285 P.3d 1193 (Utah 2012)
In 1995, TCI Cablevision of Utah approached Commercial Real Estate Investment, L.C. about developing a large commercial building where TCI could operate its northern Utah cable television business.1
TCI proposed to locate a suitable site and design a building to meet its specific needs. CRE would purchase the site and construct the building to TCI's specifications. TCI further proposed to enter into a long-term lease for the building.2
TCI identified a suitable site in Riverdale, Utah. The site was located in a commercial/industrial subdivision that was largely undeveloped. CRE agreed with the proposed site. CRE anticipated that this new building might drive additional development in the subdivision, and consequently acquired another lot adjacent to the TCI lot. But CRE did not express its intentions regarding adjacent development to TCI.3
TCI's agent prepared the lease and delivered it to CRE. The lease as drafted by TCI's agent contained blanks for the rental amounts and the term of the lease. CRE approved the lease as presented. The only additions to the lease were that the rental amounts and the term had been added. In all other respects, the final lease contained the same provisions as TCI's draft lease.4
The parties signed the lease agreement in July 1995. TCI thereafter took possession and began operating its business from the building. On July 17, 2001, however, TCI ceased operations at the building and vacated the premises. In 2002, Comcast acquired TCI and succeeded to TCI's interest in the property and to its obligations under the terms of the lease. Sometime thereafter, Comcast listed the building with a realtor in an effort to locate a replacement tenant. CRE referred any inquiries regarding the property to Comcast's real estate agent, but CRE made no other efforts to find a substitute tenant. A substitute tenant took possession of the property on February 22, 2006.5
TCI and subsequently Comcast paid all rent due under the lease since July 1995, but have refused to pay any liquidated damages pursuant to Article 9 of the lease. Not counting interest, liquidated damages from July 17, 2001, to February 22, 2006, total $1,711,990.66.67
In July 2004, CRE sued Comcast for breach of contract and attorney fees.8 Both parties filed motions for partial summary judgment as to the enforceability of the liquidated damages provision. The district court granted CRE's motion for partial summary judgment. Comcast timely appealed the district court's order.9
Whether liquidated damages clauses are subject to heightened judicial scrutiny separate from general contract defenses such as unconscionability?10
Liquidated damages clauses are not subject to heightened judicial scrutiny but instead are treated like any other contractual provision and are presumed enforceable unless a party establishes unconscionability or another general contract defense such as mistake, fraud, or duress.11
No. The court surveyed prior Utah precedents that had applied conflicting standards including penalty analysis, shock the conscience review, the first Restatement test, and deference to contracting parties. It held that all such approaches should be replaced by ordinary contract principles.12
The clause was not so one-sided as to oppress the drafter or shock the conscience at the time of formation. It is therefore enforceable under ordinary contract standards without any heightened penalty or Restatement inquiry.
The court holds that liquidated damages clauses are reviewed under the same standards as other contractual provisions and are not subject to heightened judicial scrutiny.13
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Lee concurred in upholding the clause but disagreed with repudiating the Restatement test. He agreed that the reasonableness evaluation must be made at the time of contract formation rather than with hindsight. He also agreed that prior cases needed clarification on that point.14
Yet he saw no reason to abandon the Restatement standard because it supplies predictability for contracting parties. The supposed internal inconsistency is resolved by treating the difficulty-of-estimation element as a sliding scale that informs the reasonableness inquiry.15 Lee warned that replacing the settled test with an undefined unconscionability standard invites arbitrariness.
He would have affirmed on the ground that Comcast failed to present evidence showing the liquidated sum was not a reasonable forecast.16
Whether the liquidated damages clause in the lease between CRE and Comcast is unconscionable?17
A party challenging a liquidated damages clause bears the burden of proving unconscionability by clear and convincing evidence. The analysis examines both procedural unconscionability focused on the bargaining process and substantive unconscionability focused on whether the terms are so one-sided as to oppress or unfairly surprise a party.18
No. Comcast bore the heavy burden of establishing unconscionability yet presented no evidence of procedural defects and could not show substantive unfairness.19 The lease clause was drafted by TCI's agent and presented to CRE for approval. Comcast stood in the shoes of the drafter and could not claim overreaching or unequal bargaining power.20 Substantive review at the time of formation reveals no oppression.
The clause simply required continuous operation of a purpose-built facility and scaled damages to the duration of any breach. Post hoc comparison of the $1,711,990.66 figure to actual damages is irrelevant to the unconscionability inquiry.21 The district court correctly found no hallmarks of unconscionability.22 The supreme court affirmed that the clause is enforceable.23
The court holds that the liquidated damages clause is not unconscionable and is therefore enforceable.24
Whether CRE breached its duty to mitigate damages from the tenant's breach of the continuous operation covenant?25
A landlord has a contractual and common-law duty to take commercially reasonable steps to mitigate damages from a tenant's breach. The breaching tenant bears the burden of proving failure to mitigate and must offer evidence that would allow a factfinder to determine what additional steps were reasonably required.26
No. CRE had a contractual duty to exercise reasonable best efforts to mitigate. Comcast failed to carry its burden of proving any breach of that duty.27 It is undisputed that CRE referred all inquiries to Comcast's own real estate agent and that Comcast listed the property. But Comcast offered no evidence of what more CRE could or should have done in the commercial real estate market at the pertinent point in time or whether any other tenant would have satisfied the continuous-operation requirement.28
Because the tenant asserting failure to mitigate must produce evidence sufficient to submit the issue to a jury and Comcast produced none, the district court correctly rejected the mitigation defense.29
The court holds that CRE did not breach its duty to mitigate damages.30