42 Cal. Rptr. 2d 286, 36 Cal. App. 4th 376 (1995)
In July 1989, California lettuce grower and distributor KGM Harvesting Company entered into an agreement with Ohio lettuce broker Fresh Network for the sale and purchase of lettuce.1 By May 1991, the terms required KGM to sell Fresh Network 14 loads of lettuce each week at 9 cents per pound, with each load consisting of 40 bins weighing 1,000 to 1,200 pounds.2
Fresh Network sold all lettuce received from KGM to Castellini Company on a cost-plus basis, which in turn sold it to Club Chef on a similar basis for chopping and shredding for fast food chains including Burger King, Taco Bell, and Pizza Hut.3 KGM had numerous other customers, including its subsidiaries Coronet East and West that supplied McDonald's.4
In May and June 1991, when the price of lettuce rose dramatically, KGM refused to supply Fresh Network at the contract price of 9 cents per pound and instead sold the lettuce to others at a profit of between $800,000 and $1.1 million.5 Fresh Network purchased substitute lettuce on the open market to fulfill its obligations to Castellini Company, incurring extra costs of which all but $70,000 were passed on through the chain to Club Chef and its fast food customers.6
In July 1991, both parties filed complaints under the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act.7 KGM sought $233,000 for unpaid invoices while Fresh Network sought approximately $700,000 for the difference between the cost of replacement lettuce and the contract price.8 KGM subsequently filed suit for the invoice balance and Fresh Network cross-complained for its additional cover costs.9
At trial, the parties stipulated to a directed verdict for KGM on its $233,000 claim.10 The jury awarded Fresh Network $655,960.22 representing the difference between the contract price and the cost of cover purchases in May and June 1991, resulting after offset in a net judgment of $422,960.22.11
The trial court awarded prejudgment interest commencing 30 days before trial.12 Fresh Network cross-appealed the interest commencement date.13
Whether a buyer who covers by purchasing substitute goods is entitled to recover the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price even if it passed on most additional costs to third parties?14
Under California Uniform Commercial Code section 2712, a buyer may cover by making in good faith and without unreasonable delay any reasonable purchase of goods in substitution for those due from the seller.15 Such a buyer may recover from the seller as damages the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price.16 This measure gives the buyer the benefit of its bargain.17
Yes. Fresh Network covered by purchasing substitute lettuce on the open market after KGM refused to deliver at the contract price of nine cents per pound in May and June 1991.18 The jury found that Fresh Network acted in good faith without unreasonable delay and awarded the contract-cover differential.19 Although Fresh Network passed on all but $70,000 of its extra costs to Castellini Company and further down the chain, section 2712 does not require reduction of cover damages for amounts passed on to third parties because the formula places the buyer in the identical economic position performance would have achieved.20
Fresh Network is entitled to recover the full difference between the cost of cover and the contract price without reduction for costs passed on to third parties.21
Whether the buyer was entitled to prejudgment interest from August 1, 1991 rather than from 30 days prior to trial?22
Under Civil Code section 3287, subdivision (a), every person who is entitled to recover damages that are fixed or capable of being made fixed by calculation, and whose right to recover vests upon a particular day, is entitled to recover interest from that day.23
Yes. Fresh Network supplied seller with a detailed schedule in its July 26, 1991 PACA complaint listing suppliers, purchase order numbers, bin numbers, dates, and prices that allowed computation of the cover damages.24 The minor 5.5 percent error later corrected by Fresh Network's controller did not render the damages indeterminate because the data furnished permitted ready calculation.25 Seller never disputed the amounts or method of calculation, only liability.26
Therefore, prejudgment interest runs from August 1, 1991, the date the information was provided.27
Fresh Network is entitled to prejudgment interest from August 1, 1991 rather than from 30 days prior to trial.28