549 U.S. 437 (2007)
After the 2000 census, Colorado gained an additional Representative in Congress.1 When the state legislature could not redraw the congressional districts, a state court performed the redistricting in Beauprez v. Avalos.2 The legislature later passed its own redistricting plan in 2003, which the governor signed into law as Colo. Rev. Stat. Ann. §2–1–101.3
Colorado’s attorney general filed an original action in the Colorado Supreme Court to enjoin the secretary of state from implementing the 2003 plan, relying on Article V, §44, of the Colorado Constitution, which limits redistricting to once per census.4 The Colorado General Assembly intervened to defend the plan.5 The Colorado Supreme Court granted the injunction in People ex rel. Salazar v. Davidson and held that the court-drawn districts must remain in effect until the next census.6
Three days after the Salazar decision, four Colorado citizens who had not participated in the prior litigation filed suit in federal district court.7 They alleged that Article V, §44, as interpreted in Salazar, violated the Elections Clause by depriving the state legislature of its responsibility to draw congressional districts.8 The district court initially dismissed the suit under the Rooker-Feldman doctrine, but the Supreme Court vacated and remanded.9 On remand, the district court held that the plaintiffs had standing but dismissed on issue preclusion grounds because the plaintiffs stood in privity with the losing parties in Salazar; a concurring judge concluded the plaintiffs lacked standing.10 The plaintiffs appealed.11
Whether four Colorado voters who were not parties to prior state-court litigation have standing to bring a federal claim alleging that a provision of the Colorado Constitution, as interpreted by the Colorado Supreme Court, violates the Elections Clause?12
Article III limits the jurisdiction of federal courts to cases and controversies. Standing requires a plaintiff to demonstrate injury in fact, causation, and redressability.13 A plaintiff raising only a generally available grievance about government does not state an Article III case or controversy. Such a plaintiff claims only harm to his and every citizen’s interest in proper application of the Constitution and laws. He seeks relief that no more directly and tangibly benefits him than it does the public at large.14
No. The four Colorado citizens filed suit three days after the Salazar decision.15 They allege only that Article V, §44 of the Colorado Constitution as interpreted in Salazar violated the Elections Clause by depriving the state legislature of its responsibility to draw congressional districts.16 This alleged injury is precisely the kind of undifferentiated, generalized grievance about the conduct of government that the Court has refused to countenance in the past.17 The plaintiffs assert no particularized stake in the litigation, unlike the plaintiffs in voting rights cases such as Baker v. Carr.18
The four Colorado voters lack standing to bring their Elections Clause claim.19