424 U.S. 351, 96 S.Ct. 933, 47 L.Ed.2d 43 (Sup.Ct.1976)
In 1971 the California Legislature added section 2805 to the Labor Code.1 Subdivision (a) provides that no employer shall knowingly employ an alien who is not entitled to lawful residence in the United States if such employment would have an adverse effect on lawful resident workers.2 Petitioners, who are migrant farmworkers, brought this action pursuant to subdivision (c) against respondent farm labor contractors in California Superior Court.3
The complaint alleged that respondents had refused petitioners continued employment due to a surplus of labor resulting from respondents’ knowing employment, in violation of section 2805(a), of aliens not lawfully admitted to residence in the United States.4 Petitioners sought reinstatement and a permanent injunction against respondents’ willful employment of illegal aliens.5
The Superior Court, in an unreported opinion, dismissed the complaint, holding that Labor Code 2805 is unconstitutional because it encroaches upon and interferes with a comprehensive regulatory scheme enacted by Congress in the exercise of its exclusive power over immigration.6 The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, affirmed in 1974, holding that section 2805(a) is an attempt to regulate the conditions for admission of foreign nationals.7
The Supreme Court of California denied review.8 The United States Supreme Court granted certiorari in 1975.9
Whether California Labor Code § 2805(a) is unconstitutional because it constitutes an attempt to regulate immigration and naturalization?10
Power to regulate immigration is exclusively a federal power. The Court has never held that every state enactment which in any way deals with aliens is a regulation of immigration and thus per se pre-empted by this constitutional power.11 A regulation of immigration is essentially a determination of who should or should not be admitted into the country, and the conditions under which a legal entrant may remain.12
No. California Labor Code § 2805(a) prohibits employers from knowingly employing an alien who is not entitled to lawful residence in the United States if such employment would have an adverse effect on lawful resident workers.13 The statute seeks to strengthen California's economy by adopting federal standards in imposing criminal sanctions against state employers who knowingly employ aliens who have no federal right to employment within the country.14 Even if such local regulation has some purely speculative and indirect impact on immigration, it does not thereby become a constitutionally proscribed regulation of immigration that Congress itself would be powerless to authorize or approve.15
California Labor Code § 2805(a) is not unconstitutional because it constitutes an attempt to regulate immigration and naturalization.16
Whether California Labor Code § 2805(a) is preempted under the Supremacy Clause by the Immigration and Nationality Act?17
Federal regulation should not be deemed preemptive of state regulatory power in the absence of persuasive reasons. Either the nature of the regulated subject matter permits no other conclusion or Congress has unmistakably so ordained.18 States possess broad authority under their police powers to regulate the employment relationship to protect workers within the State. Only a demonstration that complete ouster of state power was the clear and manifest purpose of Congress would justify preemption.19
No. The nature of the regulated subject matter of employment of illegal aliens does not permit only a federal conclusion. Congress has not unmistakably ordained that result in the INA.20 The central concern of the INA is with the terms and conditions of admission to the country and the subsequent treatment of aliens lawfully in the country.21 Respondents fail to point out any specific indication in either the wording or the legislative history of the INA that Congress intended to preclude even harmonious state regulation touching on the employment of illegal aliens in particular.22
The 1974 amendments to the Farm Labor Contractor Registration Act provide that the chapter is intended to supplement State action. Compliance with the chapter shall not excuse anyone from compliance with appropriate State law and regulation. This is persuasive evidence that the INA should not be taken as legislation by Congress expressing its judgment to have uniform federal regulations in matters affecting employment of illegal aliens.23
California Labor Code § 2805(a) is not preempted under the Supremacy Clause by the Immigration and Nationality Act.24