces liquidated damages of fifty dollars per acre.31 The sum total of the provisions drives too hard a bargain for a court of conscience to assist.
The terms of the printed contract preclude equitable relief.32