783 P.2d 781 (Ariz. 1989)
In the spring and summer of 1985, Phoenix Newspapers, Inc., the publisher of The Arizona Republic and Phoenix Gazette, along with fourteen editors and reporters, printed over fifty articles, editorials, and columns about the law enforcement activities of Richard G. Godbehere, the former Maricopa County Sheriff, and several deputies and civilian employees of the sheriff's office.1 The publications stated that the plaintiffs engaged in illegal activities, staged narcotics arrests to generate publicity, illegally arrested citizens, misused public funds and resources, committed police brutality, and were generally incompetent at law enforcement.2
The plaintiffs filed an eighteen-count complaint alleging that the publications were false, damaged their reputations, harmed them in their profession, and caused them emotional distress, and they asserted claims for both libel and false light invasion of privacy.3 Publishers moved to dismiss all counts for failure to state a claim; the trial court granted the motion as to the false light invasion of privacy claims on June 18, 1986, but refused to dismiss the remaining counts.4
The plaintiffs appealed, and the court of appeals affirmed the dismissal of the privacy claims in Godbehere v. Phoenix Newspapers, Inc., 155 Ariz. 389, 746 P.2d 1319 (Ct. App. 1987).5 The Supreme Court of Arizona granted review to examine the false light claims.6
Whether Arizona should recognize a cause of action for false light invasion of privacy?7
Arizona recognizes the distinct tort of false light invasion of privacy as articulated by Restatement (Second) of Torts § 652E.8 One who gives publicity to a matter concerning another that places the other before the public in a false light is subject to liability to the other for invasion of his privacy.9 Liability exists if the false light in which the other was placed would be highly offensive to a reasonable person.10 Additionally, the actor must have had knowledge of or acted in reckless disregard as to the falsity of the publicized matter and the false light in which the other would be placed.11
Yes. The Supreme Court of Arizona applied this rule to the established facts. Phoenix Newspapers, Inc. and fourteen editors and reporters printed over fifty articles stating that Richard G. Godbehere, the former Maricopa County Sheriff, and several deputies and civilian employees engaged in illegal activities, staged narcotics arrests, illegally arrested citizens, misused public funds, committed police brutality, and were incompetent.12
Plaintiffs alleged the publications were false and caused emotional distress.13 The court determined that the false light tort protects against a narrow class of wrongful conduct involving knowing or reckless publication of false information that a reasonable person would find highly offensive.14 This protection is warranted even though the injury overlaps with emotional distress claims because the torts address different types of conduct.15 The false light standards are stringent enough on their own to avoid unwarranted lawsuits.16
Arizona should recognize a cause of action for false light invasion of privacy.17
Whether a plaintiff asserting false light invasion of privacy must prove the elements of intentional infliction of emotional distress?18
A plaintiff asserting false light invasion of privacy need not prove the elements of intentional infliction of emotional distress.19 The two torts redress different types of wrongful conduct.20 The false light requirements that the publication be highly offensive to a reasonable person and made with knowledge or reckless disregard of falsity are sufficiently stringent to protect defendants without merging the actions.21
No. The trial court had dismissed the false light claims on June 18, 1986, because the publications about the plaintiffs' law enforcement activities were not extreme or outrageous as required for intentional infliction of emotional distress under the prior court of appeals decisions.22 The Supreme Court held that the fact that both torts compensate for emotional injury does not require plaintiffs to prove outrageous conduct in a false light action.23 The established facts show that the eighteen-count complaint alleged false publications damaging reputations and causing emotional distress.24 The false light elements alone suffice without the additional outrage requirement.25
A plaintiff asserting false light invasion of privacy need not prove the elements of intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Whether a public official may bring a false light invasion of privacy action based on publications relating to the performance of official public duties?26
A public official cannot sue for false light invasion of privacy if the publication relates to performance of his or her public life or duties.27 A public official may still bring such an action if the publication presents the official's private life in a false light.28 The right of privacy does not exist where the plaintiff has become a public character and the public has a legitimate interest in the manner in which law enforcement officers perform their duties.29
No. The established facts establish that Richard G. Godbehere was the former Maricopa County Sheriff and the other plaintiffs were deputies and civilian employees of the sheriff's office.30 They filed claims based on over fifty articles concerning their law enforcement activities including allegations of illegal conduct and incompetence.31 The Supreme Court applied the rule to conclude that these plaintiffs are public officials.32
The publications relate to the discharge of their public duties.33 No false light claim is available even though the publications were alleged to be false and caused harm.34
A public official may not bring a false light invasion of privacy action based on publications relating to the performance of official public duties.35