480 U.S. 245 (1987)
Over the past thirty years, utility companies throughout the country entered into arrangements for the leasing of space on poles to operators of cable television systems.1 These contracts generally provided for the payment by the cable companies of a yearly rent for space on each pole, with the fixed costs of modifications and installation borne by the cable operators.2 In many states the rates charged for these attachments were not subject to regulation.3
In response to arguments by cable operators that utility companies were exploiting their monopoly position by engaging in widespread overcharging, Congress enacted the Pole Attachments Act.4 The Act authorizes the Federal Communications Commission to regulate the rates, terms, and conditions for pole attachments to ensure they are just and reasonable in states without parallel regulation.5 The Act sets a standard for rates ranging from the additional costs of providing attachments to a formula based on the percentage of usable space occupied multiplied by operating expenses and capital costs.6
In 1963, Florida Power Corporation entered into a pole attachment agreement with Cox Cablevision Corporation at a rate of $5.50 per pole.7 Florida Power subsequently contracted with Teleprompter Corporation in 1977 at $6.24 per pole and with Acton CATV, Inc. in 1980 at $7.15 per pole.8 In November 1980 Teleprompter filed a complaint with the FCC, followed by Acton in February 1981 and Cox in July 1981, alleging the rates were unreasonable.9
The FCC's Common Carrier Bureau issued orders reducing the rates to $1.79 per pole and requiring refunds of excess rents.10 In September 1984 the FCC affirmed these orders in a single decision.11 Florida Power then sought review in the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, which held the Act unconstitutional in a per curiam opinion.12 The FCC and intervening cable operators appealed, and the Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction and consolidated the cases for argument.13
Whether the Pole Attachments Act authorizes a permanent physical occupation of utility poles?14
A government-authorized permanent physical occupation constitutes a per se taking under the Fifth Amendment.15 This rule applies only when the statute requires the property owner to suffer the occupation by a third party.16 It is distinguished from voluntary commercial arrangements subject to rate regulation.17
No. The Pole Attachments Act regulates rates charged under voluntary pole attachment agreements that utility companies like Florida Power have entered with cable operators such as Cox, Teleprompter, and Acton.18 The Act does not compel any utility to grant access or prohibit termination of existing contracts.19 The FCC orders merely reformed the rents in those preexisting leases from $5.50, $6.24, and $7.15 per pole down to the statutory maximum of fully allocated cost at $1.79 per pole.20
The Pole Attachments Act does not authorize a permanent physical occupation of utility poles.21
Whether the rates set by the FCC under the Pole Attachments Act effect a taking of property without just compensation?22
No. The FCC calculated the $1.79 per pole rate according to the statutory formula.26 This formula multiplies the percentage of usable space occupied by the sum of operating expenses and actual capital costs attributable to the entire pole.27 It thereby allows Florida Power full recovery of allocated costs rather than limiting it to marginal cost alone.28 Florida Power has never contended that this fully allocated cost measure is confiscatory.29
The rates set by the FCC under the Pole Attachments Act do not effect a taking of property without just compensation.30
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Powell joined the majority.31 He emphasized that judicial review of administrative ratemaking under the Fifth Amendment requires careful consideration of the specific statute, the agency's action, and multiple additional factors.32 This approach is preferable to reliance on any single sentence from precedent.33
He noted that the full Permian Basin opinion and related cases such as Hope Natural Gas demonstrate a more complex standard.34 The standard focuses on whether the return to equity owners is commensurate with risks in comparable enterprises.35 Yet he agreed that the rates at issue here clearly satisfy constitutional requirements.36
Whether the Pole Attachments Act unconstitutionally assigns the initial determination of just compensation to an administrative agency subject to judicial review?37
When no taking occurs under the Fifth Amendment, any question concerning the allocation of initial compensation determinations between an agency and the courts does not arise.38
No. The Pole Attachments Act effects no taking of Florida Power's property under the Fifth Amendment.39 Therefore, the Eleventh Circuit's separate holding that Congress unconstitutionally constrained the judicial function by prescribing standards for agency rate determinations necessarily falls.40 No further examination of that issue is required.41
The Pole Attachments Act does not unconstitutionally assign the initial determination of just compensation to an administrative agency subject to judicial review.42