190 U.S. 540 [23 S. Ct. 754, 47 L. Ed.1171]
Globe Refining Company, a Kentucky corporation, entered into a contract with Landa Cotton Oil Company, a Texas corporation, for the purchase of ten tanks of prime crude cottonseed oil.1 The agreement was arranged through a broker and confirmed in a letter dated July 30, 1897, from Thomas & Green to the defendant.2
The oil was to be sold at 15½ cents per gallon of 7½ pounds f.o.b. buyers’ tank at the defendant’s mill.3 Shipment was to occur part last half August and balance first half September.4 Shipping instructions were to be furnished by the Globe Refining Company.5 Payment was to be made by sight draft without exchange.6
The plaintiff arranged to send its tank cars to the defendant’s mill for loading.7 It obligated itself to a railroad company for transportation costs amounting to nine hundred dollars from Louisville to New Braunfels.8 The defendant cancelled the contract on September 2 but did not notify the plaintiff until September 14.9 As a result, the plaintiff incurred expenses related to the tank cars and alleged losses from its own customer arrangements.10
The plaintiff claimed special damages for transportation costs.11 It alleged loss of use of the tanks for thirty days valued at seven hundred dollars.12 Losses on contracts with its customers totaled seven hundred forty dollars plus one thousand dollars for loss of customers and reputation.13 It claimed three hundred fifty dollars in additional freight charges.14 These claims were detailed in the petition filed in the United States Circuit Court.
The defendant filed exceptions to the damage allegations.15 It pleaded that the damages had been claimed and magnified fraudulently for the purpose of giving the United States Circuit Court jurisdiction, when in truth they were less than two thousand dollars.16 The judge sustained the exceptions, tried the jurisdictional issue without a jury, found the plea sustained, and dismissed the suit.17 The plaintiff brought the case to the Supreme Court by writ of error.18
Whether the circuit court properly sustained exceptions to the plaintiff's allegations of special damages beyond the difference between contract and market price?19
A person can only be held to be responsible for such consequences as may be reasonably supposed to be in the contemplation of the parties at the time of making the contract.20 Mere notice to a seller of some interest or probable action of the buyer is not enough, necessarily and as a matter of law, to charge the seller with special damage on that account if he fails to deliver the goods.21 The knowledge must be brought home to the party sought to be charged, under such circumstances that he must know that the person he contracts with reasonably believes that he accepts the contract with the special condition attached to it.22
Yes. The contract between Globe Refining Company and Landa Cotton Oil Company as confirmed in the broker letter contemplated only that the buyer's tanks would be at the defendant's mill at delivery.23 The petition's allegations of special damages for nine hundred dollars in transportation costs from Louisville, seven hundred dollars for loss of tank use, seven hundred forty dollars on customer contracts plus one thousand dollars for lost reputation, and three hundred fifty dollars in additional freight did not allege that Landa Cotton Oil Company assumed liability for these items or that circumstances at contracting showed it contemplated such liability.24 The claims amounted at most to notice of the plaintiff's plans, which is insufficient to impose the special damages under the rule.25
The circuit court properly sustained the exceptions to the allegations of special damages.26
Whether the circuit court correctly tried the jurisdictional plea without a jury and found the damages fraudulently claimed to confer jurisdiction?27
Under the Act of March 3, 1875, c. 137, § 5, the court has authority to try the question of jurisdiction before hearing the merits when the defendant pleads that damages were claimed fraudulently to give jurisdiction.28
Yes. The defendant pleaded that the damages had been claimed and magnified fraudulently for the purpose of giving the United States Circuit Court jurisdiction when in truth they were less than two thousand dollars.29 After sustaining the exceptions to the damage allegations, the judge tried the jurisdictional issue without a jury as authorized by statute.30 He found the plea sustained on the basis of the plaintiff's own itemized bill for one thousand and twenty-one dollars and twenty-eight cents.31
The circuit court correctly tried the jurisdictional plea without a jury and dismissed the suit.32