678 So. 2d 378 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1996)
River Phoenix, a young actor originally from Gainesville, Florida, died on October 31, 1993, apparently from an overdose of illegal drugs.1 At the time of his death, Phoenix had contracted to appear in two films, "Dark Blood" and "Interview With the Vampire."2 The "Dark Blood" project was abandoned following his death, while "Interview With the Vampire" was completed using a replacement actor.3
CNA International Reinsurance Co. and American Casualty, members of the CNA group of insurance companies, had issued entertainment package insurance policies covering aspects of the two productions.4 CNA paid out over $5.7 million under its policy, while American Casualty paid $15,000 of approximately $400,000 in claims.5 After making these payments, the insurers became subrogated to the claims of the insureds against Phoenix's estate.6
The insurers filed complaints against the estate.7 CNA alleged breach of contract based on an actor loanout agreement between Jude Nile, a corporation owned by Phoenix and his mother Arlyn Phoenix, and Scala Productions. American Casualty sought a declaratory judgment based on a similar agreement with Geffen Pictures.8 CNA also included a count for fraud and misrepresentation arising from a medical certificate signed by Phoenix.9
The estate moved to dismiss the complaints, arguing that the personal services contracts were impossible to perform due to Phoenix's death and that the insurance policies were not effective until November 1993, after the death.10 Following hearings, the trial court granted the motions to dismiss with prejudice.11 CNA and American Casualty then appealed, and the appeals were consolidated.12
Whether the defense of impossibility of performance due to death applies when the impossibility is, allegedly, the fault of the person obligated to perform the personal services contract?13
The doctrine of impossibility of performance discharges a party's duty to render performance when, after a contract is made, the party's performance is made impracticable without his fault by the occurrence of an event the non-occurrence of which was a basic assumption on which the contract was made. If the existence of a particular person is necessary for the performance of a duty, his death or such incapacity as makes performance impracticable is an event the nonoccurrence of which was a basic assumption on which the contract was made.14
Yes. The court determined that death renders a personal services contract impossible to perform regardless of whether the death resulted from the performer's own intentional conduct.15 Applying the rule to these facts, Phoenix's death discharged the duty to perform under the actor loanout agreements because the contracts required his personal services for the film productions. The court rejected the argument that self-induced death through illegal drugs created an exception to the doctrine.
The court observed that the parties could have specifically provided for such a contingency in the agreements as they did for other hazardous activities.
The defense of impossibility of performance due to death applies even when the death may be the result of the performer's own conduct.16
Whether the trial court erred in ruling that the effective dates of the policies of insurance involved here were in November, 1993, after the widely publicized death in question?17
Generally, the parties to a contract are competent to fix the effective date of an insurance policy.18
Yes. The policies and endorsements on their faces reflected effective dates of July 23, 1993, and August 15, 1993, which preceded Phoenix's death.19 The trial court therefore erred in holding as a matter of law that the policies became effective only upon their November 12, 1993 issuance dates.20 At minimum, further development of the record is required before any such determination can be made.21
The trial court erred in ruling that the insurance policies were effective only in November 1993.22