339 F.3d 1119
Christianne Carafano, an actress known professionally as Chase Masterson for appearances in films and television shows such as Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and General Hospital, brought suit against Metrosplash.com, Inc., the operator of the Matchmaker.com online dating service, and its corporate successors.1
Matchmaker.com permits paying members to post anonymous profiles containing one or more pictures, descriptive information such as age and interests, and answers to questions designed to evoke personality, and to view profiles of and contact other members in their area via electronic mail routed through the Matchmaker server.2 Members are required to complete a detailed questionnaire containing both multiple-choice and essay questions.3 In the initial portion of the questionnaire, members select answers to more than fifty questions from menus providing between four and nineteen options.4 Matchmaker reviews photos for impropriety before posting them but does not review the profiles themselves, relying instead upon participants to adhere to the service guidelines.5
On October 23, 1999, an unknown person using a computer in Berlin posted a trial profile under the identifier Chase529 in the Los Angeles section without Carafano's knowledge, consent, or permission.6 Pictures of the actress are widely available on the Internet, and the false Matchmaker profile Chase529 contained several of these pictures.7 In response to a question about the part of the LA area in which she lived, the profile provided Carafano's home address.8 The profile included a contact email address, cmla2000@yahoo.com, which, when contacted, produced an automatic email reply stating, You think you are the right one? Proof it!! [sic], and providing Carafano's home address and telephone number.9
Carafano received sexually explicit voicemail messages on October 31, 1999, and a threatening fax upon returning home on November 4; she contacted police the next day and later received additional calls, messages, and correspondence.10 On November 6 her assistant Siouxzan Perry learned of the profile, contacted Matchmaker, and the profile was blocked from public view on November 8 and deleted early the following morning.11
Carafano filed a complaint in California state court against Matchmaker and its corporate successors, alleging invasion of privacy, misappropriation of the right of publicity, defamation, and negligence.12 The defendants removed the case to federal district court.13 The district court granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment in a published opinion. Carafano v. Metrosplash.com, Inc., 207 F. Supp. 2d 1055 (C.D. Cal. 2002).14 Carafano timely appealed.15
Whether Carafano's claims against the operator of an online dating service are barred by 47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(1)?16
Section 230(c)(1) of Title 47 provides that no provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider.17 This provision grants Internet services immunity from liability for publishing false or defamatory material when the information originates from a third party.18 It reflects Congress's intent to promote free exchange of information online and encourage voluntary monitoring without fear of tort liability.19
Yes. The Matchmaker service operated by Metrosplash qualifies as an interactive computer service under the statute because it enables multiple users to access a computer server for posting and viewing profiles.20 The profile at issue was created and posted by an unknown individual in Berlin without any involvement from Matchmaker in selecting the specific answers or including Carafano's personal details.21 Although the service provided a structured questionnaire, the user alone determined the content by choosing the options and writing the essay responses, including the home address and sexually suggestive statements.22
Matchmaker's practice of not reviewing profile text before posting confirms that it did not create or develop the underlying misinformation.23 As a result, Matchmaker did not act as an information content provider for the false profile, entitling it to full immunity from Carafano's claims.24
The application of section 230(c)(1) immunity resolves the case in favor of the service provider.25 Carafano's claims are therefore barred, and the district court's grant of summary judgment is affirmed on this statutory ground rather than the alternative grounds originally relied upon by the lower court.26