3 U.S. (3 Dall.) 171 (1796)
In June 1794 Congress passed a statute entitled "An act laying duties upon carriages for the conveyance of persons."1 Daniel Hylton owned, possessed, and kept 125 chariots for the conveyance of persons from June 5, 1794 through the last day of September 1794.2 The chariots were maintained exclusively for Hylton's private use and were never let out to hire or used to convey persons for compensation.3 Hylton received the notice required by the statute but omitted and refused to make entry of the chariots or to pay the duties, asserting that the statute was unconstitutional.4
The United States, acting through its district attorney, brought an action of debt against Hylton in the Circuit Court for the District of Virginia at the May Term 1795 to recover the penalty prescribed by the statute.5 Hylton pleaded nil debet and issue was joined.6 The parties waived trial by jury and submitted the controversy to the court on an agreed statement of facts providing that, if the court adjudged Hylton liable, judgment would be entered for the plaintiff in the sum of $2,000 to be discharged by payment of $16; otherwise judgment would be entered for the defendant.7
After argument the circuit court judges were equally divided.8 By agreement of the parties Hylton confessed judgment to furnish a foundation for appellate review.9 A writ of error was prosecuted from that judgment to the Supreme Court of the United States.10
Whether the tax imposed by the Act of Congress of June 5, 1794 on carriages kept for the conveyance of persons constitutes a direct tax that must be apportioned among the states according to their respective numbers?11
The Constitution provides that representatives and direct taxes shall be apportioned among the states according to their respective numbers.12 No capitation or other direct tax shall be laid unless in proportion to the census.13 Congress has power to lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts, and excises, which shall be uniform throughout the United States.14 Direct taxes within the meaning of the Constitution are limited to capitation taxes and taxes on land.15
No. The tax on carriages kept for private use is not a direct tax but rather an indirect tax on consumption or expense.16 Under the established facts, Hylton kept 125 chariots exclusively for his own private use without any commercial purpose.17 Such a tax falls within the category of indirect taxes that need only satisfy the uniformity requirement rather than apportionment.18 The framers intended the apportionment rule to apply principally to capitation and land taxes to protect southern states with large slave populations and extensive territories.19
A carriage tax, being a tax on luxury or expense, can be readily imposed uniformly and does not require the impractical apportionment process that would lead to arbitrary valuations.20
The carriage tax is constitutional because it constitutes an indirect tax subject to the rule of uniformity rather than a direct tax requiring apportionment among the states.21