39 Mich. 49 (1878)
Plaintiff Gibson brought an action of assumpsit against defendant Cranage to recover the contract price for making an enlarged portrait of the defendant's deceased daughter from a small photograph.1
Plaintiff testified that he had solicited the work from defendant.2 The agreement was to produce a picture the defendant would like and recognize as a good picture of his little girl, for which defendant was to pay.3 Defendant testified that plaintiff was to send the photograph away to be finished.4 If the returned picture was not perfectly satisfactory to him in every particular, he need not take it or pay for it.5 Plaintiff had urged him to proceed on that basis, assuring there was no risk.6
There was little dispute about the terms of the agreement.7 After the picture was finished it was shown to defendant, who was dissatisfied and refused to accept it.8 Plaintiff tried without success to learn the precise objections and then sent the picture back to the artist for changes.9
The next day defendant wrote plaintiff reciting the original agreement, stating that the picture was not satisfactory, declining to take it or any similar picture, and countermanding the order.10 Further correspondence followed but did not change the situation.11 When the revised picture later arrived, plaintiff asked defendant to examine it, but defendant declined to look at it until trial, when he confirmed that the same objections remained.12
Whether the parties' agreement required the finished portrait to be perfectly satisfactory to the defendant in every particular before he was obligated to accept it or pay the contract price?13
The contract was an express one under which the plaintiff agreed that the picture when finished should be satisfactory to the defendant.14 Where parties deliberately enter into an agreement which violates no rule of public policy and which is free from all taint of fraud or mistake, they are bound by its terms, and the defendant alone had the right to decide whether the portrait met the required standard of satisfaction.15
Yes. The established facts demonstrate that Gibson and Cranage formed an express agreement for production of the enlarged portrait from the small photograph.16
Gibson's testimony established that the picture had to be one Cranage would like and recognize as a good picture of his daughter.17 Cranage's testimony, which was in essential agreement, required the finished picture to be perfectly satisfactory to him in every particular or else he need not accept or pay for it.18
After the initial portrait was shown, Cranage expressed dissatisfaction and refused acceptance.19 Even after revisions were completed and a second viewing was offered, Cranage declined inspection until trial and then confirmed that the same objections persisted.20 These facts establish that the contractual condition of personal satisfaction was never fulfilled.21
The parties' agreement required the finished portrait to be perfectly satisfactory to the defendant in every particular before he was obligated to accept it or pay the contract price.22