54 P.3d 893 (Colo. 2002)
In August 1994 the Denver Publishing Company, doing business as the Rocky Mountain News, published a four-page article headlined "Denver's Biggest Crime Family."1
The story's first page depicted a family tree centered on a 1937 wedding photograph of Pete and Della Bueno.2 Mug-shot style photographs of their eighteen children encircled the parents' photo.3 Captions summarized each of the Bueno siblings' misdeeds, misfortunes, and criminal records.4 The caption under Bueno's photo read, "EDDIE, 55 Oldest of the Bueno children."5 The article's first-page subtitle declared, "15 of Pete and Della Bueno's 18 children have arrest records, making the clan Denver's biggest crime family."6
Eddie Bueno, then fifty-five, had left the family home at age thirteen and thereafter maintained virtually no contact with his parents or siblings.7 He married at twenty-one, served six years in the United States Army and received an honorable discharge, and for twenty-five years had worked his way up to center supervisor in the City and County of Denver's vehicle maintenance department.8 He had three adult children, had never been involved in his siblings' criminal activities, and had kept his relationship to the other Bueno children secret from most friends and family.9
A News reporter spent six months on the story, interviewed law enforcement officials, reviewed court and police records, and spoke with seven of the surviving siblings.10 She attempted three times to reach Eddie Bueno by telephone but received no response.11 The published article contained a statement on its final page, seven paragraphs from the end, that "Freddie, the youngest, and Eddie, the oldest, are the only two Bueno boys who have stayed out of trouble."12
Bueno sued the News and Ann Carnahan, contending the story defamed him and invaded his privacy.13 He asserted claims for false-light invasion of privacy, public disclosure of private facts, libel per se, libel per quod, and negligence.14 Before trial the court granted summary judgment to the defendants on the negligence and public-disclosure claims.15 At the close of evidence the trial judge directed a verdict against Bueno on both defamation claims.16
The false-light claim was submitted to the jury, which returned a verdict for Bueno awarding $47,973.90 in noneconomic damages, $5,280 in economic damages, and $53,253.90 in exemplary damages.17 The defendants appealed and Bueno cross-appealed the directed verdict on defamation.18 The court of appeals affirmed the false-light judgment.19 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.20
Whether Colorado should recognize the tort of false light invasion of privacy?21
The tort of false light invasion of privacy substantially overlaps with defamation both in the conduct alleged and the interests protected.22 Its subjective highly offensive standard risks an unacceptable chilling effect on First Amendment freedoms.23 Therefore Colorado declines to recognize the tort.24
No. The publication by Denver Publishing Co. of the family tree, Eddie Bueno's photograph and caption, and the surrounding statements about the crime family produced conduct that could support a defamation claim. Yet the trial court directed a verdict on defamation while allowing the false-light claim to reach the jury.25 Because the elements of the two torts are nearly identical apart from the distinction between defamatory and highly offensive, and because the interests protected reduce to reputation with the same overtones of mental distress, defamation adequately protects plaintiffs without the added subjectivity and chill of false light.26
Colorado does not recognize the tort of false light invasion of privacy.27
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Martinez And Justice Rice
Chief Justice Mullarkey dissents because the majority fails to sufficiently justify its decision to eliminate the tort of false light invasion of privacy from Colorado.28 He argues that any overlap with defamation can be addressed by precluding duplicative damages awards rather than foreclosing the claim entirely.29 He maintains that false light incorporates the same actual-malice standard that protects First Amendment interests in defamation cases.30
The decision places Colorado at odds with the clear majority of states and produces an unfair result for Eddie Bueno by setting aside the jury verdict.31
Whether a publication is actionable as false light when any allegedly offensive implications it creates are refuted by statements in the report plainly to the contrary?32
Because Colorado does not recognize the tort of false light invasion of privacy, the court does not reach the question whether a publication containing plainly contradictory statements can still be actionable.33
No. The clarifying statement on the final page of the article that Eddie and Freddie Bueno were the only brothers who stayed out of trouble directly refutes any implication that Eddie Bueno had engaged in criminal activity.34 Because the court declines to recognize false light at all, it does not decide whether such a refutation would defeat the claim.35
The court does not reach this question because it declines to recognize the tort of false light invasion of privacy.36
Whether a plaintiff must prove special damages as an element of false light in Colorado?37
Because Colorado does not recognize the tort of false light invasion of privacy, the court does not reach the question whether special damages are required.38
The court does not reach this question because it declines to recognize the tort of false light invasion of privacy.