418 U.S. 153 (1974)
In January 1972, local law enforcement officers in Albany, Georgia, seized the motion picture Carnal Knowledge from a theater managed by appellant Jenkins while he was exhibiting the film pursuant to a search warrant.1
Jenkins was later charged by accusation with the offense of distributing obscene material.2 After his trial in the Superior Court of Dougherty County, the jury that had seen the film and heard testimony returned a general verdict of guilty on March 23, 1972.3 Jenkins was fined $750 and sentenced to twelve months' probation.4
Jenkins appealed to the Supreme Court of Georgia, which affirmed the judgment of conviction on July 2, 1973.5 That court observed that the definition of obscenity in the Georgia statute was considerably more restrictive than the test set forth in Miller v. California.6 Jenkins then appealed to the United States Supreme Court, which noted probable jurisdiction.7
The record contains little information about the film Carnal Knowledge other than the film itself.8 Jenkins supplied information and critical commentary whose authenticity was not disputed.9 The film appeared on many Ten Best lists for 1971, the year of its release, and many but not all of the reviews were favorable.10
A review that appeared in the Saturday Review described the film as basically a story of two young college men, roommates and lifelong friends forever preoccupied with their sex lives, following them from their college years into their thirties as they pursue careers in New York and encounter romantic and sexual relationships.11 The jury at trial was instructed on obscenity pursuant to the Georgia statute, which defines obscene material in language similar to the definition set forth in the plurality opinion in Memoirs v. Massachusetts.12
Whether the Constitution requires that juries in state obscenity cases be instructed to apply the standards of a hypothetical statewide community?13
No. The Supreme Court of Georgia implicitly ruled that the Constitution does not require that juries be instructed to apply the standards of a hypothetical statewide community.16 The Court agrees with that ruling because Miller permits but does not require such instructions. Miller makes clear that state juries need not be instructed to apply national standards.17 The States have considerable latitude in framing statutes under this element of the Miller decision.
A State may choose to define an obscenity offense in terms of contemporary community standards as defined in Miller without further specification, as was done here.18
The Constitution does not require that juries in state obscenity cases be instructed to apply the standards of a hypothetical statewide community.19
Whether the film Carnal Knowledge may constitutionally be found to depict sexual conduct in a patently offensive way?20
Under Miller, material may be found patently offensive only if it depicts or describes in a patently offensive way sexual conduct specifically defined by state law, such as representations of ultimate sexual acts or lewd exhibition of the genitals.21 Appellate courts must independently review whether the material meets this substantive constitutional limitation.22
No. The Court's own viewing of the film satisfies it that Carnal Knowledge could not be found under the Miller standards to depict sexual conduct in a patently offensive way.23 Nothing in the movie falls within either of the two examples given in Miller of material which may constitutionally be found to meet the patently offensive element of those standards.24 There is nothing sufficiently similar to such material to justify similar treatment.25 While the subject matter of the picture is in a broader sense sex, there are scenes in which sexual conduct including ultimate sexual acts is to be understood to be taking place.
The camera does not focus on the bodies of the actors at such times.26 There is no exhibition whatever of the actors' genitals, lewd or otherwise, during these scenes.27 There are occasional scenes of nudity.28 Nudity alone is not enough to make material legally obscene under the Miller standards.29
Appellant's showing of the film Carnal Knowledge is simply not the public portrayal of hard core sexual conduct for its own sake and for the ensuing commercial gain which the Court said was punishable in Miller.30
The film Carnal Knowledge may not constitutionally be found to depict sexual conduct in a patently offensive way.31
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Justices Stewart And Marshall
Justice Brennan, with whom Justices Stewart and Marshall join, concurs in the result.32 After the Court's decision today, there can be no doubt that Miller requires appellate courts, including this Court, to review independently the constitutional fact of obscenity.33 The Court's task includes independent review of a jury's determination under part (b) of the Miller test that the work depicts or describes, in a patently offensive way, sexual conduct specifically defined by the applicable state law.34
The Miller test still leaves in this Court the responsibility of determining in each case whether the materials are protected by the First Amendment.35 This confirms his observation that the reformulation does not extricate the Court from the mire of case-by-case determinations of obscenity. He continues to adhere to his view that, at least in the absence of distribution to juveniles or obtrusive exposure to unconsenting adults, the First and Fourteenth Amendments prohibit the State and Federal Governments from attempting wholly to suppress sexually oriented materials on the basis of their allegedly obscene contents.36
He therefore concludes that the Georgia obscenity statutes under which appellant Jenkins was convicted are constitutionally overbroad and facially invalid.37
Whether a jury verdict in an obscenity case precludes independent appellate review of the claim that the exhibition is protected by the First and Fourteenth Amendments?38
Even though questions of patent offensiveness are essentially questions of fact, Miller requires that appellate courts conduct an independent review of constitutional claims to protect First Amendment values.39 No one may be prosecuted unless the materials depict or describe patently offensive hard core sexual conduct.40
No. Even though questions of appeal to the prurient interest or of patent offensiveness are essentially questions of fact, it would be a serious misreading of Miller to conclude that juries have unbridled discretion in determining what is patently offensive.41 The Court made it plain that under Miller the First Amendment values applicable to the States through the Fourteenth Amendment are adequately protected by the ultimate power of appellate courts to conduct an independent review of constitutional claims when necessary.42 The Court also made it plain that no one will be subject to prosecution for the sale or exposure of obscene materials unless these materials depict or describe patently offensive hard core sexual conduct. The Court therefore conducts such independent review here and reverses the conviction.43
A jury verdict in an obscenity case does not preclude independent appellate review of the claim that the exhibition is protected by the First and Fourteenth Amendments.44