998 So. 2d 731 (La. App. 2008)
In August 1976, Tahereh Ghassemi and Hamid Ghassemi married in Bam, Iran, when both were Iranian citizens, and their son Hamed was born the following year.1 In 1977, Hamid Ghassemi entered the United States on a student visa and later resided in Indiana while attending a university.2 Unbeknownst to Tahereh, Hamid contracted a marriage with an American woman in Indiana in 1978 or 1979 that ended in divorce in 1983, after which he became a U.S. citizen in 1989.3 In 1995, Hamid arranged for Hamed to enter the United States as his son, and Hamed became a naturalized citizen in 2003.4
Subsequently, in 2002, Hamid married another woman in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, where he had become domiciled, and they executed a separation of property agreement.5 Through Hamed's efforts, Tahereh entered the United States as a permanent resident in 2005 and settled in Baton Rouge.6 On May 22, 2006, Tahereh filed suit in the East Baton Rouge Parish Family Court seeking a divorce, spousal support, and partition of community property, alleging the 1976 Iranian marriage.7
Hamid responded with a peremptory exception of no cause of action, contending the marriage was invalid under Iranian Civil Code article 1045 because the parties are first cousins, and the exception was overruled with the validity issue set for trial on December 6, 2006.8 During litigation, discovery disputes arose when Tahereh sought financial information, leading Hamid to file motions to quash, for protective order, and to stay discovery, which the family court granted on August 29, 2006, while denying Tahereh's motion to compel and awarding Hamid $1,500 in attorney fees.9 Hamid also denied paternity of Hamed, prompting Tahereh's motion for a paternity test that the court deferred until after the scheduled trial.10
On November 2, 2006, Hamid filed a rule to show cause and motion for declaratory judgment arguing Louisiana had no obligation to recognize the Iranian marriage under comity or conflicts principles, and Tahereh responded with a dilatory exception of unauthorized use of summary proceedings that the family court overruled on December 5, 2006.11 The family court conducted a trial on the declaratory relief request on December 6, 2006.12 On June 13, 2007, the family court issued a judgment declining to recognize any Iranian marriage of the parties or give effect to Iranian laws and documents, dismissing Tahereh's petition with prejudice.13 Tahereh appealed the final judgment along with the interlocutory rulings on discovery, attorney fees, and the paternity test motion.14
Whether the family court erred in its procedural rulings on the defendant's request for declaratory relief and the plaintiff's dilatory exception?15
Under Louisiana procedural law, a court may address substantive issues directly when the record is incomplete regarding interlocutory procedural objections, allowing pretermission of procedural claims in favor of resolving the merits under LSA-C.C. arts. 3519 and 3520.16
No. The family court overruled Tahereh Ghassemi's dilatory exception of unauthorized use of summary proceedings on December 5, 2006, and proceeded to trial on Hamid Ghassemi's declaratory judgment request on December 6, 2006, despite an incomplete record lacking transcripts of the exception hearing.1718 The Court of Appeal pretermitted discussion of these procedural assignments because a substantive basis existed to reverse the final judgment under LSA-C.C. art. 3520.19
The procedural rulings do not require reversal because the substantive conflict-of-laws analysis controls the outcome.20
Whether a marriage between first cousins valid under Iranian law is recognizable in Louisiana?21
Louisiana Civil Code article 3520 provides that a marriage valid in the state where contracted shall be treated as valid unless recognition would violate a strong public policy of the state whose law applies under article 3519.22 This embodies the policy of favor matrimonii that presumes validity when the marriage is valid where celebrated.23
Yes. Tahereh Ghassemi and Hamid Ghassemi married in Bam, Iran, in 1976 when both were Iranian citizens, and the parties stipulated that first-cousin marriage is valid under Iranian law with no prohibition under Iranian Civil Code article 1045.24 Both parties are now domiciled in Louisiana, making Louisiana law applicable under article 3519, yet historical legislative ratifications of collateral marriages, the distinction from closer degrees of relation, and the absence of criminal incest liability for first cousins demonstrate that recognition does not violate a strong public policy of Louisiana.25
The Iranian marriage is recognizable in Louisiana and the family court's judgment declining recognition must be reversed.26
Related opinions on this issue
Judge Parro concurs in the majority's disposition of this appeal.27
Whether the family court abused its discretion in granting the defendant's motions to quash discovery, staying discovery, and awarding attorney fees?28
No. On August 29, 2006, the family court granted Hamid Ghassemi's motions to quash, for protective order, and to stay discovery of financial information pending the December 2006 trial on the existence and validity of the marriage, denied Tahereh Ghassemi's motion to compel, and awarded $1,500 in attorney fees.3132 These rulings were based on the need to first determine whether a marriage existed before reaching spousal support and community property claims, and the court did not abuse its discretion in sequencing discovery.33
The discovery and attorney fee rulings are affirmed as within the family court's discretion.34
Whether the family court erred in deferring the plaintiff's motion for a paternity test?35
Under LSA-R.S. 9:396 and LSA-C.C.P. art. 1464, a court may order blood tests only when the mental or physical condition of a party is in controversy and good cause is shown; paternity testing is not required when the issue is irrelevant to the pending claims for divorce, spousal support, and property partition.36
No. Hamid Ghassemi denied paternity of Hamed, who was 29 years old at the time of the 2006 proceedings, and the family court deferred Tahereh Ghassemi's motion for a paternity test until after the scheduled trial on the marriage validity.3738 Because Hamed's paternity was not a relevant fact to the divorce, support, or community property claims, the deferral was proper.39
The deferral of the paternity test motion is affirmed.40