458 Mich. 582, 581 N.W.2d 272 (1998)
On June 25, 1988, Kimberly Marie Klinke, the twenty-three-year-old daughter of the plaintiff, died in a one-car rollover accident when the left front tire of her Dodge Colt collapsed while she was traveling at highway speeds.1 Emergency workers found her wearing her lap belt, but with the shoulder harness positioned behind her and unused.2
The plaintiff filed a products liability suit against Mitsubishi Motors Corporation, the manufacturer of the vehicle, as well as the distributor and the dealership that sold the car.3 The complaint alleged defects in the design of the seat belt and defective manufacture of the left front steering knuckle.4 The trial court granted summary disposition to Mitsubishi on the seat belt design claim but allowed the defective manufacture claim to proceed to trial.5
At trial, the parties presented conflicting expert testimony regarding the steering knuckle.6 The plaintiff's expert identified small fractures in the metal, supporting the theory that the knuckle collapsed first and caused the rollover.7 Defense experts countered that the knuckle failed as a consequence of the rollover forces and that the accident resulted from the driver's sudden correction of the vehicle's direction.8 Defense experts further testified that proper use of the shoulder harness would have prevented the decedent's head injury.9
The jury returned a verdict of $5,104,000 against Mitsubishi but determined that the decedent was ninety percent negligent due to her failure to properly use the seat belt.10 The trial judge applied the five-percent statutory cap on comparative negligence for nonuse of a seat belt and entered judgment for the plaintiff in the amount of $4,848,800.11
The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court's application of the five-percent cap, holding that the cap did not apply in products liability actions, and the Supreme Court granted leave to appeal.12
Whether the Michigan Vehicle Code's seat belt statute applies in a products liability action against an automobile manufacturer?13
The seat belt statute in the Michigan Vehicle Code caps reduction in damages for nonuse of a seat belt at five percent.14 The statute is limited by the title of the code to actions involving the civil liability of owners and operators of vehicles.15 The Title-Object Clause precludes its application to products liability actions against manufacturers.16 Such actions are instead governed by the products liability statute providing for full comparative negligence reduction.17
No. This case is a products liability action brought against the manufacturer Mitsubishi Motors Corporation for the defective manufacture of the left front steering knuckle in the decedent's Dodge Colt.
The action does not involve the civil liability of owners or operators of a vehicle.18 The seat belt statute's five-percent cap is confined to the title of the Michigan Vehicle Code, which addresses only the liability of owners and operators.19
Application of the cap would affect the liability of the manufacturer in a manner not authorized by the code's title, violating constitutional principles under the Title-Object Clause.20 Therefore, the products liability statute governs, allowing the full ninety percent reduction for the decedent's comparative negligence.21
The Michigan Vehicle Code's seat belt statute does not apply in this products liability action against the automobile manufacturer.22
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Mallett, C.j., And Brickley, J.
Justice Boyle concurred in the result but wrote separately to explain her rationale.23 The safety belt law by its express terms limits its application to cases arising out of the ownership, maintenance, or operation of a motor vehicle.24 This phrase is a term of art drawn from the no-fault act.25 The statute therefore does not extend to products liability actions for defects in design and manufacture of an automobile.26
The purported distinction between liability and damages is unpersuasive.27 The law attaches consequences to the failure to wear a safety belt only where injuries arise out of the ownership, maintenance, or operation of a motor vehicle.28 A products liability case falls outside the scope of the statute.29
Joined by Cavanagh, J.
Justice Kelly dissented.30 She contended that the Title-Object Clause does not prohibit application of the seat belt statute in products liability cases.31 The statute affects rather than creates liability for manufacturers.32 At the time of its enactment, the statute would have limited rather than expanded manufacturer liability.33
The Legislature intended the penalty to apply in any action involving a motor vehicle accident.34 The state of the law at the time of enactment controls the analysis rather than later developments in comparative negligence doctrine.35 The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the statute does not apply to products liability actions.36