182 Mass. 250, 65 N.E. 69 (1902)
The plaintiff brought two separate actions against two defendants for injuries sustained in an accident.1 The actions were brought severally rather than jointly.2
The bill of exceptions does not set forth what instructions were given, and we must assume that they were appropriate to the case as presented by the evidence, and were correct.3 The only question which arises in these cases is whether the judge erred in refusing to give the instructions requested.4
The verdict of the jury has established the fact that both of the defendants were wrongdoers.5 It makes no difference that there was no concert between them, or that it is impossible to determine what portion of the injury was caused by each.6 If each contributed to the injury, that is enough to bind both.7
Whether the judge erred in refusing to give the instructions requested?8
The bill of exceptions does not set forth what instructions were given, and we must assume that they were appropriate to the case as presented by the evidence, and were correct.
No. The only question which arises in these cases is whether the judge erred in refusing to give the instructions requested.9 The bill of exceptions does not set forth what instructions were given, and we must assume that they were appropriate to the case as presented by the evidence, and were correct.
The judge committed no error in refusing the requested instructions.10
The judge did not err in refusing to give the instructions requested.11
Whether defendants who contribute to an injury without concert between them may each be held liable when sued severally?12
If two or more wrongdoers contribute to the injury, they may be sued either jointly or severally.13
Yes. The verdict of the jury has established the fact that both of the defendants were wrongdoers.14 It makes no difference that there was no concert between them, or that it is impossible to determine what portion of the injury was caused by each. If each contributed to the injury, that is enough to bind both.
The suits were brought severally rather than jointly.15 If two or more wrongdoers contribute to the injury, they may be sued either jointly or severally.
Defendants who contribute to an injury without concert between them may each be held liable when sued severally.16
Whether the jury may single out one defendant as solely to blame when both contributed to the accident?17
If both defendants contributed to the accident, the jury could not single out one as the person to blame.18 There being two actions, the plaintiff was entitled to judgment against each for the full amount.19 There is no injustice in this, for a satisfaction of one judgment is all that the plaintiff is entitled to.20
No. If both defendants contributed to the accident, the jury could not single out one as the person to blame.21 There being two actions, the plaintiff was entitled to judgment against each for the full amount. There is no injustice in this, for a satisfaction of one judgment is all that the plaintiff is entitled to.
The jury found for the plaintiff in each case, establishing that both defendants contributed to the injury.22
The jury may not single out one defendant as solely to blame when both contributed to the accident.23