360 U.S. 45 (1959)
This controversy started in a Federal District Court.1 Appellant, a Negro citizen of North Carolina, sued to have the literacy test for voters prescribed by that State declared unconstitutional and void.2 A three-judge court was convened.3 That court stayed its action, retaining jurisdiction for a reasonable time to enable appellant to exhaust her administrative remedies and obtain from the state courts an interpretation of the statute in light of the State Constitution.4
Appellant applied for registration as a voter.5 Her registration was denied by the registrar because she refused to submit to a literacy test as required by the North Carolina statute.6 She appealed to the County Board of Elections.7 On the de novo hearing before that Board appellant again refused to take the literacy test and she was again denied registration for that reason.8 She appealed to the Superior Court which sustained the Board against the claim that the requirement of the literacy test violated the Fourteenth, Fifteenth, and Seventeenth Amendments of the Federal Constitution.9 Preserving her federal question, she appealed to the North Carolina Supreme Court which affirmed the lower court.10
The literacy test is a part of § 4 of Art. VI of the North Carolina Constitution.11 That test is contained in the first sentence of § 4.12 The second sentence contains a so-called grandfather clause.13 The North Carolina Supreme Court held that a 1945 amendment to Article VI freed it of the indivisibility clause.14 In 1957 the Legislature rewrote General Statutes § 163-28.15 The amendment requires that every person presenting himself for registration shall be able to read and write any section of the Constitution of North Carolina in the English language.16 It repealed all laws and clauses of laws in conflict with the Act.17 The federal three-judge court ruled that this 1957 amendment eliminated the grandfather clause from the statute.18
There is a provision in the General Statutes for permanent registration in some counties.19 The issue of discrimination in the actual operation of the ballot laws of North Carolina has not been framed in the issues presented for the state court litigation.20
Whether the 1957 North Carolina legislation eliminated the grandfather clause from the voter literacy requirement?21
Yes. The North Carolina Supreme Court held that a 1945 amendment to Article VI freed it of its indivisibility clause that had previously linked the literacy test and grandfather clause.24 In 1957 the Legislature rewrote General Statutes § 163-28. The new statute requires that every person presenting himself for registration shall be able to read and write any section of the Constitution of North Carolina in the English language.25 The amendment repealed all laws and clauses of laws in conflict with the Act.26 The federal three-judge court ruled that this 1957 amendment eliminated the grandfather clause from the statute.
The Attorney General of North Carolina agrees that the grandfather clause contained in Art. VI is in conflict with the Fifteenth Amendment.27 Under that view Art. VI would impose the same literacy test as that imposed by the 1957 statute and neither would be linked with the grandfather clause which, though present in print, is separable from the rest and void.28
The 1957 North Carolina legislation eliminated the grandfather clause from the voter literacy requirement.29
Whether a State may consistently with the Fourteenth and Seventeenth Amendments apply a literacy test to all voters irrespective of race or color?30
The States have long been held to have broad powers to determine the conditions under which the right of suffrage may be exercised, absent, of course the discrimination which the Constitution condemns. The ability to read and write has some relation to standards designed to promote intelligent use of the ballot.31
Yes. The Court in Guinn v. United States disposed of the question in a few words.32 It noted that the establishment of the literacy test was but the exercise by the State of a lawful power vested in it not subject to our supervision, and indeed, its validity is admitted.33 Residence requirements, age, previous criminal record (Davis v. Beason, 133 U. S. 333, 345-347) are obvious examples indicating factors which a State may take into consideration in determining the qualifications of voters.34 The ability to read and write likewise has some relation to standards designed to promote intelligent use of the ballot.35
Literacy and illiteracy are neutral on race, creed, color, and sex, as reports around the world show.36 Yet in our society where newspapers, periodicals, books, and other printed matter canvass and debate campaign issues, a State might conclude that only those who are literate should exercise the franchise.37 Of course a literacy test, fair on its face, may be employed to perpetuate that discrimination which the Fifteenth Amendment was designed to uproot.38 No such influence is charged here.39 The present requirement, applicable to members of all races, is that the prospective voter be able to read and write any section of the Constitution of North Carolina in the English language.40 That seems to us to be one fair way of determining whether a person is literate, not a calculated scheme to lay springes for the citizen.41
A State may consistently with the Fourteenth and Seventeenth Amendments apply a literacy test to all voters irrespective of race or color.42