574 U.S. 445 (2015)
The Republican River originates in Colorado, crosses the northwestern corner of Kansas into Nebraska, flows through much of southwestern Nebraska, and finally cuts back into northern Kansas, draining a 24,900-square-mile watershed called the Republican River Basin.1
In 1943, Kansas, Nebraska, and Colorado entered into the Republican River Compact, approved by Congress as federal law, to apportion the virgin water supply originating in the basin, giving Nebraska roughly 49 percent, Kansas 40 percent, and Colorado 11 percent for beneficial consumptive use.2
In 1998, Kansas filed an original action in the Supreme Court alleging that Nebraska's increased groundwater pumping depleted stream flow in the basin in violation of the Compact.3 The Court appointed a Special Master who favored Kansas's position on the Compact's coverage of groundwater pumping.4 The states then negotiated and signed the 2002 Final Settlement Stipulation, which the Court approved in 2003.5
The Settlement established detailed mechanisms for measuring water use through accounting procedures and a groundwater model.6 It required multi-year averaging for compliance calculations and provided that imported water from outside the basin would not count toward a state's allocation.
By 2007, following the first post-Settlement accounting period, Kansas petitioned the Court for monetary and injunctive relief, claiming Nebraska had exceeded its allocation by 70,869 acre-feet during the 2005-2006 period and caused Kansas a $3.7 million loss. Nebraska responded with a counterclaim that the accounting procedures improperly charged it for using imported water from the Platte River Basin.7 The Court appointed a new Special Master who conducted hearings, received evidence, and entertained arguments over two years.8
The Special Master found that Nebraska had knowingly failed to put adequate compliance mechanisms in place despite a known substantial risk of violating Kansas's rights under the Compact and Settlement.9 He recommended that Nebraska pay Kansas $3.7 million in damages plus an additional $1.8 million in partial disgorgement, that Kansas's request for an injunction be denied, and that the accounting procedures be reformed using a 5-run formula to exclude imported water from consumption calculations. Kansas and Nebraska each filed exceptions to portions of the Special Master's report, and the Supreme Court heard argument in October 2014.10
Whether Nebraska knowingly failed to comply with the Republican River Compact and 2002 Final Settlement Stipulation during the 2005-2006 accounting period?11
Yes. The Special Master found that Nebraska failed to put adequate compliance mechanisms in place in the face of a known substantial risk that it would violate Kansas's rights.14 Nebraska's argument that it could not have anticipated unprecedented drought conditions fails, because its efforts to comply would have been inadequate absent the luckiest of circumstances.15 Nor can the State find refuge in the Compact's retrospective compliance calculation methods, because it had been warned each year leading up to the final compliance check that it had exceeded its allotment.16
The Court therefore agrees with the Master that Nebraska knowingly exposed Kansas to a substantial risk of receiving less water than it was entitled to under the Compact.17 In other words, Nebraska recklessly gambled with Kansas's rights.18
Nebraska knowingly failed to comply with the Republican River Compact and 2002 Final Settlement Stipulation during the 2005-2006 accounting period.19
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Scalia, J., And Alito, J.
Justice Thomas agrees with the conclusion that Nebraska knowingly but not deliberately breached the Compact.20 He emphasizes that ordinary contract principles govern compact disputes between sovereign States.21 The finding of knowing failure rests on Nebraska's failure to implement adequate mechanisms despite known risks.22
He parts company with the majority on the availability of disgorgement for such conduct.23 In his view, the traditional remedy for breach of a water compact has been performance through delivery of water rather than monetary awards beyond actual damages.24
Whether disgorgement of a portion of Nebraska's gains is an appropriate remedy in addition to damages for Kansas's losses?25
The law of contracts provides that a party injured by a breach is entitled to damages for its losses and to restitution of any gains the breaching party realized from the breach.26 In compact cases the Court may order disgorgement when a state has recklessly gambled with another state's rights to a scarce natural resource.27
Yes. The Special Master correctly applied the law of contracts to this interstate compact dispute.28 Interstate compacts are construed as contracts. The law of contracts provides that a party injured by a breach is entitled to damages for its losses and to restitution of any gains the breaching party realized from the breach.
The Special Master found that Kansas suffered losses as a result of Nebraska's breach and that Nebraska realized gains from its breach.29 Those findings are well supported by the record.30 The Court therefore agrees with the Special Master that Kansas is entitled to damages and that Nebraska should be required to disgorge its gains.31 Because Nebraska's benefit from its breach exceeded the $3.7 million loss Kansas suffered, the Special Master recommended that Nebraska disgorge part of its additional gain.32
Nebraska contends that disgorgement is improper because it did not act deliberately, which it argues is required for disgorgement in a private contract suit.33 But disgorgement is appropriate where one State has recklessly gambled with another State's rights to a scarce natural resource.34 This Court has said that awarding actual damages in a compact case may be inadequate to deter an upstream State from ignoring its obligations where it is advantageous to do so.35 Here, Nebraska took full advantage of its favorable geographic position.36
And because of the higher value of water on Nebraska's farmland than on Kansas's, Nebraska could take Kansas's water, pay damages, and still benefit.37 This Court's remedial authority extends to providing a remedy capable of stabilizing the Compact and deterring future breaches, and a disgorgement award appropriately does so here.38
Disgorgement of a portion of Nebraska's gains is an appropriate remedy in addition to damages for Kansas's losses.39
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Thomas, J.
Justice Scalia dissents from the disgorgement award.40 He maintains that the Compact does not authorize such relief.41 The Court today approves an award of damages and an injunction against Nebraska for its alleged violation of the Republican River Compact.42
In his view, the Compact is an agreement among the States to apportion the river's water.43 It does not create a cause of action for damages or authorize this Court to issue an injunction against one of the States.44 The Compact's dispute resolution provisions provide for the States to resolve their disputes through negotiation and, if necessary, through the RRCA.45
The Compact does not contemplate that one State may sue another in this Court for damages or injunctive relief.46
Joined by Scalia, J., And Alito, J.
Justice Thomas dissents from the disgorgement award.47 He argues that disgorgement is available, if at all, only for deliberate breaches.48 The Special Master's reliance on a novel Restatement provision lacks support in the law.49
He further contends that the amount awarded is arbitrary and not tied to any calculation of Nebraska's actual profits from the breach.50 The usual remedy for breach of a contract is damages based on the injured party's actual loss caused by the breach.51 Disgorgement is an extraordinary remedy that goes beyond a plaintiff's damages, requiring the breaching party to refund additional profits gained in the breach.52
Chief Justice Roberts concurs in the result on disgorgement but expresses general agreement with the discussion of equitable power.53 He is in general agreement with the discussion in Part II but does not believe our equitable power, though sufficient to order a remedy of partial disgorgement, permits us to alter the Accounting Procedures to which the States agreed.54 He joins Parts I and III of the Court's opinion.55
Whether Kansas is entitled to injunctive relief to prevent future violations by Nebraska?56
No. The Special Master found that Nebraska had knowingly violated the Compact and the settlement stipulation and that it was likely to continue to do so unless enjoined.59 Those findings are supported by the record.60 The Court therefore agrees with the Special Master that an injunction is necessary to prevent further violations only if the danger of recurrence is shown.61 Contrary to Kansas's contentions, the Master's partial disgorgement award is sufficient to achieve those goals.62
The flexibility inherent in equitable remedies allows the Court to order partial disgorgement if appropriate to the facts of the particular case.63 The Special Master properly took into account Nebraska's incentives, past behavior, and especially its more recent successful compliance efforts to determine that a small disgorgement award suffices.64 For related reasons, Kansas has failed to demonstrate a cognizable danger of recurrent violation necessary to obtain an injunction.65 Nebraska's new compliance measures, so long as followed, are up to the task of keeping the State within its allotment.66
And Nebraska is now on notice that if it relapses, it may again be subject to disgorgement of gains.67 That will adequately guard against Nebraska's repeating its former practices.68
Kansas is not entitled to injunctive relief to prevent future violations by Nebraska.69
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Scalia, J., And Alito, J.
Justice Thomas agrees that no injunction is warranted.70 He notes that the traditional remedy for breach of a water compact has been performance through delivery of water.71 Kansas failed to demonstrate the requisite danger of recurrent violation under ordinary equitable standards.72
We are especially reluctant to read absent terms into an interstate compact given the federalism and separation-of-powers concerns that would arise were we to rewrite an agreement among sovereign States, to which the political branches consented.73 The use of unbounded equitable power against States similarly threatens to violate principles of state sovereignty and of the separation of powers.74
Whether the Accounting Procedures in the Settlement should be reformed to exclude charges against Nebraska for use of imported water from outside the Republican River Basin?75
The Court may modify a technical agreement to correct material errors in the way it operates and thus align it with the compacting States' intended apportionment.76 This is especially appropriate when necessary to prevent serious inaccuracies from distorting the States' intended apportionment of interstate waters or to avert an outright breach of the Compact.77
Yes. The Special Master carefully considered the competing models proposed by the parties and concluded that the RRCA Groundwater Model is the most accurate and reliable.78 That model has been peer-reviewed and is widely accepted in the scientific community.79 It accounts for the complex hydrology of the Basin and provides a reasonable basis for calculating the effects of groundwater pumping on streamflow.80
The Master agreed and recommended modifying the Procedures by adopting an approach that the parties call the 5-run formula, to ensure that Nebraska's consumption of Platte River water will not count toward its Compact allotment.81 The Compact, recall, apportions the virgin water supply of the Republican River and its tributaries—nothing less, but also nothing more.82 The States thus agreed not to count water imported from outside the Republican River Basin.83 But in the very same provision, they agreed to calculate the use of imported water using the RRCA Accounting Procedures and the RRCA Groundwater Model.84
The Procedures and Model founder in performing that task in dry conditions.85 They treat Nebraska's use of imported water as if it were use of Basin water.86 The Master specifically determined, and our review of the testimony from the Special Master proceedings confirms, that the parties did not know the Accounting Procedures would have that effect.87 The States intended the Procedures to count only consumption of the Basin's own water supply and correlatively to exclude use of water from the Platte.
In light of all the above, the Master's proposed solution is the best one possible.88 The 5-run formula that he recommends conforms the Procedures to both the Compact and the Settlement by excluding imported water from the calculation of each State's consumption.89
The Accounting Procedures in the Settlement should be reformed to exclude charges against Nebraska for use of imported water from outside the Republican River Basin.90
Related opinions on this issue
Chief Justice Roberts dissents from the reformation of the Accounting Procedures.91 He states that he does not believe our equitable power, though sufficient to order a remedy of partial disgorgement, permits us to alter the Accounting Procedures to which the States agreed.92 He joins Parts I and III of the Court's opinion.
He is in general agreement with the discussion in Part II but does not believe our equitable power permits us to alter the Accounting Procedures.93 He therefore joins Part III of Justice Thomas's opinion.
Joined by Scalia, J., And Alito, J.
Justice Thomas dissents from the reformation of the Accounting Procedures.94 He argues that the remedy of reformation is available only when the parties reach an agreement but then fail to express it correctly in the writing.95 Here the parties made no mistake in reducing their agreement to writing.96
He contends that the appropriate equitable remedy, if any, would be rescission rather than reformation.97 The majority's new doctrine of technical agreement correction lacks support in precedent.98 Reformation is thus available only when the parties reach an agreement but then fail to express it correctly in the writing.99
If the parties make a written agreement that they would not otherwise have made because of a mistake other than one as to expression, the court will not reform a writing to reflect the agreement that it thinks they would have made.100
Joined by Thomas, J., And Alito, J.
Justice Scalia joins Justice Thomas's opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part, including the dissent from reformation of the Accounting Procedures.101 He writes separately to note that modern Restatements are of questionable value and must be used with caution.102 The object of the original Restatements was to present an orderly statement of the general common law.103
Over time, the Restatements' authors have abandoned the mission of describing the law and have chosen instead to set forth their aspirations for what the law ought to be.104 Section 39 of the Third Restatement of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment is illustrative.105