335 U.S. 464 (1948)
Michigan's system for controlling the sale of liquor includes a requirement, enacted in 1945 as Section 19a of Act 133 of the Public Acts of Michigan and codified at Mich. Stat. Ann. § 18.990 (1) (Cum. Supp. 1947), that bartenders in all cities having a population of 50,000 or more must be licensed, with the further restriction that no female may be licensed unless she is the wife or daughter of the male owner of a licensed liquor establishment.1
A three-judge district court was convened under § 266 of the old Judicial Code, now 28 U.S.C. § 2284, to consider the request for injunctive relief. After proceedings in that court, the injunction was denied, although one judge dissented from the decision reported at 74 F. Supp. 735. The case then came before the Supreme Court on direct appeal from that order.2
Whether the Equal Protection of the Laws Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment barred Michigan from making the classification the State has made between wives and daughters of owners of liquor places and wives and daughters of non-owners?3
The Equal Protection of the Laws Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment precludes irrational discrimination as between persons or groups of persons in the incidence of a law.4 The Constitution does not require situations which are different in fact or opinion to be treated in law as though they were the same.5 A statute is not invalid under the Constitution because it might have gone farther than it did or because it may not succeed in bringing about the result that it tends to produce.6
No. Michigan could, beyond question, forbid all women from working behind a bar.7 The legislature could reasonably believe that the oversight assured through ownership of a bar by a barmaid’s husband or father minimizes hazards that may confront a barmaid without such protecting oversight.8 Therefore, the line drawn between wives and daughters of owners and other women is not without a basis in reason.9
The classification made by Michigan does not violate the Equal Protection of the Laws Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.10
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Douglas And Murphy
Justice Rutledge, with whom Justices Douglas and Murphy joined, dissented.11 The equal protection clause requires lawmakers to refrain from invidious distinctions of the sort drawn by the statute challenged in this case.12 The statute arbitrarily discriminates between male and female owners of liquor establishments.13
A male owner may employ his wife and daughter as barmaids although he is always absent from his bar.14 A female owner may neither work as a barmaid herself nor employ her daughter in that position even if a man is always present.15 This result belies the assumption that the statute was motivated by a legislative solicitude for the moral and physical well-being of women who would be employed as barmaids.16
The statute should be held invalid as a denial of equal protection.17