337 Pa. 136, 10 A.2d 576 (1940)
In August 1937 the plaintiff was riding as a passenger in the first of three cars on a southbound train operated by the defendant in Philadelphia's Broad Street subway.1
At City Hall station he alighted and walked south along the platform with the standing train to his right.2 For an unexplained reason he slipped from the platform into the path of the train, which had begun to move, falling at a point immediately in front of the lead car and outside the motorman's range of vision.3 The train traveled about three-fourths of a car length before an automatic stop was triggered when some object contacted the tripper, a mechanical device extending down behind the front wheel.4
A passenger named Rodgers who had alighted from the same car saw the plaintiff fall.5 Rodgers stepped to the side of the train and spoke to the conductor who was looking out the rear window of the first car.6 Rodgers told the conductor there was a man underneath the train, although the conductor later denied the conversation.7 The conductor went forward and he and the motorman stepped onto the platform to investigate.8
The motorman took a flashlight and examined the front of the train, looked under each motor and under the train, crossed in front, crawled along the third rail, and put his hand on the platform while searching.9 The conductor made a more cursory inspection.10 Rodgers testified that the crew looked only under the front trucks with a searchlight before climbing back into the train without further searching.11 The train then proceeded south and passed over the plaintiff's body.12 The plaintiff suffered severe injuries including loss of his right foot at the ankle and his left leg between the knee and hip.13 Four minutes elapsed from the train's initial movement until the search concluded and the train departed.14
The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff in the amount of $33,487.74.15 The defendant moved for a new trial on grounds of excessiveness, rejected testimony, and errors in the charge, and also moved for judgment n.o.v.16 The court in banc granted the motion for judgment n.o.v. without ruling on the new-trial motion.17 The plaintiff appealed.18 Pending argument on the judgment motion the plaintiff moved to amend the statement of claim to add a charge of ordinary negligence and to attribute the loss of his right foot to the restarting of the train.19
Whether the evidence at trial was sufficient to permit a jury to find that the defendant's employees received notice of the plaintiff's presence under the train?20
The legal obligation to trespassers has been traditionally stated to be the avoidance of wilful or wanton negligence.21 It is not wanton negligence to fail to use care to discover the presence of an unanticipated trespasser, but it is wanton negligence, within the meaning of the law, to fail to use ordinary and reasonable care to avoid injury to a trespasser after his presence has been ascertained.22
Yes. The automatic stop brought to the attention of the train crew the fact that some object had come in contact with the tripper.23 If Rodgers' testimony was believed by the jury it meant that a person who could have had no self-interest or improper motive and was therefore presumably credible told the conductor there is a man down under there.24 The emergency stop and the information given by Rodgers cumulatively constituted impressive warning as to the situation.25
The evidence at trial was sufficient to permit a jury to find that the defendant's employees received notice of the plaintiff's presence under the train.26
Whether the motorman and conductor conducted an adequate search for the plaintiff after any such notice?27
Yes. The motorman knew that the train had proceeded three-quarters of a car length after the emergency brake first went on, from which it could have been readily inferred that the object, whatever it was, which had come in contact with the tripper, was probably to be found in the vicinity of the rear trucks of the front car.30 According to the testimony produced at the trial only four minutes elapsed from the time the train first started to move until the accident had occurred, the search had been made, and the train finally left the station.31 The plaintiff contends that the motorman could not in that time have conducted as intensive an investigation as he claims to have made.32
If that tribunal concluded that defendant was sufficiently notified of plaintiff's presence under the train to fasten upon defendant the duty of thereafter exercising due care for his safety, it was for them also to determine whether the actual search made by the motorman was as exhaustive as it should have been in the light of the obviously terrible injuries to which a person under the train was likely to be subjected.33
It was for the jury to determine whether the motorman and conductor conducted an adequate search for the plaintiff after notice.34
Whether the trial court erred in granting judgment notwithstanding the verdict on the record presented?35
Whether, in the present case, defendant's employees were put on notice that a person was underneath the train was for the jury to determine; there certainly was sufficient evidence to warrant the submission to them of that question.36
Yes. The circumstances were somewhat the same as if a huntsman were to see what appeared to be a human being moving about in a clump of bushes, or were informed that there was a trespasser there, and then, without first ascertaining the latter's exact position, shot indiscriminately into the bushes and wounded him.37 This was all for the jury.38 It follows that the trial court erred in entering judgment for the defendant notwithstanding the verdict.39
The trial court erred in granting judgment notwithstanding the verdict on the record presented.40
Whether the plaintiff should have been allowed to amend the statement of claim after verdict to conform to the trial evidence?41
Yes. The change in the averment as to the injury to the right foot conformed to the testimony given at the trial.44 Whether this testimony was objected to when offered does not appear in the printed record.45 Had it been so objected to, the statement of claim could then have been amended, subject to a plea of surprise.46 The trial court was therefore in error in overruling the motion to amend.47
The plaintiff should have been allowed to amend the statement of claim after verdict to conform to the trial evidence.48