281 Md. 560, 380A.2d 611
William R. Harris, a twenty-six-year-old who had worked for General Motors Corporation for eight years, filed suit against the company and his supervisor H. Robert Jones in the Superior Court of Baltimore City.1 Harris had stuttered throughout his life, experiencing little trouble with one-syllable words but great difficulty with longer words or sentences that sometimes caused him to shake his head up and down when speaking.2 Jones supervised Harris at a GM automobile assembly plant during part of 1975.3 Jones was aware of Harris's speech impediment along with his sensitivity to the disability.4
Over a five-month period between March and August of 1975, Jones approached Harris over thirty times at work and verbally and physically mimicked his stuttering disability.5 Two or three times a week during this period, Jones approached Harris and told him in a smart manner not to get nervous.6 As a result of this conduct, Harris felt shaken up and like going into a hole and hiding.7
On June 2, 1975, Harris asked Jones for a transfer to another department.8 Jones refused the request, called Harris a troublemaker, and chastised him for repeatedly seeking the assistance of his committeeman while shaking his head up and down to imitate Harris's pronunciation of the word as mmitteeman.9 Harris filed an employee grievance against Jones requesting that GM instruct Jones to properly conduct himself, and the grievance was marked as satisfactorily settled after GM so instructed Jones.10 Harris filed a similar grievance on another occasion during the period, which was also marked as satisfactorily settled after further instruction to Jones.11
Harris had been under the care of a physician for a nervous condition for six years prior to the commencement of Jones's harassment.12 He saw his physician on one occasion during the five-month period, and the physician prescribed pills for his nerves.13 Harris admitted that many things made him nervous, including bosses.14 Harris admitted that other employees at the plant mimicked his stuttering.15
Harris's wife testified that her husband was in a shell at the time they were married approximately seven years prior to the trial.16 She said it took her about a year to get him to associate with family and friends and that he thereafter became calmer, although he still had a difficult time talking.17 Mrs. Harris testified that beginning in November of 1974 her husband became ill-tempered at home, drank too much, threw a meat platter at her on one occasion, and that they separated for a two-week period that month.18 She indicated that her husband's nervous condition got worse in June of 1975.19
The case was submitted to the jury after the trial court denied the defendants' motions for directed verdicts.20 The jury awarded Harris $3,500 in compensatory damages and $15,000 in punitive damages against both Jones and GM.21 The Court of Special Appeals reversed the judgments entered on the jury verdicts for the plaintiff on that cause of action.22 The Court of Appeals of Maryland granted certiorari to review the decision of the Court of Special Appeals and to decide whether, if intentional infliction of emotional distress is a viable tort in Maryland, the court erred in reversing judgments entered on jury verdicts for the plaintiff on that cause of action.23
Whether intentional infliction of emotional distress is recognized as a valid and independent tort cause of action in Maryland?24
The court recognizes the independent tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress.25 Four elements must coalesce. (1) The conduct must be intentional or reckless. (2) The conduct must be extreme and outrageous. (3) There must be a causal connection between the wrongful conduct and the emotional distress. (4) The emotional distress must be severe.2627
Yes. The Court of Appeals of Maryland sanctioned the independent tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress.28 The Court of Special Appeals recognized it in a case of first impression.29 The court relied on Restatement (Second) of Torts § 46 and the four elements from Womack v. Eldridge.30
This approach minimizes problems of distinguishing true claims from false ones and serious wrongs from trifling annoyances.31
Intentional infliction of emotional distress is recognized as a valid and independent tort cause of action in Maryland.32
Whether the evidence at trial was legally sufficient to establish a causal connection between the defendant's conduct and the plaintiff's emotional distress?33
Yes. The Court of Appeals of Maryland assumed without deciding that a causal relationship was shown between Jones's wrongful conduct and Harris's emotional distress.36 The facts establish that Harris visited his physician once during the five-month period of harassment for nerve pills after six prior years of treatment.37 His condition worsened in June 1975.38
The evidence at trial was legally sufficient to establish a causal connection between the defendant's conduct and the plaintiff's emotional distress.39
Whether the evidence at trial was legally sufficient to establish that the plaintiff's emotional distress was severe?40
The emotional distress must be severe. This means distress so severe that no reasonable person could be expected to endure it.41 The intensity and duration of the distress serve as factors.42 The extreme and outrageous character of the conduct provides important evidence of severity under comment j of Restatement (Second) of Torts § 46.43
No. The Court of Appeals of Maryland held that the evidence was legally insufficient to establish severe emotional distress.44 Harris was only shaken up and felt like going into a hole and hiding.45 He saw his physician once during the period for the same nerve treatment received for six years prior.46 His family problems antedated the encounter with Jones.47 No evidentiary particulars were provided on the intensity, duration, or degree to which his speech impediment worsened.48
The evidence at trial was not legally sufficient to establish that the plaintiff's emotional distress was severe.49