104 F. Supp. 2d 1332 (2000)
William S. Klocek brings suit against Gateway, Inc. and Hewlett-Packard, Inc. on claims arising from purchases of a Gateway computer and a Hewlett-Packard scanner.1 This matter comes before the Court on the Motion to Dismiss which Gateway filed November 22, 1999 and Defendant Hewlett-Packard, Inc.’s Motion To Dismiss, Or In The Alternative For Stay Of Proceedings filed December 22, 1999, among other motions.2
Plaintiff brings individual and class action claims against Gateway, alleging that it induced him and other consumers to purchase computers and special support packages by making false promises of technical support.3 Individually, plaintiff also claims breach of contract and breach of warranty, in that Gateway breached warranties that its computer would be compatible with standard peripherals and standard internet services.4 Whenever it sells a computer, Gateway includes a copy of the Standard Terms and Conditions Agreement in the box which contains the computer battery power cables and instruction manuals.5 At the top of the first page, the Standard Terms include a notice that by keeping the Gateway 2000 computer system beyond five days after the date of delivery, the customer accepts the Terms and Conditions, which contain an arbitration clause providing that any dispute shall be settled exclusively and finally by arbitration in Chicago, Illinois before a sole arbitrator under the Rules of Conciliation and Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce.6
Plaintiff brings individual and class action claims against Hewlett-Packard, claiming that it breached a duty to warn consumers that its products are incompatible with Gateway computers.7 In the opening paragraph of the complaint, plaintiff alleges generally that defendants have caused him personal damages in excess of $350,000 and caused class damages exceeding $350,000.8 At the end of the complaint, plaintiff itemizes the damages as follows: $350,000 in actual damages against Gateway and $24,000 plus unitemized punitive damages against each defendant.9
Plaintiff filed the motion to certify a class on October 29, 1999.10 Gateway filed its motion to dismiss on November 22, 1999.11 Hewlett-Packard filed its motion on December 22, 1999.12 Plaintiff filed the motion for sanctions on December 3, 1999, the motion for a writ of certiorari on December 6, 1999, and the motion for verification on January 25, 2000.13 The court resolves these motions in its memorandum and order.14
Whether Gateway's motion to dismiss should be granted on the ground that the plaintiff must arbitrate his claims under the Standard Terms and Conditions Agreement shipped with the computer?15
Under the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. §§ 3 and 4, a court must determine whether the parties formed a written agreement to arbitrate by applying ordinary state contract law principles of formation.16 In Kansas and Missouri the UCC § 2-207 governs, treating additional terms in an acceptance or confirmation as proposals that do not become part of the contract absent express assent by a non-merchant buyer.17
No. The court first determines that the record fails to establish the state whose law governs contract formation because Gateway shipped the computer but provides no details on where the last act occurred.18 Under either Kansas or Missouri law the UCC applies to the sale of goods.19 The Standard Terms arrived inside the box after the sale transaction was completed by payment and delivery, making them a proposal for additional terms under § 2-207 rather than part of the original contract.20 Plaintiff is a consumer, not a merchant, so the arbitration clause requires his express assent, which keeping the computer for five days does not supply because Gateway never informed him at the time of sale that acceptance was conditioned on the Standard Terms.21
Gateway's motion to dismiss is overruled because no enforceable arbitration agreement was formed.22
Whether Hewlett-Packard's motion to dismiss or stay should be granted for lack of subject matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a)?23
Federal courts possess limited jurisdiction.24 They may not proceed unless the plaintiff establishes that the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000 exclusive of interest and costs.25 When the face of the complaint shows to a legal certainty that the plaintiff cannot recover the jurisdictional amount against Hewlett-Packard, dismissal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction is required.26
Yes. Plaintiff itemizes only $24,000 in actual damages plus unitemized punitive damages against Hewlett-Packard while alleging $350,000 in actual damages and millions in punitive damages against Gateway alone.27 No facts are pleaded that would support an award of $75,000 or more against Hewlett-Packard for failure to warn of scanner incompatibility.28 Plaintiff cannot aggregate class claims or claims against other defendants to satisfy the amount-in-controversy requirement for the claim against Hewlett-Packard.29
Hewlett-Packard's motion to dismiss is sustained for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.30
Whether the plaintiff's motion to certify a class should be granted?31
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a)(4) requires that the representative party fairly and adequately protect the interests of the class.32 Due process demands stringent application of this requirement because absent class members are bound by the judgment.33 A pro se litigant ordinarily lacks the legal training and expertise necessary to protect class interests.34
No. Plaintiff appears pro se and therefore cannot serve as an adequate class representative.35 A layperson does not possess the legal training required to protect the interests of absent class members who would be bound by any judgment.36 In addition, a pro se plaintiff may not represent other parties in federal court under 28 U.S.C. § 1654.37
The motion to certify a class is overruled.38
Whether the plaintiff's motion for a writ of certiorari to obtain records from a prior state court case should be granted?39
A federal district court possesses no appellate jurisdiction over state trial courts.40 Therefore it lacks authority to issue a writ of certiorari directing a state court to produce transcripts or records.41 Such requests are governed by the procedures of the court that originally created the records.42
The motion for a writ of certiorari is overruled.45
Whether the plaintiff's motions for sanctions, expenses and punitives and for verification should be granted?46
No. Plaintiff identifies no legal or factual basis supporting sanctions against Gateway's counsel or requiring verification that counsel notified other courts of an ethical complaint.49 The court finds no merit in either request.50 Plaintiff alleges deficiencies in citation to legal authorities but provides no specific examples warranting sanctions.51 The request for verification orders lacks any legal foundation under applicable rules or ethical standards.
The motions for sanctions and for verification are overruled.52