206 U.S. 230 (1907)
The State of Georgia filed a bill in equity in the Supreme Court against the Tennessee Copper Company and other copper companies with works in Tennessee.1 This action followed a resolution of the Georgia legislature and the direction of the Governor.2 The bill sought to enjoin the defendants from discharging noxious gas from their works over Georgia's territory.3
The complaint alleged that the discharges caused wholesale destruction of forests, orchards, and crops in five counties of the state, along with other injuries and threats.4 Georgia had made a vain application to Tennessee for relief.5 A preliminary injunction was denied, but an early day was fixed for final hearing, and the parties tried the case on affidavits without objection.6
The defendants generate large quantities of sulphur dioxid in their works near the Georgia line, which becomes sulphurous acid upon mixing with air.7 This gas is carried by the wind great distances over tracts of Georgia land.8 Evidence showed pollution of the air and damage to forests and vegetable life on a considerable scale.9
In 1904, after the evil had grown greater, Georgia brought an earlier bill in the Supreme Court.10 The defendants were abandoning the old method of roasting ore in open heaps and agreed not to return to it, leading to dismissal of the bill without prejudice.11 Georgia now finds that tall chimneys cause the poisonous gases to be carried to greater distances, and the evil has not been helped.12
The case was decided on the affidavits submitted by the parties.13
Whether the defendants' operations near the Georgia line generate sulphur dioxid that becomes sulphurous acid and is carried by wind over tracts of Georgia land causing damage to forests, orchards, and crops?14
A state seeking injunctive relief for transboundary pollution must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendants generate noxious gases that are carried into the state and cause or threaten damage on a considerable scale to forests, crops, and vegetable life.15
Yes. The defendants generate large quantities of sulphur dioxid in their works near the Georgia line, which becomes sulphurous acid upon mixing with air. This gas is carried by the wind great distances over tracts of Georgia land. Evidence showed pollution of the air and damage to forests and vegetable life on a considerable scale.
The proof requires but a few words and establishes that the sulphurous fumes cause and threaten damage on so considerable a scale to the forests and vegetable life within Georgia as to make out a case.16
The defendants' operations generate and disperse the polluting gases that damage Georgia's territory.17
Whether Georgia exercised due diligence in pursuing relief after an earlier 1904 bill was dismissed without prejudice upon the defendants' agreement to abandon open-heap ore roasting?18
A state is not guilty of laches in an interstate nuisance suit when it brings an initial action promptly after the harm increases.19
Yes. In 1904, after the evil had grown greater, Georgia brought an earlier bill in the Supreme Court. The defendants were abandoning the old method of roasting ore in open heaps and agreed not to return to it, leading to dismissal of the bill without prejudice. Georgia now finds that tall chimneys cause the poisonous gases to be carried to greater distances, and the evil has not been helped.
Due diligence has been shown because the conditions were different until recent years and the state acted promptly when the new method proved inadequate.20
Georgia exercised due diligence and is not barred by laches.21
Whether the proof submitted on affidavits establishes pollution and damage on a scale that requires the Court to address the request for injunctive relief?22
When the evidence demonstrates pollution of the air and damage to forests and vegetable life on a considerable scale, the Court must address the state's request for injunctive relief. It should not leave the state to an action at law.23
Yes. The proof submitted on affidavits establishes pollution of the air and the magnitude of that pollution.24 Without any attempt to go into details immaterial to the suit, the Court is satisfied by a preponderance of evidence that the sulphurous fumes cause and threaten damage on so considerable a scale to the forests and vegetable life, if not to health, within the plaintiff State as to make out a case within the requirements of Missouri v. Illinois.25 If the State of Georgia adheres to its determination, there is no alternative to issuing an injunction after allowing a reasonable time to the defendants to complete the structures that they now are building.26
The affidavits establish the requisite scale of pollution and damage, requiring the Court to grant injunctive relief.27
Whether Georgia, in its quasi-sovereign capacity, is entitled to an injunction to prevent the pollution of its air and destruction of its forests by the defendants' operations?28
A state possesses an interest independent of and behind the titles of its citizens in all the earth and air within its domain.29 It may obtain specific injunctive relief to protect its quasi-sovereign rights from transboundary nuisance without the balancing of equities that applies between private parties.30
Yes. This is a suit by a State for an injury to it in its capacity of quasi-sovereign.31 In that capacity the State has an interest independent of and behind the titles of its citizens, in all the earth and air within its domain.32 It has the last word as to whether its mountains shall be stripped of their forests and its inhabitants shall breathe pure air.33
The State owns very little of the territory alleged to be affected, and the damage to it capable of estimate in money, possibly, at least, is small.34 It is a fair and reasonable demand on the part of a sovereign that the air over its territory should not be polluted on a great scale by sulphurous acid gas.35 The forests on its mountains should not be further destroyed or threatened by the act of persons beyond its control.36 If any such demand is to be enforced this must be, notwithstanding the hesitation that we might feel if the suit were between private parties.37
Georgia is entitled to injunctive relief in its quasi-sovereign capacity.38
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Harlan concurs in the result that Georgia is entitled to the general relief sought by its bill.39 He agrees that Georgia has established its right to such relief by proof.40 However, he does not concur in the view that this court owes some special duty to Georgia as a State.41
When the Constitution gave this court original jurisdiction in cases in which a State shall be a party, it was not intended to authorize the court to apply in its behalf any principle or rule of equity that would not be applied, under the same facts, in suits wholly between private parties.42 Georgia is entitled to the relief sought not because it is a State, but because it is a party which has established its right to such relief by proof.43