233 N.Y. 236, 135 N.E. 275
Plaintiffs bought of Bech, Van Siclen & Co., a corporation, 905 bags of beans.1 The beans were to be paid for in accordance with weight sheets certified by public weighers.2
Bech, Van Siclen & Co., the seller, requested the defendants, who are engaged in business as public weighers, to make return of the weight and furnish the buyers with a copy.3 A letter to the weighers, dated July 20, 1918, informed them that the bags were on the dock, that the beans had been sold to Glanzer Bros., the plaintiffs, who would accept delivery Tuesday, July 23, and that the defendants were to communicate with the plaintiffs, and ascertain whether it would “ be in order ” to be on the pier Tuesday morning to weigh the beans before delivery.4 The defendants did as bidden.5
They certified the weight of the 905 bags to be 228,380 pounds, and were paid for the service by the seller.6 Their return recites that it has been made “ by order of ” Bech, Van Siclen & Co., “ for G. Bros.” One copy of the return they sent to the seller, and a duplicate to the buyers.7
Later, 17 bags, containing 4,136 pounds, were withdrawn from the shipment.8 The others were accepted and paid for on the faith of the certificates.9 The plaintiffs, upon attempting a resale, found that the actual weight was less by 11,854 pounds than the weight as certified in the return.10 Upon learning this, they brought suit against the defendants in the City Court of New York for $1,261.26, the amount overpaid.11
The trial judge, upon motions made by each side for the direction of a verdict, ordered judgment for the plaintiffs.12 The Appellate Term reversed upon the ground that the plaintiffs had no contract with the defendants, and must seek their remedy against the seller.13 The Appellate Division reversed the Appellate Term, and reinstated the verdict.14 The defendants are the appellants here.15
Whether public weighers who certify the weight of goods at the seller's request owe a duty of care to the buyer who relies on the certification for payment?16
One who follows a common calling may come under a duty to another whom he serves, though a third may give the order or make the payment.17 The duty, growing out of a contract, has an origin not exclusively contractual and is imposed by law given the contract and the relation.18 The controlling circumstance is the proximity or remoteness in the thought and purpose of the actor, and when the certificate is a deliberate act intended to sway conduct, the weighers are held for the careless performance of the service of weighing.19
Yes. The defendants held themselves out to the public as skilled and careful in their calling.20 They knew that the beans had been sold, and that on the faith of their certificate payment would be made.21 They sent a copy to the plaintiffs for the very purpose of inducing action.22 All this they admit. In such circumstances, assumption of the task of weighing was the assumption of a duty to weigh carefully for the benefit of all whose conduct was to be governed.23 We do not need to state the duty in terms of contract or of privity.24 Growing out of a contract, it has none the less an origin not exclusively contractual.25 Given the contract and the relation, the duty is imposed by law.26
The plaintiffs bought 905 bags of beans from Bech, Van Siclen & Co. with payment to be made in accordance with the certified weight sheets.27 The seller requested the defendants to furnish the buyers with a copy of the return, and a letter informed the defendants that the beans had been sold to the plaintiffs.28 The defendants certified the weight at 228,380 pounds, sent a duplicate to the buyers, and recited that the return was made by order of the seller for G. Bros.29 The plaintiffs accepted and paid for the beans on the faith of the certificates after 17 bags were withdrawn from the shipment.30 Upon discovering that the actual weight was less by 11,854 pounds, the plaintiffs sued for the amount overpaid.31 The trial judge directed judgment for the plaintiffs, the Appellate Term reversed, and the Appellate Division reinstated the verdict.32 The defendants' knowledge of the prospective use by the plaintiffs and the deliberate nature of the certificate establish the required proximity between the act and the consequence.33
The public weighers owed a duty of care to the buyer who relied on the certification for payment.34