17 F. Cas. 144 (1861)
John Merryman resided in Baltimore County, Maryland.1 In the early morning hours of May 25, 1861, an armed force professing to act under military orders entered his home while he was peaceably with his family.2 He was compelled to rise from his bed, taken into custody, and conveyed to Fort McHenry, where General George Cadwalader held him in confinement.3
The application for a writ of habeas corpus was made to Circuit Justice Taney under the fourteenth section of the Judiciary Act of 1789.4 Although the petition was presented to Taney in Washington, he resolved to hear the matter in Baltimore because the prisoner was confined there within his circuit.5 The writ was served on General Cadwalader, requiring him to produce Merryman before the court.6
In response, General Cadwalader admitted the facts of the arrest and detention but refused to obey the writ.7 He explained that Merryman had been arrested by order of General Keim of Pennsylvania and placed in his custody.8 Cadwalader claimed he was authorized by the President to suspend the writ of habeas corpus and, in the exercise of that authority, declined to produce the prisoner or provide a copy of any warrant.9
No specific act constituting an offense against the laws of the United States had been charged against Merryman upon oath.10 The arrest occurred upon general charges of treason and rebellion without proof or specification of witnesses or acts.11 No official notice of any presidential suspension of the writ had been given to the courts or the public by proclamation or otherwise.12
Whether the President of the United States possesses authority to suspend the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus?13
The Constitution locates the suspension power exclusively in Article I, Section 9.14 This provision is addressed to the legislative department that enumerates powers granted to Congress.15 It expressly prohibits suspension of the writ except when the public safety requires it in cases of rebellion or invasion.16 Article II confers no corresponding authority on the President.17
No. The established facts show that General Cadwalader refused to produce John Merryman in response to the writ served upon him, asserting that he acted under presidential authorization to suspend the privilege.18 The constitutional text places the suspension clause in the legislative article immediately after the enumeration of congressional powers and before the necessary-and-proper clause, demonstrating that only Congress may exercise it.19 Historical practice during the Burr conspiracy confirms this allocation: President Jefferson transmitted evidence to Congress and sought legislative action rather than claiming unilateral power.20 The President’s constitutional duty is limited to taking care that the laws are faithfully executed, which does not include suspending constitutional privileges or authorizing military officers to disregard judicial process.21
The President does not possess authority to suspend the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus.22
Whether the President may delegate to a military officer the discretion to suspend the writ of habeas corpus and refuse obedience to a judicial writ?23
No. The established facts establish that General Cadwalader, a military officer stationed in Pennsylvania, claimed presidential authorization to suspend the writ and therefore declined to produce Merryman or furnish a copy of any warrant when the writ was served at Fort McHenry.26 The Constitution assigns no suspension power to the executive, so no delegation is possible.27 The return to the writ rested solely on the asserted presidential order, without any claim that Congress had acted, confirming that the refusal constituted an unauthorized substitution of military discretion for judicial process.28
The President may not delegate to a military officer the discretion to suspend the writ of habeas corpus and refuse obedience to a judicial writ.29
Whether a military officer may detain a civilian arrested at home without a warrant or specific charges supported by oath when served with a writ of habeas corpus?30
The Fifth Amendment guarantees that no person shall be deprived of liberty without due process of law.31 This requires judicial process supported by oath or affirmation.32 A military officer may not detain a civilian on vague charges of treason or rebellion once a writ of habeas corpus has been served unless Congress has validly suspended the privilege.33
No. The established facts demonstrate that an armed force entered Merryman’s home in Baltimore County at two o’clock in the morning, seized him from his bed without any warrant, and conveyed him to Fort McHenry on general charges of treason and rebellion unsupported by oath or specification of witnesses or acts.34 When the writ issued under the Judiciary Act of 1789 was served, General Cadwalader continued the detention solely on the basis of the claimed presidential suspension.35 The Fifth Amendment’s due-process requirement and the Sixth Amendment’s guarantees of speedy trial and confrontation apply to civilians and cannot be displaced by military order when the writ remains in force.36
A military officer may not detain a civilian arrested at home without a warrant or specific charges supported by oath when served with a writ of habeas corpus.37