569 U.S. 66 (2013)
In February 2009, Laura Symczyk, a registered nurse formerly employed by Genesis Healthcare Corporation at its Pennypack Center facility in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, filed a complaint in federal district court on behalf of herself and all other persons similarly situated.1 She alleged that the facility violated the Fair Labor Standards Act by automatically deducting thirty minutes from employees' pay for meal breaks even when they performed work during those periods.2 Symczyk estimated that she and other employees had worked through unpaid meal breaks for approximately fifteen to thirty minutes per shift and sought statutory damages.3
After Symczyk filed her complaint but before any conditional certification of a collective action, Genesis served her with an offer of judgment under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 68 that included seven thousand five hundred dollars for her individual claim plus reasonable attorneys' fees, costs, and expenses as determined by the court.4 The offer specified that it would be deemed withdrawn if not accepted within ten days.5 Symczyk did not respond to the offer within the allotted time.6
Genesis then filed a motion to dismiss the action for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, asserting that the offer fully satisfied Symczyk's individual claim and that no other plaintiffs had joined the suit.7 The district court determined that the offer fully satisfied Symczyk's claim, noted that no other potential plaintiffs had opted into the suit, and dismissed the case for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.8
Symczyk appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, which reversed the district court's dismissal.9 The Third Circuit held that Symczyk's individual claim was not moot and that her collective action was not moot because she possessed a substantive or procedural right to certification that the offer did not satisfy.10 The Supreme Court granted certiorari to review the case.11
Whether a case becomes moot, and thus beyond the power of an Article III court to adjudicate, when the lone plaintiff receives an offer from the defendant to satisfy all of the plaintiff's claims?12
Article III, Section 2 of the Constitution limits the jurisdiction of federal courts to cases and controversies.13 A case becomes moot when the issues presented are no longer live or the parties lack a legally cognizable interest in the outcome.14 In putative collective actions under the FLSA, the named plaintiff's individual claim becoming moot before certification means the action is no longer justiciable because the plaintiff lacks standing to represent others.15
Yes. The facts establish that Symczyk filed her complaint in February 2009 alleging violations of the Fair Labor Standards Act on behalf of herself and similarly situated employees at the Pennypack Center.16 Genesis made a Rule 68 offer of judgment for seven thousand five hundred dollars plus fees before any conditional certification.17 Symczyk did not accept it. The district court found the offer satisfied her individual claim. It dismissed the case for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction since no other plaintiffs had joined.
The Supreme Court assumed the individual claim was moot and determined that the collective action allegations did not preserve the case because no certification had occurred and Symczyk had no personal stake in representing others.18
The case became moot when the lone plaintiff's individual claim was satisfied by the defendant's offer, requiring dismissal for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.19
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Ginsburg, Justice Breyer, And Justice Sotomayor
Justice Kagan dissented, arguing that the majority resolved an imaginary question because an unaccepted Rule 68 offer does not moot the plaintiff's individual claim.20 She explained that an unaccepted offer is a legal nullity, leaving the plaintiff's interest in the lawsuit intact and the court's ability to grant relief undiminished.21 Kagan contended that the premise of the majority's decision is flawed, as the individual claim never became moot, and the collective action issue should not have been reached.22
She further noted that in FLSA damages actions, individual claims remain live until settled or judicially resolved, making the relation-back doctrine unnecessary in this context.23