383 U.S. 463, 86 S. Ct. 942, 16 L. Ed. 2d 31 (1966)
In the District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, a judge sitting without a jury convicted petitioner Ralph Ginzburg and three corporations controlled by him upon all twenty-eight counts of an indictment charging violation of the federal obscenity statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1461.1
Ginzburg was sentenced to five years in prison and fined twenty-eight thousand dollars.2 The Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed the convictions.3 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.4
The three publications were Eros, a hard-cover magazine of expensive format, Liaison, a bi-weekly newsletter, and The Housewife's Handbook on Selective Promiscuity, a short book.5 EROS early sought mailing privileges from the postmasters of Intercourse and Blue Ball, Pennsylvania.6 The trial court found the obvious, that these hamlets were chosen only for the value their names would have in furthering petitioners' efforts to sell their publications on the basis of salacious appeal; the facilities of the post offices were inadequate to handle the anticipated volume of mail, and the privileges were denied.7 Mailing privileges were then obtained from the postmaster of Middlesex, New Jersey.8 EROS and Liaison thereafter mailed several million circulars soliciting subscriptions from that post office; over 5,500 copies of the Handbook were mailed.9
Typical of the advertising techniques was a full-page advertisement in The New York Times for Eros.10 It occupied the better part of a page, and contained a large photograph of a nude man and woman in a sexual pose.11 The circulars sent for Eros and Liaison stressed the sexual candor of the respective publications.12 The advertising for the Handbook, apparently mailed from New York, consisted almost entirely of a reproduction of the introduction of the book, written by one Dr. Albert Ellis.13 Although he alludes to the book's informational value and its putative therapeutic usefulness, his remarks are preoccupied with the book's sexual imagery.14 This evidence was introduced at trial to show the methods by which the publications were advertised and sold.15
Whether the convictions may be sustained under the standards for obscenity enunciated in Roth v. United States and subsequent cases?16
Under Roth v. United States, material is obscene if its dominant theme taken as a whole appeals to a prurient interest in sex, if it is patently offensive because it affronts contemporary community standards relating to the description or representation of sexual matters, and if it is utterly without redeeming social value. In close cases evidence of pandering may be probative with respect to the nature of the material in question and thus satisfy the Roth test.17
Yes. The established facts show that Ginzburg and his corporations were convicted on twenty-eight counts under 18 U.S.C. § 1461 for mailing Eros, Liaison, and the Handbook after a non-jury trial in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.18 The defense conceded at trial that each publication fell within the Roth test standing alone.19
Ginzburg sought mailing privileges from the postmasters of Intercourse and Blue Ball, Pennsylvania, before obtaining them from Middlesex, New Jersey. He mailed several million circulars plus over 5,500 copies of the Handbook.20 The advertising included a full-page New York Times advertisement for Eros. It featured a large photograph of a nude man and woman in a sexual pose together with text promising the most sensual nudes and material normally found in the bottom drawer. Circulars for Eros and Liaison stressed sexual candor.21 The Handbook advertisement reproduced Dr. Albert Ellis's introduction preoccupied with sexual imagery.22
These facts of deliberate commercial exploitation for prurient appeal resolve all ambiguity and permit the Roth standards to be satisfied in the context of sale and promotion, sustaining the convictions.23
The convictions may be sustained because the pandering shown in the established facts supplies the decisive context that satisfies the Roth test.24
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justice Stewart
Justice Black would reverse these convictions because the Federal Government has no power to censor the mails, no matter how obscene the material may be.25 The First Amendment says that Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.26 That Amendment should be given its plain meaning.27
It forbids the Federal Government from censoring the mails.28 The power to censor is an awesome power.29 It is a power that is subject to abuse.30 I would not entrust it to any government official.31
Justice Black further concludes that the criteria declared by the Court as guidelines for determining obscenity are so vague and meaningless that they leave the fate of a person charged with violating censorship statutes to the unbridled discretion, whim and caprice of the judge or jury which tries him.32
Justice Douglas dissents because obscenity is a vague and elusive concept.33 What is obscene to one man may be beautiful to another.34 The line between obscenity and protected speech is too vague to be enforced by criminal sanctions.35
The First Amendment protects all speech except that which is plainly and demonstrably harmful.36 These publications are not in that category.37 They may be offensive to some, but that is not enough to justify criminal punishment.38
Justice Douglas further objects that the Court's new pandering exception condemns an advertising technique as old as history and engrafts an unwarranted limitation on First Amendment rights, as a book should stand on its own irrespective of the reasons why it was written or the wiles used in selling it.39
Justice Harlan would reverse the convictions because the federal obscenity statute is concerned with unlawful shipment of nonmailable matter and its focus is solely on the character of the material in question.40 The Federal Government is constitutionally restricted to banning from the mails only hardcore pornography.41 The material in question here does not fall within that narrow class.42
Justice Harlan further concludes that the new pandering gloss is an impermissible judicial rewriting of the statute that is both vague and unsupported by the trial record, as the theory on which the convictions are now sustained is quite different from the basis on which the case was tried and decided by the District Court and affirmed by the Court of Appeals.43
Justice Stewart dissents because if the First Amendment means anything, it means that a man cannot be sent to prison merely for distributing publications which offend a judge's esthetic sensibilities.44 The Court today appears to concede that the materials Ginzburg mailed were themselves protected by the First Amendment.45 Yet the Court says Ginzburg can still be sentenced to five years in prison for mailing them because he was guilty of commercial exploitation, of pandering, and of titillation.46
Ginzburg was not charged with any of those grounds.47 Therefore, to affirm his conviction now on any of those grounds denies him due process of law.48 Justice Stewart further concludes that the Court assumes the power to deny Ralph Ginzburg the protection of the First Amendment because it disapproves of his sordid business, a power the Court does not possess.49