382 U.S. 399 (1966)
Appellant Giaccio was indicted by a Pennsylvania grand jury and charged with two violations of a state statute which makes it a misdemeanor to wantonly point or discharge a firearm at any other person.1 In a trial before a judge and jury appellant’s defense was that the firearm he had discharged was a starter pistol which only fired blanks.2 The jury returned a verdict of not guilty on each charge.3
Acting pursuant to instructions of the court given under authority of a Pennsylvania statute of 1860, the jury assessed against appellant the court costs of one of the charges amounting to $230.95.4 The Act of 1860 provides that in all cases of acquittals by the petit jury on indictments for offenses other than felonies, the jury trying the same shall determine by their verdict whether the county or the prosecutor or the defendant shall pay the costs.5 Whenever the jury shall determine that the defendant shall pay the costs, the court shall forthwith pass sentence to that effect and order him to be committed to the jail of the county until the costs are paid unless he give security to pay the same within ten days.6
Appellant made timely objections to the validity of this statute on several grounds including an objection that the statute is unconstitutionally vague in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause because it authorizes juries to assess costs against acquitted defendants with a threat of imprisonment until the costs are paid without prescribing definite standards to govern the jury’s determination.7 The trial court held the 1860 Act void for vagueness in violation of due process, set aside the jury’s verdict imposing costs on the appellant, and vacated the sentence imposed upon Defendant that he pay said costs forthwith or give security to pay the same within ten days and to stand committed until he had complied therewith.8
The Superior Court of Pennsylvania, one judge dissenting, reversed the trial court.9 The State Supreme Court, again with one judge dissenting, agreed with the Superior Court and affirmed its judgment.10 This left appellant subject to the judgment for costs and the sentence to enforce payment.11 The United States Supreme Court noted jurisdiction to consider the question raised concerning vagueness and absence of proper standards in the 1860 Act.12
Whether the Pennsylvania Act of 1860 authorizing juries to impose costs on acquitted defendants is unconstitutionally vague in violation of the Due Process Clause?13
A law fails to meet the requirements of the Due Process Clause if it is so vague and standardless that it leaves the public uncertain as to the conduct it prohibits.14 It also leaves judges and jurors free to decide, without any legally fixed standards, what is prohibited and what is not in each particular case.15
Yes. This 1860 Pennsylvania Act contains no standards at all.16 It does not place any conditions of any kind upon the jury’s power to impose costs upon a defendant who has been found by the jury to be not guilty of a crime charged against him.17 In the established facts, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty on each charge against appellant Giaccio yet assessed costs of $230.95 against him under the Act, which then directed the court to sentence him to jail until payment or security was given.
The Act as written does not even begin to meet the constitutional requirement of carrying an understandable meaning with legal standards that courts must enforce.18 Subsequent court interpretations still left the jury with broad power to act on its own notions rather than fixed legal standards.19
The 1860 Act is constitutionally invalid both as written and as explained by the Pennsylvania courts.20
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stewart concurs in the Court’s determination that the Pennsylvania statute here in question cannot be squared with the standards of the Fourteenth Amendment, but for reasons somewhat different from those upon which the Court relies.21 Despite the Court’s disclaimer, much of the reasoning in its opinion serves to cast grave constitutional doubt upon the settled practice of many States to leave to the unguided discretion of a jury the nature and degree of punishment to be imposed upon a person convicted of a criminal offense.22 In the present case it is enough for him that Pennsylvania allows a jury to punish a defendant after finding him not guilty.23
That violates the most rudimentary concept of due process of law.24
Justice Fortas states that in his opinion, the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment does not permit a State to impose a penalty or costs upon a defendant whom the jury has found not guilty of any offense with which he has been charged.25