767 F.2d 437, 41 UCC 832 (8th Cir. 1985)
HWH was an order-buying cattle company which purchased cattle on commission for feedlots.1 It is owned by the Hitch family, which owns several feedlots and other cattle businesses.2 On September 13, 1978, HWH entered into a contract with Clayton Schroeder to purchase 2,000 steers for $67.00 per hundredweight.3 The contract specified delivery between March 1 and May 31, 1979 in Artesia, New Mexico.4 HWH gave Schroeder a $50,000 downpayment.5
HWH in turn had a contract with its customer Western Trio Cattle Co. to sell it 2,000 head of cattle of the same description for $67.35 per hundredweight.6 Western Trio had given HWH a $50,000 downpayment which HWH used to pay Schroeder.7 Schroeder was only able to deliver 1,397 cattle to HWH, leaving it 603 head short.8
As a result, HWH filed an action for breach of contract against Schroeder in federal district court for the Northern District of Iowa.9 The matter came to trial before the district court without a jury on April 15-16, 1982.10 The district court found that Schroeder breached its contract with HWH by failing to deliver 603 head of cattle.11 It awarded HWH $15,075, the remaining amount of the downpayment which Schroeder had retained, and $1,371.83 in damages for HWH's lost commission on the 603 cattle not delivered.12
HWH appealed from the district court's judgment.13 Schroeder contended that HWH exercised its option to cover by purchasing replacement cattle in June 1979.14 HWH's buyer Gene McGlaun testified at trial that he was in Dodge City, Kansas in June 1979 and telephoned C.A. Heldridge, Schroeder's agent, to let him know that substitute cattle were available which could be purchased to fulfill the contract with a freight adjustment of roughly $0.50 per hundredweight over the contract price.15 According to McGlaun, Heldridge responded that such an offer sounded like a good deal and that he would call him back with a reply but never did.16
McGlaun further testified that he bought 120-130 head of cattle in Dodge City on that day but these were not to cover for the 603 cattle not delivered under the contract with Schroeder.17 His purchases were for other customers and each set of cattle stood on their own to fill individual customers' needs.18 HWH contended that it is entitled to damages based upon the market price of cattle meeting the contract description in Artesia, New Mexico on June 1, 1979, the day after the last day of delivery under the contract.19 The district court rejected this argument because it would have resulted in an undeserved windfall to HWH.20 HWH had already voluntarily limited its market price by agreeing to sell these cattle to Western Trio for $0.35 per hundredweight more than it paid for the cattle.21
The district court also found that the parties modified the time for delivery.22 HWH indicated it would have accepted delivery through the summer of 1979 during which time the price of cattle fell back to around $67.00 per hundredweight.23 Western Trio is managed by the Hitch family which also owns HWH, and Western Trio made no demand on HWH to fulfill the remainder of the contract.24
Whether HWH covered by making a substitute purchase of cattle in June 1979?25
Under Iowa Code Ann. § 554.2712, after a breach the buyer may cover by making in good faith and without unreasonable delay any reasonable purchase of or contract to purchase goods in substitution for those due from the seller.26
No. Gene McGlaun testified that he telephoned Schroeder's agent about substitute cattle.27 The purchases made in Dodge City were for other customers and each set of cattle stood on their own to fill individual customers' needs.28 Schroeder introduced no evidence to contradict this testimony.29 The court concluded from this testimony and other testimony concerning the nature of HWH's order-buying operation that any cattle purchased were not substitute cattle to fulfill the contract with Schroeder.30
HWH did not cover by making a substitute purchase of cattle in June 1979.31
Whether HWH is entitled to damages measured by the difference between market price on June 1, 1979 in Artesia, New Mexico and the contract price?32
Under Iowa Code Ann. § 554.2713, the measure of damages for nondelivery is the difference between the market price at the time when the buyer learned of the breach and the contract price together with any incidental and consequential damages, but subject to the principle in Iowa Code Ann. § 554.1106 that remedies shall be liberally administered to put the aggrieved party in as good a position as if the other party had fully performed.33
No. Adopting HWH's position would result in granting it a windfall of some $62,000 in violation of the general principle concerning remedies.34 HWH only expected to receive its $0.35 commission on the transaction as an order-buyer.35 It had already voluntarily limited its market price by agreeing to sell to Western Trio.36 The district court properly rejected the contention that HWH is liable to Western Trio for market price damages.37
Western Trio made no demand on HWH and the evidence indicated that Western Trio would have at best only broken even due to the fallen cattle market.38
HWH is not entitled to damages measured by the difference between market price on June 1, 1979 in Artesia, New Mexico and the contract price but is limited to its lost commission.39
Whether the parties modified the delivery date of the contract?40
The court found it unnecessary to review whether the parties modified the delivery date of the contract.41
No. The court found it unnecessary to review whether the parties modified the delivery date of the contract. It affirmed the district court's judgment on the basis of restricting recovery to HWH's expectancy interest in lost commission.42 This approach avoided any need to examine the modification issue further.43
It is unnecessary to decide whether the parties modified the delivery date of the contract.44